why did traffic attorney ask me citizenship status before hiring him

by Amely Abernathy MD 8 min read

Is it illegal for an employer to ask about citizenship status?

workers are protected from citizenship status discrimination by contacting IER and at 8 U.S.C. §§ 1324b(a)(1), (3). 3. May I ask applicants for citizenship or immigration status information? Generally, an employer may ask job applicants if they have the legal right to work in the United States and if they will need sponsorship for an

Can an employer reject a job applicant based on citizenship?

May 31, 2019 · The Immigration Reform and Control Act makes it illegal to treat job candidates differently based on their citizenship status. It’s illegal for an employer to discriminate based on citizenship in any part of the employment process, whether in recruiting, hiring, disciplining, or firing. Yet, it's also illegal to employ an unauthorized worker.

Can an employer refuse to hire a non-citizen?

Hiring a citizenship lawyer can help avoid green card problems After an immigrant obtains a permanent resident green card, the green card can be revoked for any number of actual or perceived criminal or immigration violations. Typically, the permanent resident is not notified that they have placed their green card in jeopardy. Instead, they first […]

What is discrimination based on citizenship?

Oct 06, 2014 · The notion of an "illegal question" is not as clear as you appear to believe. As a matter of good practice, an employer should not ask whether a job applicant is a U.S. Citizen before making an officer of employment because it is unlawful to discriminate in hiring based upon an applicant's citizenship or immigration status -- but asking the question of itself does …

What does it mean when an application asks for citizenship?

The country in which a person is born in, or naturalized that protects and to which that person owes allegiance.

Can a traffic violation affect citizenship?

Driving points can affect your U.S. citizenship status, but generally, the points you receive on your license from standard moving violations – like speeding or making an illegal turn – aren't severe enough for USCIS to deny you citizenship.

Can employers require U.S. citizenship?

Generally not. A “U.S. citizens-only” policy in hiring is illegal. An employer may require U.S. citizenship for a particular job only if it is required by federal, state, or local law, or by government contract.

Can you ask someone if they are U.S. citizen?

Most employers should not ask whether or not a job applicant is a United States citizen before making an offer of employment. ... Federal law also prohibits employers from conducting the Form I-9 and E-Verify processes before the employee has accepted an offer of employment.

What does have you ever been cited mean?

If you were dismissed, cited, or issued a court date to pay a fine, usually that doesn't indicate an ARREST. It does mean that you were detained and cited. But, you didn't get “booked.” So to speak.Mar 4, 2019

Does speeding ticket affect citizenship Canada?

As mentioned above, traffic tickets are not indictable offences and will not have any impact on your application.Feb 22, 2018

Is it illegal to ask citizenship status?

Citizenship: Inquiries about an individual's citizenship or county of birth are prohibited and can be perceived as discrimination on the basis the individual's national origin. Applicants cannot be discriminated against based on their citizenship status, except in rare circumstances when required by federal contract.

Is it illegal to ask immigration status?

The Immigration Reform and Control Act requires you to verify your employees' eligibility status, even those you know to be U.S. citizens. However, the same Act prohibits you from asking people to prove their citizenship or work status before offering them employment.Jun 28, 2021

Do employers have to verify citizenship?

Federal law requires employers to follow Form I-9 and E-Verify rules consistently, regardless of an employee's citizenship, immigration status, or national origin.Feb 15, 2019

How do I legally ask about my citizenship status?

The primary way of asking about citizenship status is to have the employee fill out IRS Form I-9, “Employment Eligibility Verification,” no later than his or her first day of work for pay.Jan 29, 2015

Can you ask citizenship status in interview?

Generally, California employers may not ask you about your citizenship status during an interview. After you receive a job offer, though, employers must work to verify your identity and work eligibility.Mar 14, 2019

How do employers verify citizenship?

Use Form I-9 to verify the identity and employment authorization of individuals hired for employment in the United States. All U.S. employers must properly complete Form I-9 for each individual they hire for employment in the United States. This includes citizens and noncitizens.Apr 13, 2021

What documents are required for an I-9?

The I-9 Form regulates what types of documents an employer can request and how many the job candidate is required to supply. There are three lists of acceptable, unexpired documents that an employee can choose from: 1 List A – Documents that establish both identity and employment authorization. 2 List B – Documents that establish identity. 3 List C – Documents that establish employment authorization.

What is discrimination based on citizenship?

Discrimination based on citizenship, on the other hand, occurs when individuals are treated differently because of their citizenship or immigration status. In the hiring process, this typically occurs when: An unlawful method is used to verify a job applicant’s eligibility to work in the United States.

What is the IRCA?

The Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (IRCA) is the federal law that makes it illegal to treat job candidates differently based on citizenship (8 U.S.C. §1324a). It covers the verification process that must be followed in determining whether someone is legally authorized to work and what records must be kept.

What is the purpose of the 1-9 form?

