The spouse or next of kin of a decedent in New York has the power to authorize an autopsy under New York law for the sole purpose of ascertaining the cause of death. An autopsy can also be authorized for any other purpose by written instrument specifying the purpose and extent of the autopsy.
Full Answer
Courts must often weigh the need for evidence derived from an autopsy against the wishes of the next of kin. An autopsy is a medical examination of a dead body, performed in order to learn about the circumstances of the person’s death.
A doctor might ask you to allow an autopsy if your loved one died of an unexpected illness. They’re usually trying to learn more about what happened, either to ease your mind, to learn whether other family members might be in danger of the same thing, or to find out something that might help other patients.
Third, a private autopsy can often assist a medical malpractice lawyer in the pursuit of a lawsuit against the hospital. In a medical malpractice lawsuit, a lawyer for the family must prove not only that the hospital committed malpractice but also that it was a cause of the death of the patient.
Most states recognize the need in cases of work-related deaths when the autopsy will likely result in relevant evidence as to the cause of death. Typically, if survivors object, they risk having their benefit claims suspended or forfeited. Insurance payouts.
When Is One Required? Although laws vary, nearly all states call for an autopsy when someone dies in a suspicious, unusual, or unnatural way. Many states have one done when a person dies without a doctor present.
Autopsies may be done for several reasons, including the following: When a suspicious or unexpected death occurs. When there's a public health concern, such as an outbreak with an undetermined cause. When no doctor knows the deceased well enough to state a cause of death and to sign the death certificate.
Unless the case has medicolegal implications and an autopsy is ordered by the coroner or medical examiner, the next-of-kin of the deceased has the legal right to make the decision.
Autopsies are not always required prior to making a professional medicolegal determination as to the cause and manner of death. However, an autopsy may be performed if the Medical Examiner determines, in their sole discretion, that it is necessary in order to determine the exact cause and manner of death.
Under What Circumstances Will an Autopsy be Performed?The death is known or suspected to have been caused by apparent criminal violence.The death is unexpected and unexplained in an infant or child.The death is associated with police action.More items...
Autopsies are not performed on everyone who dies. The laws of each state vary, but ultimately the family and the wishes of the person (if known) are respected.
Doctor's response. Yes, an autopsy can be ordered by authorities without relatives' consent in several situations. For example, in all U.S. states, an autopsy can be ordered if there is suspicion of foul play.
The autopsy report describes the autopsy procedure, the microscopic findings, and the medical diagnoses. The report emphasizes the relationship or correlation between clinical findings (the doctor's examination, laboratory tests, radiology findings, etc.) and pathologic findings (those made from the autopsy).
In cases where the cause and manner of death are certified at the time of the autopsy, the autopsy, investigative, and toxicology reports can still take between 3 to 5 months to be completed, finalized, and approved by supervisors.
Forensic pathologist Dr. Stephen J. Cina says that autopsies are best if performed within 24 hours of death, before organs deteriorate, and ideally before embalming, which can interfere with toxicology and blood cultures.
Get a legal pronouncement of death But if your relative died at home, especially if it was unexpected, you'll need to get a medical professional to declare her dead. To do this, call 911 soon after she passes and have her transported to an emergency room where she can be declared dead and moved to a funeral home.
Medical examinersMedical examiners and coroners commonly determine cause and manner of death without an autopsy examination. Some death certificates generated in this way may not state the correct cause and manner of death.
Industry defendants have demanded exhumations and autopsies because, according to some experts, only an autopsy can accurately determine the presence (or not) of asbestos-caused illness. Criminal cases. Defendants in criminal cases have often demanded autopsies of their victims, in order to prove or bolster a defense.
Autopsies have been ordered in automobile accident cases (to determine, for example, the presence of drugs or alcohol), medical malpractice, and cases claiming death due to asbestos exposure.
State statutes authorize autopsies in order to determine the cause of sudden, suspicious, or violent deaths. They’re performed by a coroner (a state official, not necessarily a medical doctor) or a medical examiner (who is a doctor). Statutes typically require that the deceased’s next of kin be notified that the procedure will take place. Objections by the next of kin won’t necessarily stop an autopsy; the examiner has the discretion to proceed or not.
When a coroner or medical examiner performs an autopsy pursuant to statute, that person is acting as a government official and enjoys the same limited immunity that other officials have when carrying out their duties.
Defendants in criminal cases have often demanded autopsies of their victims, in order to prove or bolster a defense. Most courts will order an autopsy in compelling cases, recognizing that the freedom of the defendant is at stake.
An autopsy is a medical examination of a dead body, performed in order to learn about the circumstances of the person’s death. Autopsies are done either before burial or after burial (which requires exhumation). State and federal statutes dictate the situations in which an autopsy can be done, which fall into two camps: those that are required by law due to the nature of the decedent’s death, and those that may be ordered by a judge in a civil or criminal context, to provide evidence in a lawsuit or prosecution.
A typical statute (such as Pennsylvania’s) authorizes an autopsy in the following situations: (1) sudden deaths not caused by readily recognizable disease, or wherein the cause of death cannot be properly certified by a physician on the basis of prior (recent) medical attendance; (2) deaths occurring under suspicious circumstances , ...
