: why do the women go to so much trouble to hide the dead canary from the county attorney?

Why does the Canary need to be hidden?

This leads them to the conclusion that John killed Minnie's bird and in doing so, also killed her only joy. The women ultimately decide to hide the dead bird from the men, and in doing so, they...

Why do the women conceal the evidence they found?

Cite. The significance of the dead canary is paramount in the play, for it represents the missing piece of evidence that the men are desperately trying to find, and which the women, engaged in ...

Why do the women conceal the dead bird?

 · At some point in their lives they have felt the way Mrs. Wright felt/feels. They also hide the canary from the attorney because the canary was the evidence they gave the motive for the murder. What explains Mrs. Peter’s sudden change of allegiance when she supports Mrs. Hale’s assertion that “the cat got it”?

What clues reveal Minnie's motive for killing the Canary?

2. Question 2: Why do the women go to so much trouble to hide the dead canary from the county attorney? What explains Mrs. Peters's sudden change of allegiance when she supports Mrs. Hale’s assertion that “the cat got it”? Lewis Hale’s defines the relationship between men and women in this story.

Why does Mrs Peters hide the evidence?

Peters realize from the clues they find that Mrs. Wright (Minnie Foster) has killed her husband but that she was justified in doing so. They conceal the evidence to prevent Mrs. Wright's possible conviction.

What is the purpose of the dead canary in Trifles?

The bird also symbolizes Minnie's need for companionship in her childless home, and the death of the bird showed that John not only didn't acknowledge this need but actually removed her remaining source of happiness in a cruel and brutal way.

What do the women do at the end of Trifles?

Mrs. Hale says that Mrs. Wright was going to finish the quilt by knotting it, which is a whole lot like the way she finished off her husband… by knotting a rope around his neck. The pronoun "we" also packs a punch in the last line.

What do the women decide to do with the evidence they find Trifles?

-The women decide to hide the evidence from the men; they conceal the trifles their husbands wouldn't understand, and the men return without proof of Minnie's guilt.

What is the significance of the cage and the dead bird that are found in Mrs Wright's belongings?

The birdcage and dead canary in Trifles are significant pieces of evidence, which point to Mrs. Wright's motive to kill her husband. The canary also symbolically represents Mrs. Wright and the birdcage symbolizes her oppressive marriage.

What does the dead bird symbolize in a jury of her peers?

The Dead Bird Symbol Analysis Peters reveals Minnie Wright's guilt, but also shows the cruelty of which John Wright was capable. Although John Wright's act of strangling the songbird was a single cruel act, it symbolizes the way he has treated Minnie throughout their marriage.

What is ironic about the ending of Trifles?

Written in the early 1900s, “Trifles” deals with the rights of, expectations for and assumptions about women in society at the time. In an ironic twist, the audience knows that the women have solved the murder mystery while the men remain oblivious of the truth because of their assumptions.

What does knot it mean in Trifles?

The act of knotting a quilt is linked to the act of killing a man with a rope around his neck. The play ends with George Henderson asking the women how Minnie was going to finish the quilt. Mrs. Hale's certainty that she was going to “knot it” symbolizes the women's certainty that Minnie killed her husband.

How does the symbol of the broken fruit jar impact the theme that women were often unhappy in the roles they were expected to fulfill?

In part two of Trifles, how does the symbol of the broken fruit jar impact the theme that women were often unhappy in the roles they were expected to fulfill? The shattered fruit jar symbolizes the broken and unhappy home in which Mrs. Wright lived.

What do the women find in Mrs Wright's sewing box?

Meanwhile, the women discover an empty birdcage and eventually find the dead bird in a box in Mrs. Wright's sewing basket while they are searching for materials for the quilt. The bird has been strangled in the same manner as John Wright.

Why does Mrs Hale find it difficult to cross over Mrs Wright's threshold?

In "Jury", why does Mrs. Hale find it difficult to cross over Mrs. Wright's threshold? She has never visited before, although she feels she really should have.

Who found the dead bird trifles?

Meanwhile sorting through her items, Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters find the dead canary in a box.

What did the women notice about Minnie Wright's cheerless home?

The women notice her cheerless home: no children to bring life to it; living with a hard man could have crushed the spirit of Minnie Wright.

What did the men dismiss these things as?

The men dismiss these things as "trifles.". Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters take exception to the comments: they, too, work hard with little recognition for their labors. Knowing of Mrs. Wright before she married, of her love of singing and sweet disposition, they wonder what changed her: MRS. HALE.

What is the significance of the dead canary?

