why would a defense attorney want to delay a pre-trail conference

by Darlene Abshire 5 min read

There are some circumstances where the judge allows us to have more pre-trial conferences. For example, sometimes the police can’t find the video of the incident, or a witness is hard to locate, or there is restitution due but the amount is unknown. There are many reasons that could delay the resolution of the case.

Attorneys often request continuances because their work on other cases has prevented them from devoting the necessary time to the case at hand. Courts usually allow some leeway in these situations, especially for court-appointed defense attorneys.

Full Answer

What is a pre-trial conference in a criminal case?

Feb 10, 2022 · Basically, a pre-trial conference is a check-in. It’s a chance for the defense attorney and prosecutor to meet, discuss the case, and determine if there are any outstanding issues. If there are any questions about witnesses or particular pieces of evidence, a pre-trial is a chance to sort them out. The attorneys then report back to the judge ...

Why hire an attorney for a pretrial conference?

In spite of this general approach, both the defense and the prosecution in a criminal case (and the court, on its own motion) may ask for and obtain a continuance, beginning with the defendant’s first appearance, which is typically the arraignment (where the defendant is appraised of the charges and asked how he wishes to plead). Requests (called “motions”) for a continuance can …

What happens if the defense delays the trial?

Apr 28, 2021 · During the criminal pre-trial conference, the defense attorney will be given an opportunity to review the prosecutor’s file. This will include the police report, a list of the defendant’s prior offenses, if any, and any other evidence the prosecution intends to introduce. Legally, the defense attorney is entitled to review and copy ...

Can a case take more than one pretrial conference?

Oct 21, 2017 · A pretrial conference is a scheduled meeting between the Defendant, Plaintiff, and their attorneys, conducted prior to trial. The conference is held before the actual trial judge or a magistrate (a judicial officer who possesses fewer judicial powers than a judge). A pretrial conference may be held prior to trial in both civil and criminal cases.

Is a continuance a good thing?

If the prosecution makes meaningful changes to the facts contained in the indictment, the defense may be justified in seeking a continuance so that they can prepare for the changed facts. If the change is relatively minor and not relevant to the merits of the case, however, a continuance probably is not warranted.Oct 18, 2021

What is the purpose of pre-trial in criminal cases?

The pre-trial order binds the parties, limits the trial to matters not disposed of, and controls the course of the action during the trial, unless modified by the court to prevent manifest injustice.

What does status pretrial mean?

A pretrial hearing, sometimes called a pretrial conference, is a meeting of the defense, the prosecution, and the judge before a trial commences. ... The judge can determine if there is fair cause for a trial.

Can you go to jail at a pretrial hearing?

Yes, a person can be arrested at a pre-trial hearing, but there has to be a valid reason to do so.

What happens during the pre-trial conference?

The pre-trial conference is conducted for the expeditious disposition of the case. ... In the pre-trial and preliminary conference, there is narrowing of conflict between the parties. In furtherance of this, the judge is sanctioned to allow the number of witnesses to be presented, limit the trial days, etc.

What matters shall be considered during the pre-trial?

The pre-trial brief shall contain, among others: (a) a summary of admitted facts and proposed stipulation of facts; (b) the main factual and legal issues; (c) the documents or other object evidence to be marked; and (d) the names of the witnesses, and the summary of their testimonies.Mar 5, 2021

What happens at a pre-trial review?

In complex litigation, the court may hold what is known as a pre-trial review (PTR). It is a hearing and is usually fixed to take place up to ten weeks before the date listed for trial. ... Check that the parties have complied with all previous court orders and directions. Give directions for the conduct of the trial.

What is pre-trial order?

A pre-trial order is an order issued by the court upon the termination of the pre-trial. This order recites in detail the following: The matters taken up in the conference; The action taken thereon; The amendments allowed to the pleadings; and.Aug 7, 2017

When the judge informs the defendant of their rights what is it called?

8. Arraignment -- After an Indictment or Information has been filed and arrest has been made, an Arraignment must take place before a Magistrate Judge. During an Arraignment, the accused, now called the defendant, is read the charges against him or her and advised of his or her rights.Apr 26, 2021

Is a pre-trial review necessary?

A pre-trial review is held if the case is complex or the trial is expected to be lengthy. The aim is to make sure the trial will proceed efficiently, particular areas of dispute being identified and narrowed down as far as possible.

What does PTPH mean?

Plea and Trial Preparation HearingThe first hearing at Crown Court after the case has been sent by the Magistrates is the Plea and Trial Preparation Hearing ("PTPH").Aug 27, 2021

What rights do remand prisoners have?

A person who is on remanded in a prison is not treated as a convicted prisoner, as they have not yet been found guilty of any offence. They should also have further rights in prison, such as being able to wear their own clothes and having more visits.Oct 16, 2020

Typical Reasons Why Defendants Ask For Continuances

Judges are often asked to continue a hearing or a trial for these reasons: 1. At arraignment, to secure counsel. An arrestee’s first court appearan...

Typical Reasons Why Prosecutors Ask For Continuances

Prosecutors must bring a case to trial within the speedy trial window unless the defendant has waived time. If the defendant refuses to waive time...

When The Judge Says, “No,” Does The Defendant Have Any recourse?

Judges are normally very careful to document the evidence offered in support of the motion for a continuance, and their reasons for granting or den...

Questions For Your Attorney

1. I’ve waived time and need more time to prepare my case. What do I have to tell the judge to get the trial date pushed back? 2. If the prosecutor...

What is a pre trial conference?

A pre-trial conference is a critical step in any criminal case. It comes after a criminal defendant has been arraigned, but before the case goes to trial. The goal of the pre-trial conference is to bring the prosecutor and the defense attorney together to explore possibilities of resolving the case without going to trial.

What is included in a criminal pre trial conference?

This will include the police report, a list of the defendant’s prior offenses, if any, and any other evidence the prosecution intends to introduce.

What happens when a defendant is charged with a felony?

If a defendant has been charged with a felony, the case will first go to the Circuit Court where a judge will determine whether there is probable cause to believe the defendant committed a felony. The preliminary hearing is another crucial step because it allows the defense attorney to cross-examine key witnesses and challenge the evidence against the defendant. A defense attorney may even be able to have the case dismissed at this stage if the arrest was illegal.

What happens after a felony arraignment?

If there is a finding that there was probable cause to believe the defendant committed a felony, the case will be scheduled for an arraignment where the defendant will enter a plea of guilty, not guilty, or no contest. The pre-trial conference will be held after the arraignment.

What happens if you plead guilty to a misdemeanor?

In a misdemeanor case, the defendant will enter a plea of guilty, not guilty, or no contest at the arraignment. There is no separate hearing on probable cause. A defendant who enters a plea of guilty or no contest this early in the proceedings will often receive a lighter sentence because the defendant will have made clear to the judge that they acknowledge their wrongdoing and do not wish to waste the court’s time.

What is the role of a defense attorney?

Legally, the defense attorney is entitled to review and copy everything the prosecution has about his client. Depending on the nature of the case and the defendant’s criminal history, the file may be very small, or it may be quite large. To realistically evaluate the possibilities of resolving the case without going to trial, ...

What is plea bargaining?

A plea bargain generally involves the defendant agreeing to plead guilty or no contest to an offense that is less severe than what they were charged with. Most people see plea bargaining as benefiting everyone involved: the prosecutor gets a conviction, albeit for a lesser charge, and the defendant receives a charge and sentence that is less severe than what they were originally facing and will have less of an impact on their life and their future.

What is a pretrial conference?

A pretrial conference in a criminal case is an opportunity for the defense lawyer to talk with the prosecutor about the case and the charges. Generally, the lawyers meet during or before a pretrial conference. The defendant does not participate or attend the meeting, although the defendant almost always has to be at the court for the hearing date.

What happens when a case goes to trial?

If the case is going to trial or a motion hearing, the parties will advise the court regarding what direction the case is going, and the court will set dates for future hearings. Finally, many cases take more than one pretrial conference to determine the necessary course of action.

What is a pretrial?

A pretrial is an opportunity for the parties to discuss important issues in the case and explore the possibility of a settlement before trial.

Where do plea negotiations take place?

In many cases, discussions regarding plea negotiations take place at the pretrial conference. Although there are many cases where plea negotiations take place outside the courthouse, the defense lawyer does some of his or her most important work at this critically important meeting. An experienced, successful attorney intensely prepares before the pretrial conference to ensure that he is in the best possible position to negotiate and persuade the prosecutor to resolve a case in a way that is satisfactory to the client. The lawyers with LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C. take the time to have discussions with the prosecution and provide documentation to the prosecutor in advance of the pretrial in a criminal case, when possible, to make the hearing as productive as possible. Where a less experienced attorney, court-appointed lawyer, or a bargain attorney may plan just to show up and “wing it,” our team takes great care to prepare for the pretrial conference in advance of the hearing by working together to formulate the most persuasive arguments possible.

What is a pretrial in a felony case?

Once the case gets to Circuit Court, a pretrial is scheduled right after the felony arraignment. A pretrial in a criminal case can be used by a defense lawyer to advocate for their client, ...

What are contested motions in criminal cases?

The areas that frequently result in contested motions include the admissibility of evidence, undue delay in the proceedings, deprivation of due process, violations of the constitution, the admissibility of evidence, and bond conditions. Although an experienced criminal defense lawyer will make every effort to persuade the prosecutor into stipulating (agreeing) to any desired relief, some issues cannot be resolved without a fight.

What is evidentiary issue?

Evidentiary Issues. The prosecution and defense may or may not agree as to what constitutes evidence in a case. Whether the parties discuss the possibility of a motion or a trial, a judge may use the pretrial conference to review the evidence each party intends to introduce or oppose. By examining the evidence before a motion, evidentiary hearing, ...

What is a Pretrial Conference?

A pretrial conference is a scheduled meeting between the Defendant, Plaintiff, and their attorneys, conducted prior to trial. The conference is held before the actual trial judge or a magistrate (a judicial officer who possesses fewer judicial powers than a judge). A pretrial conference may be held prior to trial in both civil and criminal cases.

What is the Purpose of a Pretrial Conference?

The purpose of the pretrial conference is to assure that all parties are prepared to go on to trial, and to discuss the possibility of settling the case prior to going to trial. This conference is ordered by the court and is held in the courtroom to facilitate a face-to-face discussion.

What Do You Bring to a Pretrial Conference?

When you come to a pretrial conference, you should bring the original Summons and Complaint, your Answer, and any other motions or legal documents you received from the court or the Plaintiff's attorney. If you have kept any type of personal log regarding the progression of the case, bring that along with you as well.

What is a reasonable time to prepare for trial?

Both the prosecution and the defense are entitled to a reasonable time to prepare for trial. Exactly what constitutes a reasonable time is open to interpretation, and depends on the circumstances and complexity of a particular case. In general, each side must be given sufficient time to: review the evidence.

How to prepare for trial?

Both the prosecution and the defense are entitled to a reasonable time to prepare for trial. Exactly what constitutes a reasonable time is open to interpretation, and depends on the circumstances and complexity of a particular case. In general, each side must be given sufficient time to: 1 review the evidence 2 investigate the facts 3 consult with witnesses 4 negotiate a plea agreement (if one is possible), and, 5 in the case of the defense, hold lawyer-client meetings.

What is a continuance in a trial?

A continuance is a grant of additional preparation time before or during a trial. Either the prosecution or the defense can request a continuance, and sometimes even the court can order a continuance of its own accord.

What is new evidence?

the new evidence is reasonably related to evidence the defendant already knows about. the defendant has enough time without the continuance to prepare for the new evidence. the defendant wasn't diligent in anticipating the evidence (for example, defense counsel failed to read forensic reports turned over by the prosecution ...

What is the 6th amendment?

The Sixth Amendment guarantees criminal defendants the right to counsel, but that right has limitations. Defendants have the right to counsel of their choosing —within reason. When a defendant wants to change their defense attorney for another, the court must consider several factors before granting a continuance to allow the new lawyer to prepare. A judge may not arbitrarily insist that the case move forward when it's clear that a continuance is needed for a new lawyer .

What is the most important consideration for a judge?

Perhaps the most important consideration for a judge is whether the party requesting the continuance has been diligent —in other words, whether the party put in sufficient effort. Parties must be active in reviewing evidence, interviewing witnesses, issuing subpoenas, and testing forensic evidence.

Can an attorney text you?

Attorneys have the option, but are not required, to send text messages to you. You will receive up to 2 messages per week from Martindale-Nolo. Frequency from attorney may vary. Message and data rates may apply. Your number will be held in accordance with our Privacy Policy.

Pretrial Conference in A Criminal Case

  • A pretrial conference typically occurs in all felony and misdemeanorprosecutions. In a misdemeanor, the pretrial follows the arraignment. In a felony, the district court judge sends the case to the Circuit Court if he or she finds there is probable cause to believe the defendant committed a felony. Once the case gets to Circuit Court, a pretrial is scheduled right after the fel…
See more on notafraidtowin.com

Felony and Misdemeanor Plea Negotiations

  • In many cases, discussions regarding plea negotiations take place at the pretrial conference. Although there are many cases where plea negotiations take place outside the courthouse, the defense lawyer does some of his or her most important work at this critically important meeting. An experienced, successful attorney intensely prepares before the pretrial conference to ensure …
See more on notafraidtowin.com

Trial Negotiations at The Pretrial

  • There are also cases where the client may have no interest in entering a plea and will accept nothing less than a dismissal or a trial. When this is the plan, we will talk with the prosecutor about the trial process to determine how we can get our client the greatest possible advantage. Important trial decisions are often made based upon information obtained at the pretrial in a cri…
See more on notafraidtowin.com

Discovery in A Criminal Case

  • The discovery in a case can be anything from simple to extraordinarily complex and voluminous. Cases we handle include misdemeanors and felonies with police reports that are only a few pages to complex RICO prosecutions in Federal Court with tens of thousands of pages of reports and thousands of hours of recorded calls and meetings. There are also cases with no physical exhibi…
See more on notafraidtowin.com

Evidentiary Issues

  • The prosecution and defense may or may not agree as to what constitutes evidence in a case. Whether the parties discuss the possibility of a motion or a trial, a judge may use the pretrial conference to review the evidence each party intends to introduce or oppose. By examining the evidence before a motion, evidentiary hearing, or trial, areas of agreement and disagreement ca…
See more on notafraidtowin.com

The Court Hearing – Appearing in Front of The Judge

  • After the pretrial discussion, the parties often appear before the judge to advise the court on the case’s status. If the government agrees to a dismissal, the prosecution will generally request dismissal at the pretrial conference. If the is a plea bargain or sentence bargain, the prosecution and defense will advise the court of the resolution, and the plea is then “placed on the record.” “P…
See more on notafraidtowin.com

Michigan Criminal Defense Attorney

  • Not already a client with LEWIS & DICKSTEIN, P.L.L.C.? We know that our clients often experience tremendous stress and anxiety when charged with a criminal offense. We take the time to help the client understand the criminal process so that their stress level is reduced, and they do not have to worry about not following the procedure for the various court hearings. One of the many thing…
See more on notafraidtowin.com