The reason is because stopping the spread of diseases is important to the government.
The answer isn't always a clear one. When a person dies, an autopsy can be ordered depending on the situation -- such as in the case of famed painter Thomas Kinkade, who recently died.
And of course, families can always request an autopsy for their late loved one, as well.
The foul play doesn't have to be obvious either. A police investigator can have one done against a family's wishes if foul play is suspected.
Some states, such as California, allow doctors to request an autopsy when an infant dies.
Reasons Why Requesting an Autopsy May Be Important. Even in cases of natural death, however, the next-of-kin may still wish to request an autopsy for several reasons: 2 . To confirm a medical diagnosis made before the death involving a genetic disease that could affect surviving family members. While advancements have been made in accurately ...
Before requesting an autopsy, the next-of-kin should thoroughly consider the possible ramifications, which might include: 1 The effect of the post-mortem procedure on grieving survivors. An autopsy involves making incisions in the chest and/or skull of the deceased in order to inspect/remove organs, which some loved ones might find an unpleasant idea. 4 2 Cultural or religious acceptance. For example, both Orthodox and Conservative Jewish law generally prohibit autopsies because of the belief in the inviolability of the body after death. 5 3 Additional financial obligation. The cost of the autopsy might be charged to the family if not ordered by a medical examiner. 3
4 . Cultural or religious acceptance.
An autopsy or post-mortem examination is a surgical procedure performed by a forensic pathologist to examine a deceased human body and its organs to determine the cause of death. If authorities consider a death suspicious, they will order an autopsy, but only around 8% of all deaths in the U.S. are autopsied. 1 .
Yale School of Medicine. Reasons for an autopsy.
Even in cases of natural death, however, the next-of-kin may still wish to request an autopsy for several reasons: 2
Verywell Health uses only high-quality sources, including peer-reviewed studies, to support the facts within our articles. Read our editorial process to learn more about how we fact-check and keep our content accurate, reliable, and trustworthy.
For example, in all U.S. states, an autopsy can be ordered if there is suspicion of foul play. This type of autopsy is referred to as a forensic autopsy and is performed to gather information of interest to authorities and to determine the manner of death (homicide, suicide, accident, natural death, or undetermined manner).
In most states, autopsies may also be ordered if there is a belief that the death represents a significant public health concern (such as from a threatening infectious disease), if a person inexplicably dies who was not under medical care, who was receiving medical care from a physician for less than 24 hours, or if a person dies from an injury, such as an automobile accident. Autopsies that are ordered by authorities are performed and evaluated in the medical examiner's office or coroner's office.
MedicineNet does not provide medical advice, diagnosis or treatment. See additional information.
If an autopsy is not required by law or ordered by authorities, the deceased person's next of kin must give permission for an autopsy to be performed.
There are other options for gathering additional information after the death of a loved one, including hiring an outside expert to review medical records and internal autopsy reports, or requesting a second autopsy if you doubt the results of the first. State laws governing autopsies vary. Consulting an attorney experienced in working with families in cases of suspected malpractice or negligence can be a good place to start.
Why do an autopsy? If you have any questions about care, treatment, or anything that may have contributed to your loved one’s demise, only an autopsy can help you determine the exact cause of death and serve as best evidence. Even if you don’t suspect malpractice or negligence, an autopsy can help in providing reassurance and answers.
How soon should an autopsy be done? Timing is critical. It should be done as soon as possible (within 24 hours if possible) for best information. However, even autopsies performed later can yield valuable results.
When a loved one dies while under the care of a medical professional or in an institutional setting and you have questions surrounding their care and treatment, you may feel angry and helpless. Depending on the circumstances of the death, a physician, medical examiner, or legal authority might order an autopsy to learn more.
While Kate Lotti is a licensed attorney, her primary focus and passion is in legal operations. She applies her knowledge and years of experience to ensure that every facet of the firm’s operations supports both the firm’s attorneys and clients at peak efficiency. She particularly enjoys the areas of client service, internal processes, and information technology support. Ms. Lotti is licensed to practice law in Massachusetts.
discovery of the cause of death is necessary to meet an immediate and substantial threat to the public health and that a dissection or autopsy is essential to ascertain the cause of death;
You must be over 18 to authorize an autopsy.
The spouse or next of kin of a decedent in New York has the power to authorize an autopsy under New York law for the sole purpose of ascertaining the cause of death. An autopsy can also be authorized for any other purpose by written instrument specifying the purpose and extent of the autopsy.
Notwithstanding any other provision of law, in the absence of a compelling public necessity, no dissection or autopsy shall be performed over the objection of a surviving relative or friend of the deceased that such procedure is contrary to the religious belief of the decedent, or, if there is otherwise reason to believe that a dissection or autopsy is contrary to the decedent’s religious beliefs.
A coroner who is a physician licensed to practice medicine, a coroner’s physician, and the county medical examiner can perform or direct the performance of an autopsy in the course of an investigation or upon the written request of a district attorney, sheriff, police chief, or superintendent of the state police.