how does a state attorney decide to take a case

by Ophelia Turcotte 6 min read

In broad terms, the decisions a lawyer makes in a case are related to strategy or tactics, or technical questions related to procedure. These decisions are the lawyer’s because they usually do not “materially affect” the client’s interests. See Model Rule 1.2.

A trial may take place, and the State's Attorney must prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the suspect committed the crime. Either a judge or a jury may decide the verdict on how well the State's Attorney proved the case.

Full Answer

What happens at a state's attorney trial?

There are a number of reasons why an attorney might decide against taking your case, and there may be steps you can take to make your case more attractive to a lawyer. Why a Personal Injury Lawyer Might Refuse to Take Your Case It's Too Late to Sue. All personal injury cases are subject to lawsuit-filing deadlines set by the statute of ...

How does a lawyer make a decision for a defendant?

Either a judge or a jury may decide the verdict on how well the State's Attorney proved the case. During the trial, the State's Attorney may make opening and closing statements, offer evidence, question witnesses and challenge the defense attorney's legal actions. If the defendant is found guilty, the State's Attorney recommends a sentence for the judge to determine and may have …

How does the prosecutor present the case first in court?

At the guilt phase of the trial, the defense attorney chose strategically to concede that his client committed the crimes but argued that his client was incapable of having the state of mind necessary for first-degree murder. (The strategy was to argue that the man had a "mental incapacity" that prevented him from forming specific intent.)

How is a verdict decided in a criminal case?

How does an attorney know that YOU have a GOOD case? The answer is by meeting with you. The answer is by getting your medical records. The answer is my reviewing your records. The answer is by having a medical expert review your records. Only then do we know for sure whether you have a valid case.

image

Why do prosecutors sometimes choose not to prosecute criminal cases?

No likelihood of success. Prosecutors may decline to press charges because they think it unlikely that a conviction will result. No matter what the prosecutor's personal feelings about the case, the prosecutor needs legally admissible evidence sufficient to prove the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.

Why would a state attorney call me?

The DA is required to call you under the Victim Bill of Rights because this is a domestic violence case. They could get in trouble if they did not do so. They have to send you a victim impact statement, get your position on the case, find out...May 15, 2012

What test should the prosecutor use to determine whether a prosecution should be instituted or not?

When considering whether or not it will be in the public interest to prosecute, the prosecutor should consider factors such as the nature and seriousness of the offence, the interests of the victim and the broader community, and the circumstances of the offender.

How do you win a court case?

FOUR THINGS TO REMEMBER TO WIN A COURT CASETell the Court Everything That It Wants to Know. ... Know the Facts and Questions of Law. ... Present Your Case Convincingly. ... Avoid Lengthy Unreasonable Arguments & Tiresome Cross Examination.

What is exculpatory evidence?

Evidence, such as a statement, tending to excuse, justify, or absolve the alleged fault or guilt of a defendant.

What does a state advocate do?

A state advocate is someone who has been admitted as an advocate of a High Court. He/she acts as a “public prosecutor” in a High Court. A state advocate's work is also done in court, although more preparation and research on cases is necessary.

On what basis will the state decide to institute a prosecution in this case?

The principal criterion is whether there is sufficient evidence that a crime has been committed and whether there is a reasonable prospect of a successful prosecution.

On what basis will the state decide to institute a prosecution?

The decision regarding the court in which to prosecute an accused is determined by the complexity and seriousness of an offence, and the need for the Prosecuting Authority to guard against making decisions that will bring the law into disrepute.

How does the DPP decide to prosecute?

In more serious crimes (indictable offenses), the decision is made by the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP). The decision about whether to prosecute is based primarily on whether or not there is enough evidence to prove in court, beyond a reasonable doubt, that a crime was committed by the suspect.

Can you fight a case without lawyer?

Yes. You have the right to fight your own cases without engaging any advocate. It is not necessary that you must engage an advocate to fight your case in a court. A party in person is allowed to fight his own case in the court.Jul 9, 2015

What is the best color for a defendant to wear to court?

The best color to wear to court is probably navy blue or dark gray. These colors suggest seriousness. At the same time, they do not come with the negative connotations that are often associated with the color black (for instance, some people associate black with evil, coldness, and darkness).

