why wont the attorney use mental illness defense

Most attorneys prefer to work with clients who do not have mental illness. However, as they become more experienced interacting with defendants who are affected by mental illness, they become more knowledgeable and are more willing to defend them. A large majority believe that their law school education about mental illness was inadequate.

Full Answer

Do I need a criminal defense attorney for a mental illness case?

Jan 07, 2014 · Mitigation: When a mental illness does not right to the very high level necessary to establish an inability to understand right from wrong, or to participate in the defense, it may still be used as mitigation. This means that it can be used to negotiate with the prosecutor to reduce charges, or to assist the court in providing a lowered or ...

What percentage of lawyers don’t know about mental health law?

I have represented thousands of people before, many of whom have serious mental illnesses or chemical dependency problems. I have sought mental health opinions in about 50 cases, with about 10 of them with viable mental health defenses. In some of those cases, we chose to waive the defense for one strategic reason or another.

Do public defenders know enough about mental health law?

Mental Illness and Mental Health Defenses: Perceptions of the Criminal Bar Richard L. Frierson, MD, Mary S. Boyd, MD, and Angela Harper, MD As the number of state mental hospital beds declines, persons with persistent mental illness are increasingly encountered by those working in the legal system.

Can treatment for mental illness help avoid criminal prosecutions?

Legal dilemmas involving mental illness and the need for criminal defense demand an attorney who understands the struggles of those with mental health challenges. At The Gage Law Firm , we specialize in criminal and probate cases involving mental illness and have handled over 800 criminal cases involving mental health.

Is mental illness a legal defense?

The insanity defense, also known as the mental disorder defense, is an affirmative defense by excuse in a criminal case, arguing that the defendant is not responsible for his/her actions due to an episodic or persistent psychiatric disease at the time of the criminal act.

Why is the insanity defense rarely used?

However, the insanity defense is rarely used and hardly ever successful. This is generally because of the difficulty in proving legal insanity. Many criminal defendants suffer from mental illness and can produce evidence of this illness such as psychiatric or layperson testimony.

Is mental health a good defense?

Criminal responsibility defenses focus on the defendant's mental status at the time of the crime. It is also an affirmative defense, which means the defendant needs to raise the defense and prove it up by a preponderance of the evidence.

Can depression be used as a defence?

Depression has been used as a basis for an insanity defence. Clinical depression, even when it is non-psychotic may provide enough ground for a legitimate excuse for criminal or otherwise immoral failures to act.

Can psychopaths plead insanity?

Some States Say Psychopaths Can't Use An Insanity Defense : Shots - Health News Having a serious mental diagnosis doesn't necessarily mean that juries will consider an insanity defense. Some states have changed their laws to exclude people with antisocial personality disorder.Aug 3, 2016

What is guilty but mentally ill?

The guilty but mentally ill (GBMI) verdict is premised on the notion that when a defendant raises a claim of insanity, the jury should be permitted to return a verdict that falls between the total inculpation of a guilty verdict and the complete exoneration of a not guilty by reason of insanity verdict.

What qualifies as legally insane?

Generally speaking, criminal insanity is understood as a mental defect or disease that makes it impossible for a defendant to understand their actions, or to understand that their actions are wrong.

What 3 things must be proven for a person to be declared legally insane?

In states that allow the insanity defense, defendants must prove to the court that they didn't understand what they were doing; failed to know right from wrong; acted on an uncontrollable impulse; or some variety of these factors.Jan 18, 2019

Should insanity be a legal defense?

States should provide a full insanity defense. When defendants' mental illnesses prevent them from understanding the wrongfulness of the act or prevent them from controlling their behavior, they should be acquitted by reason of insanity. Criminal liability in these instances is unfair. Inappropriate, and ineffective.

Is mental health an excuse for criminal behaviour?

Myth #3: Mental illnesses are just an excuse for poor behaviour. Fact: It's true that some people who experience mental illnesses may act in ways that are unexpected or seem strange to others. We need to remember that the illness, not the person, is behind these behaviours.

What is the 3 3 3 rule for anxiety?

Follow the 3-3-3 rule. Then, name three sounds you hear. Finally, move three parts of your body — your ankle, fingers, or arm. Whenever you feel your brain going 100 miles per hour, this mental trick can help center your mind, bringing you back to the present moment, Chansky says.Mar 26, 2017

What happens if you are deemed insane?

If you successfully plead the insanity defense, then you will not receive the normal jail/prison sentence for your crime. Instead, you will be committed to a state mental hospital. There are two reasons for commitment: to rehabilitate and treat the defendant, and.Feb 1, 2022

What is the justice system?

Second, by definition, the justice system is dealing with a defendant who has a severe mental illness or intellectual disability.

Is psychology a science?

First, psychology is an inexact science. Unlike in the hard sciences where a person expects a high level of precision, psychology deals with the realities of human nature. Because human behavior is incredibly complex, psychologists use much broader probabilities and estimates in forming their opinions.

What is diminished capacity defense?

Diminished Capacity/Culpability Defenses. The last type of mental health defense that can be raised is a diminished capacity or culpability defense. This defense is related to criminal responsibility, but is not quite the same for an important reason.

Can a person be tried for mental illness?

No person who, as a result of mental disease or defect, lacks capacity to understand the proceedings against the person or to assist in the person’s own defense shall be tried, convicted, or sentenced for the commission of an offense so long as such incapacity endures.