The significance of the dead canary is paramount in the play, for it represents the missing piece of evidence that the men are desperately trying to find, and which the women, engaged in their "trifles," find almost by accident. It is only they that are able to piece together that the canary represents the one piece of evidence that links Minnie Wright to the murder, and thus they hide it. Note how, highly ironically, after having found the bird, they hear the County Attorney say:

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

What does "if there was some definite thing" mean?

If there was some definite thing. Something to show--something to make a story about--a thing that would connect up with this strange way of doing it.

What is a certified educator?

Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.

Who came with the sheriff and other men who are looking for evidence?

Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale come with the sheriff and other men who are looking for evidence; the women will gather some of Mrs. Wright's things to take to her.

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

What is a certified educator?

Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.

What was the final straw in the story of Minnie and John Wright?

Peters and Mrs. Hale find a number of clues which point to Mr. Wright's cruelty, such as the realization that Minnie no longer wears pretty clothes because her husband didn't like it. The factors pointing to Minnie's unhappiness with her husband included bread left out to get stale, a half-cleaned table, and erratic stitching in a quilt. The final straw is the discovery of a dead canary , which the ladies assume was killed by John. This is the final discovery, and from everything the ladies have seen, they consider it likely that John's murder of the innocent canary was the final straw that made Mrs. Wright snap and decide to murder her husband.

What happened to Minnie the Canary?

Minnie has been the victim of domestic abuse for some time. She'd been able to put up with a lot from her abusive husband, John, but his killing of her precious pet canary proved to be the last straw. The bird was just about the only good thing Minnie had left in her life, and so its violent death at the hands of her husband tipped her over the edge.

What does the canary symbolize in the play?

The canary symbolizes Minnie. Her marriage becomes her cage, and in killing the canary, her husband kills a part of her as well as the only thing left in her life that gave her beauty and pleasure. Only Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale appreciate the significance of the canary and the grueling, lonely life Minnie led with her husband, and this reasoning leads them to understand also that Minne kills her husband with her sewing scissors in retribution for his cruelty.. When they say at the end of the play “knot it,” they seem to answer the question the men ask (condescendingly) about Minnie’s quilting, but in reality pronounce Minnie “not guilty” for her crime because they empathize with her so completely.

Why did Minnie kill her husband?

In the play Trifles, Minnie murdered her husband because of his cruel and abusive nature. She did not murder the canary, and the assumption is that her husband carried out that travesty.

How long is the free trial for eNotes?

Start your 48-hour free trial to unlock this answer and thousands more. Enjoy eNotes ad-free and cancel anytime.

What is a certified educator?

Our certified Educators are real professors, teachers, and scholars who use their academic expertise to tackle your toughest questions. Educators go through a rigorous application process, and every answer they submit is reviewed by our in-house editorial team.

Who did Minnie leave to answer the question of why she killed her husband?

Minnie herself does not get to answer the question of why she killed her husband. It is left to her friends, Mrs. Peters and Mrs. Hale, to deduce her motives and share them with the audience of this great play.

What evidence does George Henderson find in the kitchen?

Before the men head upstairs to examine the scene of the crime, George Henderson finds Minnie Wright ’s canning jars of fruit in the pantry, which have broken and caused a sticky mess. Mrs. Peters exclaims sadly that Minnie was worried about the possibility that her newly canned jars would burst in the cold weather. Mr. Peters is amazed and amused that Minnie could worry about her domestic projects in the face of her serious situation. Mr. Hale responds that “women are used to worrying over trifles .”

Why is Martha Hale concerned about her husband's retelling of events?

Martha Hale’s concern about her husband’s retelling of events reflects her awareness that Minnie is in trouble and that the opinion of a man (her husband)—even a not completely competent man—could help or harm Minnie’s situation because Mr. Hale’s testimony will be taken seriously by the other men. Active Themes.

What is Martha Hale's role in the story?

Martha Hale participates in the appearance-based judgments that other characters in the story tend to make when she observes Mr. and Mrs. Peters in terms of how she thinks a sheriff and his wife ought to look. The physical differences between Mr. and Mrs. Peters mirror the power differences between the characters: Mr. Peters holds all the power and Mrs. Peters none. Martha’s regret over not visiting Minnie eventually develops into her certainty that there are more forms of wrongdoing than are punishable by law.

Why does Minnie think Minnie killed her husband?

She believes Minnie killed her husband and that her reasons for doing so were connected to her isolation and mistreatment. John Wright is considered “a good man,” which reminds the reader that these qualities of “goodness” would have been defined by other men, and not by his wife. Active Themes.

