who owns attorney work product

Who Owns Lawyers' Work Product? The attorney-client privilege clearly belongs to the client alone, although the client's lawyers must assert the privilege when they can. In contrast lawyers have at least some ownership interest in their work product – but few courts have applied that abstract principle to real-life situations.

Full Answer

Can a lawyer create work product?

Jan 22, 2014 · Who Owns Lawyers' Work Product? The attorney-client privilege clearly belongs to the client alone, although the client's lawyers must assert the privilege when they can. In contrast lawyers have at least some ownership interest in their work product – but few courts have applied that abstract principle to real-life situations. In Gruss v.

Who owns your work product?

Jun 23, 2017 · Friday, June 23, 2017. California has codified the attorney work product doctrine in Section 2018.030 of the California Code of Civil Procedure. …

Do lawyers have ownership of their work?

The statute is silent on who controls work product and thus may be in a position to object or waive discovery with respect to work product. Because it is the attorney's work product that is protected, it would be reasonable to assume that it is the attorney who holds the "privilege".

Who has the privilege of work product?

Dec 31, 2005 · Dec 31, 2005 2006 U. Ill. L. Rev. 127 Download. This article explores the issue of who has, or who should have, the power to control or waive the work-product privilege: the attorney or the client. The Restatement of the Law Governing Lawyers takes the posi-tion that work-product privilege is entirely subject to client control. Sev-eral American jurisdictions have …

Who owns the work product?

Under the law, the general rule is that the copyright in and to the work product of an individual employee or independent contractor is owned by that individual unless an exception applies. The “Work for Hire” doctrine is an exception to such rule.Nov 2, 2021

Does attorney work product belong to the client California?

As one court noted, "California has two conflicting absolutes, the absolute right of a client to his attorney's work product, and the absolute right of an attorney to protect his or her impressions, conclusions, opinions, and legal research or theories from disclosure." (Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer, Inc.Feb 27, 2012

Is work product a privilege?

Generally, work product is privileged, meaning it is exempt from discovery. However, there are exceptions. Work product is divided into two categories: ordinary and opinion.

What is the difference between attorney-client privilege and work product?

According to the Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute, the “attorney-client privilege refers to a legal privilege that works to keep confidential communications between an attorney and his or her client secret.” On the other hand, the Cornell Law School Legal Information Institute proclaims “the work product ...Mar 17, 2020

Who owns a client file?

Categories of document original documents sent to the firm by the client will continue to belong to the client, except where title was intended to pass to the firm. documents sent or received by the firm as the agent of the client belong to the client.

Who is the exclusive holder of the word product doctrine?

Even though the attorney client privilege and the work product doctrine are similar in many ways, the holders of these privileges are distinct. Rather than the client, the attorney is the holder of work product protection.

Are communications between attorneys work product?

This article focuses on the attorney work-product doctrine as applied by California state courts and how it differs from attorney-client privilege. Communications between attorney and client, to include necessary third parties, are protected by the attorney- client privilege under Evidence Code section 952.

What is protected by the work-product doctrine?

Attorney work product privilege permits attorneys to withhold from production documents and other tangible things prepared in anticipation of litigation by or for another party or its representative.

What kind of work falls under the work product rule?

A legal doctrine that provides that certain materials prepared by an attorney who is acting on behalf of his or her client during preparation for litigation are privileged from discovery by the attorney for the opposition party.

What is the meaning of work product?

Legal Definition of work product : the set of materials (as notes), mental impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal theories developed by or for an attorney in anticipation of litigation or for trial.

Is attorney work product hyphenated?

Often stated as the work-product doctrine1 or even the work-product rule. Further, some present the privilege using a hyphen, as in attorney-work product.

Are client notes work product?

In a recent article in California Trusts and Estates Quarterly, attorneys Ciarán O'Sullivan and Andrew Verriere opine that an estate planner's notes and other internal file materials likely qualify as work product under the California Code of Civil Procedure such that a court would decline to compel their production.Feb 28, 2022

What is the work product doctrine in California?

California has codified the attorney work product doctrine in Section 2018.030 of the California Code of Civil Procedure. That statute establishes two categories of protected work product. Under subdivision (a), a "writing that reflects an attorney’s impressions, conclusions, opinions, or legal research or theories is not discoverable ...

What does "attorney" mean in Section 2018.030?

Nonetheless, the Court of Appeal found that construing "attorney" in Section 2018.030 to mean the law firm, not the individual attorney, was consistent with the "purpose and legislative intent, as well as the public policy to be served by the attorney work product privilege". The Court of Appeal concluded by emphasizing the "narrowness ...

Is the attorney's work product protected?