What is a mental health power of attorney?

A mental health power of attorney, also called a psychiatric advance directive, is a legal document that identifies one or more individuals as an agent or agents who act on behalf of a person who is mentally ill. An agent has certain powers to make decisions on the care of another, such as types of treatment and treatment facilities. This document ideally identifies your loved one's wishes for treatment and care, set forth prior to a recurrence of mental illness. Treatment and care can include things such as: 1 Treatment facilities 2 Medications 3 Drug trial participation 4 Crisis intervention 5 Care of dependents

Why is a power of attorney important?

A mental health power of attorney is important to ensure your loved one receives the care he deserves and desires. It enables your loved one to declare his wishes during periods of lucidity so that if there is a recurrence, he will be treated according to his wishes. Without a mental health power of attorney, family and friends are unable ...

What does an agent do?

An agent has certain powers to make decisions on the care of another , such as types of treatment and treatment facilities. This document ideally identifies your loved one's wishes for treatment and care, set forth prior to a recurrence of mental illness. Treatment and care can include things such as:

Is insanity an affirmative defense?

An affirmative defense is one in which the criminal defense attorney argues that his client should be found not guilty even if the prosecution is able to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant committed the crime with which he has been charged. ...

Why is the medical profession important?

The medical profession has gone to great lengths to preserve patient privacy and to give patients a sense of agency regarding their treatment. If you have ever had a chronic illness, you probably appreciate being able to make the choice about to whom to disclose your diagnosis.

What happens if a jury finds a defendant guilty?

If the jury finds the defendant guilty, the judge often sentences him to whatever the usual punishment is for the crime he committed. If the sentence involves a prison term, the judge may order the defendant to spend a certain amount of time in a psychiatric hospital before entering prison.

Is mental illness a public issue?

While the social stigma surrounding mental illness has certainly lessened in recent years (outside of the criminal courts, the word “insanity” is rarely used to refer to mental illnesses), most people would prefer that their mental health not be a matter of public discussion.

Is mental health a factor in criminal cases?

Your mental illness may or may not be an important factor in your criminal law case. If you have questions about your mental health, contact a physician. If you need advice about criminal charges that have been brought against you, contact The Law Office of H. Chase Harbin for a legal consultation.

What is a mental disability in Connecticut?

Connecticut statutes generally use the term “psychiatric disability” rather than “mental illness.” Section 17a-495 of the Connecticut General Statutes defines a “person with psychiatric disabilities” as “any person who has a mental or emotional condition which has substantial adverse effects on his or her ability to function and who requires care and treatment.” C

How common is mental illness?

About 15% of all people with mental illness will have an accompanying substance abuse disorder, although the percentage in the criminal justice system is much higher. About 16-20 percent of the jail and prison population has a significant mental illness (schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, or major depression) at any given time; this far exceeds the rate for these disorders in the general population. It is a common misperception that people with severe mental illness are significantly more violent than other people. Research shows this is generally not true. In fact, the vast majority of people with mental illness in jail are arrested for nonviolent offenses. Often, it is when people with mental illness are undiagnosed, untreated or stop taking their medication that they get in trouble with the law.

Is mental retardation the same as mental illness?

MENTAL ILLNESS AND MENTAL RETARDATION ARE NOT THE SAME: Mental retardation is a permanent condition characterized by significantly below average intelligence accompanied by significant limitations in certain skill areas. Mental illness, on the other hand, usually involves disturbances in thought processes and emotions and may be temporary, cyclical, or episodic. Most people with a mental illness do not have intellectual deficits; some, in fact, have high intelligence. It is possible for a person with mental retardation to also have a mental illness. Some of the Connecticut statutes that address mental illness also address mental retardation, and you should look carefully at those statutes for the differences in how the two are addressed. This handbook does not address mental retardation.

What is competence to stand trial?

The question of competence to stand trial relates to a criminal defendant’s mental state at the time of trial — not at the time of the alleged offense. In other words, determinations regarding your client’s competence are not determinations on the merits of your client’s case, and a determination of incompetence will not excuse the offense against your client.

Can you force a client to go to jail?

You cannot force your client to get treatment if he or she does not want it, even though you know it may be in his or her long-term interest. You may be limited in what you can do for your client. If your client’s charges are minor and he or she has a supportive family, has a safe place to live, is usually relatively stable, and is competent, it may be better for your client to plead to jail time if you can negotiate a good deal rather than pursuing the insanity defense, even if applicable, or accepting a probated sentence. However, you have an obligation to set out all the pros and cons of any plea bargain agreement for your client. If your client is considering straight jail time, you should tell him or her the possible benefits of taking probation with conditions that require treatment. Tell your client what you believe the chances are of him or her staying out of trouble if he or she does not get treatment, and what penalties might await your client if he or she re-offends.

What to do if a doctor is not able to testify?

If it is not, you should call the examining doctor and ask for a revised report. If you believe the revised report is still inadequate or inaccurate, you should ask for a second opinion. Inquire within the legal and mental health communities about other doctors who may be able to testify at the competence hearing on behalf of your client.

What is a NGRI verdict?

It is true that, like a simple not-guilty verdict, an NGRI verdict is considered a full acquittal of all charges. However, if you try your client’s case to the judge, the judge might be reluctant to find your client not guilty by reason of insanity if he or she is operating under the myth that your client will automatically go free upon such a verdict — especially if your client is charged with a violent crime.