What does Minnie Wright's possessions reveal to the reader?

Minnie Wright’s possessions reveal to the reader the type of situation she lived in with her husband.

How did Minnie change after her marriage?

Minnie changed after her marriage from a lively youth to a reclusive woman. This transformation is mentioned several times and here it is blamed on John Wright. This transformation speaks to the scale of John’s impact on Minnie. Whatever happened in their relationship, it was dramatic enough and hurtful enough to change Minnie’s personality.

What is telephone in a life?

A telephone is associated with communication and staying in touch. Minnie Wright lived a lonely life that would have been changed had her husband chosen to install a telephone. Mr. Hale’s request is too late to save Minnie or John Wright, an example of situational irony.

What is the men's rebuke for the women's focus on the quilt?

The men’s rebuke for the women’s focus on the quilt reinforces the ideas established through the previous scene of Mr. Henderson’s criticism of Minnie’s housekeeping: the men dismiss and laugh at the women, Mrs. Hale is resentful of this, and Mrs. Peters tries to excuse the men for their unkind treatment. Mrs. Hale’s act of re-sewing the quilt shows both how Minnie was in some kind of emotional distress and that Mrs. Hale is willing to conceal aspects of Minnie’s situation from the men.

What does George Henderson say about the murder of John Wright?

The women then overhear the men talking as they come down the stairs. George Henderson is saying that the murder is all perfectly clear except for a motive, a reason for killing John Wright in such a strange way. The attorney says he’ll stay at the house longer and go over everything again. Mr. Peters asks if he wants to look over what Mrs. Peters is taking to Minnie in jail, but the attorney says that she’s trustworthy because, after all, “a sheriff’s wife is married to the law.”

What is the metaphor of the knotted quilt?

The metaphor of the knotted quilt demonstrates the women’s certainty that Minnie killed her husband by strangulation, an act suggested by the term “to knot.”. The men, meanwhile, still see the quilt as just a “trifle” and don’t at all get the significance of what the women are saying.

What is the dead bird in Minnie?

More broadly, though, Mrs. Hale sees instantly that the dead bird is more than mere evidence of motive: it also shows the pattern of emotional abuse Minnie endured at Wright’s hands. She instinctively hides the bird from the men (who for their part are still mocking the women for their interest in the quilt), because she knows they will see it only as evidence of motive rather than evidence of abuse, and because in light of what she now knows she feels a stronger loyalty to Minnie than to the men .

What does the overheard conversation of the men reemphasize?

The overheard conversation of the men reemphasizes the importance of what the women have found: the one remaining piece of evidence. Mr. Henderson’s decision to trust Mrs. Peters is an act of further belittlement: he does not think her capable of deception, and he believes her subject to the will of her husband, and therefore the law. He sees her, essentially, as belonging to her husband. But of course that is exactly the sort of thinking that ultimately led Minnie to murder her husband.

What does the apron in Minnie Wright's house reveal?

The details of Minnie Wright’s house reveal much about her relationship with her husband, as well as the way her marriage restricted her joy, her possessions, and isolated her. The men are blind to, and completely uncaring about, all of this contextual understanding. The apron Minnie’s wants shows that she is unable to let go of her assigned responsibilities as a woman, despite the situation.

Why does Minnie hide the bird from the men?

She instinctively hides the bird from the men (who for their part are still mocking the women for their interest in the quilt), because she knows they will see it only as evidence of motive rather than evidence of abuse, and because in light of what she now knows she feels a stronger loyalty to Minnie than to the men.

What did Trump call the men and women behind the cameras?

The men and women behind the cameras exchanged wide-eyed looks and shrugs and did nothing. Trump called them liars, cowards, snakes. The whole amphitheater turned to them and booed, cursing them, throwing up double middle-fingers.

What is the irony of the whole thing?

The deepest irony of the whole thing was being surrounded by people who mock underprivileged minorities for seeking autonomous "safe spaces" while crying for the government to build a literal wall around them all and kill every single person they're afraid of.

Who did Trump trash?

Trump had spend most of his time trashing Marco Rubio -- "Little Marco" -- and the crowd was more amped than ever to see that trashing through. Trump is a showman, exceptional at getting people excited about what he says.

Did Trump say "get em outta here"?

Sometimes he'd say "get 'em outta here" but he didn't have to say it, people knew what to do. People wanted to do it. Then he'd pick right back up where he left off without missing a beat. It was a compelling display of power -- Trump just standing there and watching as a dissenting voice grew dimmer with distance and got drowned out by jeers.