The statute is silent on who controls work product and thus may be in a position to object or waive discovery with respect to work product. Because it is the attorney's work product that is protected, it would be reasonable to assume that it is the attorney who holds the "privilege".

What happens if you create something that you are paid?

If your creation relates to the work for which you are paid, your employer may argue that it owns that work. If you have an employment agreement, find out whether it addresses ownership of employee work. A lawyer can help you figure out whether you have an argument that you should own something you created.

What is an independent contractor?

An independent contractor, by comparison, is in business for him- or herself, who is not managed or directed by the hiring firm, often works on a project basis, and determines the hours, location, and means of completing the job independently.

How many types of works for hire are there?

Works for Hire. There are nine types of works for hire. If you create one of these things as an independent contractor, it will belong to the firm that hired you to create it if you have entered into a written agreement to that effect. If you don’t have a written agreement, you will own the work.

What is a paycheck?

Your paycheck is intended to cover the work you are paid to do, including your creative work and innovations. This rule applies to all work that falls within your job description, created at least in part for your employer, using your employer’s facilities, and so on.

What rights do you have to work on your job?

If you are an employee, the general rule is that all of the work you do on the job – and the rights to that work, such as copyright, the right to license or sell it, and so on -- belong to your employer.

Do you retain copyright if you are hired as an independent contractor?

If you are hired as an independent contractor to create something that doesn’t fit within a work-for-hire category, you will retain the copyright unless you sign a written agreement assigning some or all of your rights over to the hiring firm. You might decide to sign over your copyright entirely.

Do employees have rights to work?

Generally, employees have very few (if any) rights to work they create on their employer’s dime. You are an employee if your employer has the right to dictate and control how you do your work, including the time, place, and methods by which you do your job.

What is discoverable under CRCP 26?

Under CRCP 26, information prepared in anticipation of litigation is discoverable “only upon showing that the party seeking discovery has substantial need of the materials.” 37 Cardenas v. Jerath provides guidance on what “substantial need” a party seeking materials must demonstrate to obtain work product that would normally be protected. 38 The Colorado Supreme Court in Cardenas recognized that “a party is unable without undue hardship to obtain the substantial equivalent of the materials by other means when the requested materials are not available by any other source.” 39 Demonstrating substantial hardship requires the moving party to show that “the facts contained in the requested documents are essential elements of the requesting party’s prima facie case.” 40

What is the work product doctrine?

1 In Hickman, the Court aimed to balance the “competing interests” of the privacy of a lawyer’s work and public policy encouraging reasonable and necessary inquiries. 2 Hickman concerned the defense of the owners of a sunken tugboat following the drowning of five of its nine crew members while they were operating the tugboat to assist a car float across the Delaware River. A month after the accident, a public hearing was held before the US Steamboat Inspectors, at which the four survivors were examined. Three weeks later, the survivors were privately interviewed by a lawyer retained in anticipation of litigation against the tugboat owners. While four of the five deceased crew members’ estates settled before litigation, the fifth claimant brought a lawsuit eight months after the interviews were conducted.

What is the Hawkins rule?

The Hawkins Court contemplated the challenges of establishing a bright-line rule to mark the decision between ordinary business activity and conduct taking place in anticipation of litigation .

What is attorney client privilege?

The attorney-client privilege and the work product doctrine are sometimes confused. The attorney-client privilege is similar to, yet distinct from, the work product doctrine, and the differences are important. The attorney-client privilege aims to protect confidential communications between the attorney and the client for the purpose ...

What amendments clarified the scope of discovery regarding expert witness-related communications and draft reports?

The 2015 amendments to the Colorado Rules of Civil Procedure clarified the scope of discovery regarding expert witness-related communications and draft reports. 59 Previously, the rules did not provide express protections for draft reports of and communications with experts.

Does the work product doctrine apply to wrongful conduct?

The work product doctrine does not apply to documents that may establish wrongful conduct, which are carved out by the crime-fraud exception. Interestingly, the earliest Colorado decision to address the crime-fraud exception to the work product doctrine came before Hawkins explicitly established the doctrine itself. In A v. District Court, the Colorado Supreme Court considered whether documents prepared by counsel for specific civil litigation were protected from discovery under the work product doctrine in grand jury proceedings. 49 The Court noted that the nature of civil and grand jury proceedings was vastly different, and the alignment of parties in such proceedings was not similar. 50 Based on this, the Court held that “the civil litigation in which the work-product was gathered is not so closely related to the grand jury investigation as to require the application of the work-product exemption.” 51

Does work product shield underlying facts from discovery?

The Court explained that work product would not shield underlying facts from discovery. Instead, the discovery of underlying facts contained within work product could only be had in certain limited circumstances, and the party seeking such discovery must carry the burden to demonstrate production: