why didn't amanda knox have an attorney when she was being questioned by police?

by Sandy Kuhn 8 min read

Amanda did not have a lawyer present during her interrogation. She was told it would be worse for her if she did. Amanda was told that she was being questioned as a witness but she was clearly being interrogated as a suspect.

She was confronted by aggressive police officers who were accusing her of a horrible crime that she didn't commit. Amanda was terrified. Amanda did not have a lawyer present during her interrogation. She was told it would be worse for her if she did.

Full Answer

What really happened to Amanda Knox?

The Italian supreme court ruled that the interrogation of Amanda Knox was inadmissible in the trial. The court stated that the interrogation was illegal because Amanda did not have an attorney present. The civil trial was running at the same time as the murder trial so the same jury had the results of the illegal interrogation read to them anyway.

How did Amanda Knox behave after Meredith Kercher’s murder?

Sep 30, 2016 · Why the Amanda Knox Case Still Doesn't Make Any Sense: Inside a Shockingly Misogynistic Murder Investigation After Knox became the victim of a prosecutor with a very salacious take on the case and ...

Was Amanda Knox's guilt determined by preponderance of evidence?

Jan 24, 2019 · The European Court of Human Rights ordered the country to pay Knox nearly $21,000 for failing to provide legal assistance and an interpreter when police initially questioned her in a 2007 murder case.

Why was Amanda Knox so susceptible to Italian officials?

Dec 20, 2020 · Knox's defenders say that they didn't because if she passed, their case would have been weakened and discredited, so it wasn't to their advantage to do so. What do you think? How accurate are lie detector tests and why aren't they admissable in court?

See more

Jun 13, 2014 · A third indication that Giuliano MIgnini and the Italian police intentionally framed Amanda Knox and Raffaele Solelcito in the murder of Meredith Kercher can be seen in the manner of evidence collection and avoidance. Simply by looking at the Prosecutor Mignini’s selectivity in regard to the evidence of the crime – what to examine or …

Was Amanda Knox compensated for her wrongful conviction?

Ms. Knox and her boyfriend, Raffaele Sollecito, were ultimately acquitted of that crime, with Europe's top human rights court ruling that she had been deprived of adequate legal aid during an interrogation, and that the DNA evidence used to convict her was flawed. It ordered Italy to pay her $21,000 in damages.Nov 8, 2021

How long was Amanda Knox interrogation?

Amanda Knox has revealed why she initially lied and told Italian police she was in the apartment when her roommate Meredith Kercher was killed in November 2007. Sitting down with JuJu Chang on Friday's Nightline, Knox explained that Italian police broke her down during a grueling 53-hour interrogation.Dec 2, 2020

What did Amanda Knox say about Patrick Lumumba?

They found a text-message on my phone that I'd sent to my boss, Patrick Lumumba. He'd given me the night off work that day in question, & I'd written him, in my broken Italian, “Ci vediamo piu tardi. Buona serata.”

Did Amanda Knox Get Married?

Knox and Robinson got engaged in November 2018. They went on to tie the knot in February 2020.Oct 22, 2021

How did Rudy Guede know Meredith?

Guede admitted he was in Meredith's room at the time of the attack. His DNA, along with Meredith's blood, was found on Meredith's purse. His shoeprints, set in Meredith's blood, were found in the bedroom and in the hallway leading out the front door.

Where is Amanda Knox now?

After spending almost four years in an Italian prison, Knox returned to Seattle, where she grew up and lived before her conviction. Since being acquitted of murder charges, the 34-year-old has been working with the Innocence Project, a non-profit organization dedicated to putting an end to wrongful convictions.Oct 22, 2021

Is Amanda Knox rich?

Amanda Knox net worth: Amanda Knox is an American author who has a net worth of $500 thousand. Amanda is best-known for being convicted and eventually exonerated in the 2007 murder of Meredith Kercher....Amanda Knox Net Worth.Net Worth:$500 ThousandGender:FemaleHeight:5 ft 4 in (1.63 m)Nationality:United States of America1 more row

Where is Nick Pisa now?

The SunAccording to Muck Rack, Pisa is currently listed as a journalist with The Sun. Pisa, who can notoriously take credit for the term "Foxy Knoxy", which was used to describe Knox by many outlets during the trials, seems to still be reporting, albeit not on Knox's case.Sep 30, 2016

Who was Amanda Knox?

A top European court has found faults in how Italian police initially questioned Amanda Knox, an American who was imprisoned for nearly four years in Italy after her roommate was killed, and ordered Italy to pay her damages.

Why did Italy pay Amanda Knox?

Italy Ordered To Pay Damages To Amanda Knox The European Court of Human Rights ordered the country to pay Knox nearly $21,000 for failing to provide legal assistance and an interpreter when police initially questioned her in a 2007 murder case.

How much did Italy pay Knox?

The court ordered Italy to pay Knox nearly $21,000 (18,400 euros) in damages, costs and expenses. Knox's lawyers first filed the complaint with Europe's human rights court ...

What happened to Meredith Kercher?

The decision examines what happened on Nov. 6, 2007, when police questioned Knox at 5:45 a.m. about the death of Meredith Kercher, a British student studying in Perugia who had been found days earlier with her throat slashed in the apartment she shared with Knox.

Sunday, December 20, 2020

If you've studied the infamous and controversial Amanda Knox true crime case, involving her and her boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito's public trial, incarceration and acquittal for the murder of her roommate Meredith Kercher, you may confused because the evidence doesn't stack up and seems conflicting and confusing.

Amanda Knox: Evidence Lists of Her GUILT or Involvement in Meredith Kercher's Murder - Best Summaries From True Crime Buffs

If you've studied the infamous and controversial Amanda Knox true crime case, involving her and her boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito's public trial, incarceration and acquittal for the murder of her roommate Meredith Kercher, you may confused because the evidence doesn't stack up and seems conflicting and confusing.

Who killed Meredith Kercher?

To be clear, there is quite literally no conceivable way Amanda Knox is responsible for the murder of Meredith Kercher. Period. Not possible. And yet, Amanda Knox spent almost four years in Italian prison for a crime it is extraordinarily obvious she did not commit.

Where did Meredith Kercher live?

  • ] Meredith Kercher was an exchange student from England sharing an apartment with Amanda Knox, an exchange student from the U.S., in Perugia, Italy, a town of about 150,000 people.

What is your heart will heal?

Your Heart Will Heal—A Gentle Guided Journal For Getting Over Anyone, by Chrissy Stockton, will help you uncover inner peace and the strength to move on. Process every stage of your breakup: shock, denial, grief, sadness, insecurity, and anger while feeling supported and loved through your pain. Make this guided journal your trusted friend during your journey to feeling whole again.

Was Amanda Knox a true crime?

It’s not that the murder was especially difficult to solve, they actually caught the guy who did it and he’s in jail. The strange thing about this case is the Italian police’s (and subsequently, the international media’s) extreme fascination with Amanda Knox and insistence that she was a viable suspect despite a mountain of evidence to the contrary.

How long was Amanda Knox in jail?

Many people found Knox’s demeanor to be cold and calculating. So Amanda Knox spent four years in prison (and another four years waiting to be declared officially innocent) for the crime of behaving unpredictably—for being mismatched. But being weird is not a crime.

Who is Amanda Penn?

Amanda Penn is a writer and reading specialist. She’s published dozens of articles and book reviews spanning a wide range of topics, including health, relationships, psychology, science, and much more. Amanda was a Fulbright Scholar and has taught in schools in the US and South Africa.

Was Amanda Knox convicted of murder?

Was Amanda Knox guilty? The arrest and conviction of Amanda Knox was a sensation in the media and tabloids. But it doesn’t make sense that Amanda Knox was implicated in the murder.

An international incident

In case you don't recall all the details, Knox was accused (along with her boyfriend at the time, Raffaele Sollecito) of the savage murder of Ms. Kercher, her roommate and fellow exchange student. Kercher was from Britain; Knox from Seattle.

Amanda's strange behavior

There were admittedly some reasons for the Italian police to be suspicious. A scary thing about criminal trials, and one of the scariest things about this case, is how much of what we think of as the truth turns on perception—and perceptions can be distorted, or simply not reflect reality.

Theories of devil worship

Cases of devil worship leading up to murder have been greatly exaggerated in the popular consciousness.

An overzealous prosecutor

The more we learn about the context of the Amanda Knox trial, the weirder things tend to get, and nothing is stranger, perhaps, than the scorch-the-earth tactics that Italian prosecutor Giuliano Mignini brought to the trial. For American audiences, the zeal with which Mignini attacked Knox blurred the lines between prosecution and persecution.

A theory of three killers

The evidence, in retrospect, seems to sensibly point one way. Male footprints, no forced entry, a stabbing in the bedroom, a murder scene wiped clean.

The guilt of Rudy Guede

The most shocking thing about the trials is that they went forward after someone else was already convicted of the murder.

The media's incendiary reaction

" This has gotten out of hand ." Such was Knox's reaction, delivered in writing, to having been tried in absentia and convicted of murder a second time in 2014. Talk about an understatement—it was out of hand well long before.

Background

  • [*] Meredith Kercher was an exchange student from England sharing an apartment with Amanda Knox, an exchange student from the U.S., in Perugia, Italy, a town of about 150,000 people. [*] In mid-October 2007 Kercher and Knox met a 20-year-old man named Rudy Guede who was friends with the men who lived in the apartment below them. Guede was homeless and known to have c…
See more on thoughtcatalog.com

The Murder

  • [*] On November 2, 2007 Knox returned home from spending the night with her Italian boyfriend Raffaele Sollecito and found the front door of her apartment ajar. Inside the apartment, Knox noticed drops of blood in the shared bathroom. Because Meredith’s bedroom door was locked, Knox assumed she was sleeping and showered and left the apartment. Later in the day, she retu…
See more on thoughtcatalog.com

Evidence Against Rudy Guede

  • [*] Guede’s fingerprints were found all over the crime scene in Meredith’s bedroom. Guede claimed that he had a date with Kercher on the night of her murder and that the two ended up in her bedroom where they exchanged a consensual kiss before deciding not to have sex because they did not have a condom. He claims he then had stomach pains and went to the bathroom in the a…
See more on thoughtcatalog.com

Police Fixation on Amanda Knox

  • [*] Knox was detained and interviewed by police (in her non-native language, Italian) for four dayswithout being given access to a lawyer. [*] Knox testified that during this time she was physically abused by the policeand coerced into giving false information when they became unsatisfied with her real story. Because of this coercion, Knox says she ended up giving false inf…
See more on thoughtcatalog.com

Reversal

  • [*] In March 2015 the highest court in Italy ruled that both Amanda Knox and Raffaele Sollecito were innocent of all charges related to Meredith Kercher’s murder. The court found that there was literally no evidence that Knox or Sollecito were present in Meredith’s room at the time of the murder and that the DNA evidence cleanly pointed to Rudy Guede acting alone.
See more on thoughtcatalog.com

So… What Happened?

  • The murder of Meredith Kercher is an open and shut case. Rudy Guede was convicted of the murder in an Italian court and is serving time. Why were the police so obsessed with Amanda and her boyfriend? Well, this isn’t the first time Italian police have demonstrated a bizarre fixation on a foreign suspect despite there being literally no evidence to support the fixation. Douglas Presto…
See more on thoughtcatalog.com