How do I talk to a judge without a lawyer?

To speak to the judge on your case, you must file a written motion with the court. You cannot write the judge a personal letter or email, and you cannot speak to the judge unless you are in a hearing.Dec 4, 2020

How are state attorneys elected?

In general, State's Attorneys are elected by the people they represent. Their duties are spelled out in the laws of the local governments they represent, and they're held accountable by the voters for how well they do their jobs and how well their performance matches up with the local politics of the area. But a State's Attorney hardly ever does ...

What is an assistant state attorney?

Assistant State's Attorneys, also known as Deputy State's Attorneys,are the ones who actually appear in court, file the legal briefs and interview witnesses. The State's Attorney, on the other hand, is in charge of policy, staffing and running the office, and making decisions about certain high-profile cases. Advertisement.

What is a prosecutor?

A State's Attorney is the most common term for a prosecutor, someone who represents the people in criminal and civil legal matters. But while the most iconic image of a State's Attorney is ...

What is the job of a criminal prosecutor?

Criminal prosecutions are the chief duty of most State's Attorney offices. In many states, such as Michigan, criminal prosecutions follow a predetermined series of steps [source: Prosecuting Attorneys Association of Michigan ]. First, police file a warrant or charging request with the State's Attorney following an investigation.

How do police arrest a suspect?

First, police file a warrant or charging request with the State's Attorney following an investigation. Attorneys review the request and may decide to issue a warrant, which allows the police to arrest the suspect. An arraignment in court follows, at which the suspect is formally charged with a crime and enters a plea.

What is an arraignment in court?

An arraignment in court follows, at which the suspect is formally charged with a crime and enters a plea. Depending on the type and severity of a crime, there can be several pretrial hearings. At some point during these hearings, a plea bargain may be offered to induce the suspect to enter a guilty plea. Advertisement.

How many judicial districts does the US have?

One U.S. Attorney is assigned to each of 93 federal judicial districts around the country and is the top law enforcement official for the federal government in those districts. From there, the attorney will prosecute criminal cases, represent the federal government and collect debts owed to the federal government.

What is the right to know before making a decision?

Before making an important decision, a defendant is entitled to know what alternatives are reasonably available and, as far as can be predicted, the likely consequences of each. For example, assume that the defendant is charged with assault with a deadly weapon. The defense attorney tells the defendant, "The prosecutor is willing to accept a guilty plea to simple assault and recommend a sentence of six months in county jail and a fine of $500. The decision is yours—what do you want to do?"

Can a lawyer withdraw from a case?

Occasionally, lawyers and defendants have such strongly opposing views that the lawyer cannot effectively carry out the defendant's desired strategy. In such a situation, the attorney may seek to withdraw as the defendant's counsel, or the defendant may seek to have the attorney replaced. Whether this will be permitted in either case depends on whether the prosecutor will be prejudiced or the proceedings will be unnecessarily delayed or disrupted.

Can a defense lawyer admit guilt?

Defense lawyers also aren't allowed to impose their judgment on their clients when it comes to admitting guilt at trial. In 2018, the U.S. Supreme Court considered the case of a defendant who had been on trial for three murders. ( McCoy v. Louisiana, 584 U. S. ____ (2018).) At the guilt phase of the trial, the defense attorney chose strategically to concede that his client committed the crimes but argued that his client was incapable of having the state of mind necessary for first-degree murder. (The strategy was to argue that the man had a "mental incapacity" that prevented him from forming specific intent .)

What is medical malpractice law?

Medical malpractice law is a fascinating area of law. It is technical. It is highly specialized and requires a great deal of knowledge of medicine as well as a high degree of trial skill. In this lecture, which was designed to teach lawyers who practice in other areas of law, what they need to know about medical malpractice law in New York. Lawyers across the country

Can you add videos to your watch history?

Videos you watch may be added to the TV's watch history and influence TV recommendations. To avoid this, cancel and sign in to YouTube on your computer. An error occurred while retrieving sharing information. Please try again later.

What are tactical decisions?

Tactical or strategic decisions may involve the following: 1 the choice of motions; 2 the scope of discovery; 3 which witnesses to call; 4 the substance of the direct and cross-examination.

What is scope of representation?

From the outset of the case, the lawyer and client should determine the “scope” of the representation. They will set forth the goals of the representation. Some goals are short-term, such as closing on a piece of property, and sometimes they are long-term, as in providing ongoing advice for a corporation.

What is an arrest report?

Arrest reports summarize the events leading up to arrests and provide numerous other details, such as dates, time, location, weather conditions, and witnesses' names and addresses. Arrest reports are almost always one-sided.

Can a prosecutor file charges against a suspect?

Prosecutors can file charges on all crimes for which the police arrested a suspect, can file charges that are more or less severe than the charges leveled by the police, or can decide not to file any charges at all. ( U.S. v. Batchelder, U.S. Sup. Ct. 1979.)

Who decides where charges are brought?

The prosecutor has the discretion to decide where the charges are brought. The defendant does not have this same discretion. The prosecutor will often make the decision based on who is investigating and the size of the case. It can depend on whether the defendant is investigated by the local police, the FBI, the DEA, as well as whom the case was brought to after the investigation. If the case was presented before the US Attorney’s Office, they may decide to take the case.

What is the difference between federal and state courts?

There are many differences that exist between federal courts and state courts, beginning with the way they are constructed. Federal courts have judges who are selected by the President of the United States and confirmed by the United States Senate. These judges are often tenured for life unless they are removed for bad behavior.

Is narcotics a priority?

Recently, the Attorney General announced that certain narcotics offenses are no longer as much of a priority as they were in the past. Changes in the economy have allowed for health care fraud to become a very hot area for prosecution.

Do federal prosecutors have discretion?

Oftentimes there is an overlap between what can be brought in federal court and what can be brought in state court, so prosecutors have discretion and flexibility, especially in the District of Columbia.

Is a federal prosecutor better than a state prosecutor?

The vetting process for federal prosecutors is more intense than for state prosecutors. A position as a federal prosecutor is a more prestigious position and federal prosecutors typically have fewer cases. This allows them to be generally better prepared for trial. However, there are still a lot of very good prosecutors at the state level who enjoy prosecuting these cases. It would be a mistake to think that all state prosecutors are not as good as federal prosecutors because this is not the case.

How does the prosecutor present the case?

The prosecutor presents the state’s case first by calling and questioning witnesses on “direct examination.”. After direct examination of each witness, the defendant’s attorney is permitted to question the witness by “cross examination.”.

What is the role of an assistant state attorney?

When the State Attorney’s Office receives a formal complaint from a law enforcement agency, an assistant state attorney, assigned to the case, will review the reports and may interview witnesses. It is important to cooperate with this office to ensure that all the information about the crime is provided.

What is the first appearance of a defendant?

At First Appearance, the defendant is informed of the charges for which he/she was arrested and. is advised of his/her rights. The Judge reviews the law enforcement reports and may raise or lower the amount of the bond, or may release the defendant on his or her own recognizance.

When did the statewide sentencing guidelines become effective?

Statewide sentencing guidelines became effective on October 1, 1983. These guidelines provide a range of recommended sentences for all felony cases. The court must sentence according to these guidelines unless the court states a clear and convincing reason why it chooses to sentence outside the guidelines.

Who selects the jury?

A jury is selected by the state and defense attorneys and seated as the first item of procedure. The trial begins with an “opening statement” from the assistant state attorney, hereinafter called “prosecutor” and the defense attorney.

Can a judge accept a guilty plea?

Due to the serious nature of felony charges, a judge rarely accepts a “guilty” or “ no contest” plea at arraignment . Therefore, other pre-trial proceedings will be scheduled. At misdemeanor arraignment, the judge will, quite frequently, accept a plea of “guilty” or “no contest”.

What is a summons for a defendant?

If an Information is filed and the defendant has not yet been arrested , an order (a summons) for the defendant to appear in court or an order (a capias or a warrant) for the arrest of the defendant will be issued).

Dennis M. Abrams

It really depends on the complexity of the case and the amount of medical records. Send a quick email or make a call to the lawyer and ask for how long s/he thinks it will take to complete the review.

Peter J Bartinik

Your lawyer will have to determine what evidence will be required to successfully pursue your case. It is not just the medical records that are important. He will have to engage experts that will have to support necessary elements of a malpractice action.

David Ian Schoen

The time can vary greatly. AS long as there is good communication between you, that is OK

James E. Girards

I have been doing medical malpractice cases for over 20 years. In my experience in what might be described as a typical malpractice case it takes about 100 days to get through the review process. In a birth injury case or any other particularly complex situation it can take much longer.

Jason Todd Studinski

Ask the lawyer directly. The answer can vary from lawyer to lawyer and from case to case. If you are dealing with a potential medical malpractice case it can take a while because typically the lawyer is consulting with at least one expert to review the case to determine whether it has merit. I hope this helps. Good luck.

image

Stages in The Criminal Justice System

  1. Crime Committed
  2. Law Enforcement Investigation
  3. Suspect Charged or Arrested
  4. First Appearance (if arrested)
See more on sao12.org

First Appearance

  • If a defendant is arrested and unable to post bond, he or she is entitled to appear before a judge within 24 hours. At First Appearance, the defendant is informed of the charges for which he/she was arrested and is advised of his/her rights. The Judge reviews the law enforcement reports and may raise or lower the amount of the bond, or may release the defendant on his or her own reco…
See more on sao12.org

Filing of Criminal Charges

  • When the State Attorney’s Office receives a formal complaint from a law enforcement agency, an assistant state attorney, assigned to the case, will review the reports and may interview witnesses. It is important to cooperate with this office to ensure that all the information about the crime is provided. This review of the case will determine if there is sufficient evidence to pursue …
See more on sao12.org

Victim Impact/Restitution Statement

  • The Office of the State Attorney provides each victim with a Victim Impact/Restitution Statement for completion. This form affords the opportunity to provide information concerning the effect of the crime, the financial losses incurred and your recommendation for a sentence in this case. Please complete the statement promptly as requested and return it to the State Attorney’s Office…
See more on sao12.org

Victim Compensation

  • The Bureau of Victim Compensation was established by the State of Florida to financially aid innocent victims/survivors of violent crime (including DUI and Hit & Run charges). Victim Compensation is a Payer of Last Resort that provides benefits, within limits and in the event the crime has produced a financial hardship, for medical expenses, funeral costs, counseling, loss o…
See more on sao12.org

You May Be Eligible If You are...

  1. an adult victim or intervenor who has been physically injured as a result of a crime
  2. a victim or intervenor who has suffered psychiatric or psychological injury as a result of a forcible felony
  3. a surviving spouse, parent or guardian, sibling, child or principal dependent of a deceased victim
  1. an adult victim or intervenor who has been physically injured as a result of a crime
  2. a victim or intervenor who has suffered psychiatric or psychological injury as a result of a forcible felony
  3. a surviving spouse, parent or guardian, sibling, child or principal dependent of a deceased victim
  4. the parent or guardian of a minor or incompetent victim that has been injured as a result of a crime

Arraignment

  • As the victim, you have the right to be present at arraignment. However, your presence is not required. At arraignment, the defendant will be formally advised of the charges filed by the State. The defendant is also informed of the right to an attorney. If the accused indicates an inability to afford an attorney but wishes to be represented, the judge may appoint an attorney from the Pub…
See more on sao12.org

Depositions

  • A deposition is an interview or testimony taken under oath of any or all witnesses in a case by the defendant’s attorney after formal charges have been filed. In most cases, an assistant state attorney will also be present during the deposition which maybe recorded by either a court reporter or by a tape recorder which will later be produced into a written transcript. The defenda…
See more on sao12.org

Pre-Trial Proceedings

  • CASE MANAGEMENT, PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCES, PLEA HEARINGS, MOTION HEARINGS, and DOCKET SOUNDING are all types of pre-trial proceedings. Case Managementin Felony Court is a calendared date when the prosecutor, defense attorney and the judge select a trial date for a case. Generally, details of the case are not discussed other than the trial period in which the cas…
See more on sao12.org

Trial Procedure

  • A jury is selected by the state and defense attorneys and seated as the first item of procedure. The trial begins with an “opening statement” from the assistant state attorney, hereinafter called “prosecutor” and the defense attorney. The opening statement outlines the facts that each party expects to establish during the trial. The prosecutor presents the state’s case first by calling an…
See more on sao12.org