The 1-9 Form is available on the US Citizenship and Immigrations Services website and is the tool employers must use to verify that a job candidate is authorized to work in the U.S. The I-9 Form regulates what types of documents an employer can request and how many the job candidate is required to supply. There are three lists of acceptable, ...

What is the Immigration Reform and Control Act?

The Immigration Reform and Control Act applies to employers with four or more employees and protects U.S. citizens and nationals against discrimination. It does not cover independent contractors and domestic services workers who sporadically work in private homes.

What is an e-verify form?

Some state and federal laws require employers to participate in the E-Verify process, which confirms work-authorization by comparing information on the I-9 Form to records maintained by the Department of Homeland Security and the Social Security Administration.

Can a permanent resident get a green card?

After an immigrant obtains a permanent resident green card, the green card can be revoked for any number of actual or perceived criminal or immigration violations. Typically, the permanent resident is not notified that they have placed their green card in jeopardy. Instead, they first become aware of their deportability only after submitting fingerprints for a replacement green card (I-90), removal of conditions (I-751) or citizenship. But, by then it is too late. Once labeled by USCIS as being in violation of immigration laws, the permanent resident will be placed in removal proceedings and could be deported. The only way to avoid such a situation is to have never applied for the benefit in the first place.

Can a lawyer help with citizenship?

Nervousness can lead an innocent applicant to appear evasive or dishonest. A citizenship lawyer can accompany an applicant to his or her citizenship interview and can help set the tone for a successful interview. The citizenship lawyer can also address any issues that may arise concerning residency, physical presence, or moral character.

Is it illegal to ask a job applicant if they are a US citizen?

The notion of an "illegal question" is not as clear as you appear to believe. As a matter of good practice, an employer should not ask whether a job applicant is a U.S. Citizen before making an officer of employment because it is unlawful to discriminate in hiring based upon an applicant's citizenship or immigration status -- but asking the question of itself does not create a cause of action against the employer. It's only if the employer later commits, or can plausibly be accused of committing, an act of discrimination that the question comes into play as evidence of the employer's knowledge and intent. Illegal questions make it easy for a savvy job applicant to file a lawsuit, and for that lawsuit to result in a settlement or verdict in favor of the worker, even if the employer in fact rejected the applicant for unrelated reasons.#N#Once a job offer is made, the employer can ask for and verify immigration status and eligibility to work. It would be terribly awkward for an applicant who lied in relation to the same questions during the application process to suddenly tell the truth after receiving the offer, and revoking the offer based upon the employee's having lied during the application process would not constitute discrimination based upon the applicant's citizenship or immigration status. Similarly, if the applicant lied again upon receiving the job offer, the employer would be entirely justified in firing the employee when the truth came to light.#N#As for trying to play games with a question about the future need for sponsorship, that would be foolish. Once the applicant is hired, the employee is required to verify his eligibility to work and will find out that he's on F1 OPT. The employee can try arguing until he's blue in the face that he didn't actually lie, because he might rub a magic lamp, have a visa genii emerge and be granted some form of status that allows him to continue to work without being sponsored for an employment visa, but odds are the employer is going to view him has having lied and will be free to terminate his employment on that basis.

Does an EAD card expire?

Your EAD card expires. You would require sponsorship in the future. Lying on the application is grounds for termination. Hell could freeze over also. There is no way you are going to marry a US citizen and get through the denial and waiver process before you EAD card expired.

Can you play word games in your mirror?

You can go play word games in your mirror for all I care. File an EEOC complaint and hope you get somewhere before you must leave the US or continue making circular arguments to a local lawyer.

Cameron Sean Huey

1. T he attorney cannot talk during the interview or during the test. However, I went for a client to explain a criminal history and my client was granted citizenship because fo a very old prior infraction due to no records. I always, ALWAYS advise clients who have traveled more than a few times or who have criminal histories to bring an attorney.

Barbara A. Marcouiller

In over 21 years of experience, I have seen that the presence of an attorney seems particularly helpful for older females. It makes a big difference in confidence level to have someone sitting at your side, even though what that person is allowed to do is limited.

Anthony Stroik

Welcome back! You can see the variety of answers so far. Even though there is disagreement about whether it is a yes or a no, reasons on both sides of the disagreement are sound.

David L Le Roy

It is true that an attorney is not allowed to "testify" for the client. The attorneys role is to ensure that the questioning is relevant, fair, and to facilitate the interview by clarifying confusions between the client and the officer as well as to answer and clarify any and all legal related issues.

Rehim Babaoglu

An immigration attorney's presence always helps at interviews. I don't allow my clients to go without me. The attorney can ask to have the question rephrased or asked another way such that the client may better understand it.

Liya Djamilova

No, an attorney will not be able to help her to understand the questions. What attorney can do is to make sure that the officer who conducts the interview evaluates it properly without any prejudice to your mother and if she answered sufficiently, the officer would take it as such.

Irene Vaisman

The attorney cannot answer the questions for her. The attorney can answer questions that deal with the legal theory of the case, but the personal once.