why an attorney shouldn't negotiate an osha case

by Kyla Harber I 10 min read

Involving an OSHA attorney creates a barrier between OSHA and the company, which requires OSHA to communicate with the attorney and not company representatives. This limits communication between OSHA and the company representatives, ensuring that the information provided to OSHA is accurate, appropriate, and properly tracked.

Full Answer

What happens if you contest an OSHA citation?

 · If you involve an OSHA attorney, that attorney will act as the “bad guy,” telling OSHA “no” when appropriate, which allows company representatives to maintain a good relationship with OSHA. OSHA understands that part of an OSHA attorney’s job is saying “no,” so they view push back from an OSHA attorney as the attorney doing his or her job, not trying to …

Can OSHA bring criminal charges against an employer?

 · When workplace accidents happen, OSHA may review the situation and fine the business for lapses in safety practices. The intent of these fines is to ensure that companies and employers are accountable for practices that may endanger the safety of workers. However, there are times when OSHA may be willing to negotiate these fines down.

Can OSHA issue criminal sanctions for workplace safety violations?

 · OSHA fines are categorized as willful when the company committed the violation with either an intentional disregard of or plain indifference to OSHA regulations. “It takes a lot to be plainly indifferent,” the DC Circuit Court wrote in its opinion. Now, in a blog post, attorney Shannon Young of Harmon & Davies writes this decision “gives ...

Did you know OSHA is referring safety violations to district attorneys?

treatment, the cases are OSHA recordable. For example, an employee hurts his back at work but chooses to keep working without reporting it. That night at home, his back feels worse, so the employee visits a local urgent care clinic. The doctor there prescribes pain medication, which makes the case OSHA

Are OSHA fines negotiable?

OSHA may negotiate lower penalties in exchange for fixing things specifically addressed in the citation. It is not always possible to negotiate fines with OSHA.

How do you fight an OSHA citation?

the OSHA area office listed on the Citation and Notification of Penalty. If you wish to contest any portion of your citation, you must submit a Notice of Intent to Contest in writing to the OSHA area office within 15 working days after receipt of the Citation and Notification of Penalty.

Are OSHA settlements confidential?

Response: Currently, the settlement agreements on the OSHA web site are major agreements the Agency has entered into and are public information.

What are the disadvantages of the OSHA law?

OSHA's VPP encourages employee participation, yet this becomes a disadvantage to employers. The National Labor Relations Act may complicate employee involvement along with giving employees too much control over workplace issues. This can develop into management and employee disagreements over health and safety issues.

Can OSHA shut down a company?

OSHA officials can order work to stop if they find a severe risk on-site, but contrary to popular belief, they don't have the authority to shut down a business entirely. Only a court order can do that.

What are the reasons for contesting an OSHA fine instead of simply paying the fine?

Among the specific grounds for an appeal are the following: the safety order was not violated, the classification of the alleged violation (e.g., serious, repeat, willful) is incorrect, the abatement requirements are unreasonable or the proposed penalty is unreasonable.

Why is OSHA ineffective?

More than 90% of current permissible exposure limits date to industry consensus standards set in the 1960s, and there are no permissible exposure limits for the vast majority of chemicals used in today's workplace; OSHA's attempts to address this have been unsuccessful.

Is OSHA strict?

Since 1973, Cal/OSHA has been issuing standards that are considered more stringent than federal OSHA's baseline. In some cases, a state program will include statutes regarding specific hazards that federal OSHA does not address at all.

Who is over OSHA?

the United States Department of LaborOSHA is part of the United States Department of Labor. The administrator for OSHA is the Assistant Secretary of Labor for Occupational Safety and Health.

Is a case recordable if an employee is injured?

If an employee is injured and is sent home or placed on light duty for the remainder of the shift, the case is not recordable - as long as the employee can return to routine duties the next calendar day and no recordable medical treatment is rendered.

Is a medical case recordable?

Recordability is based on the doctor’s opinion, not the employee’s actions. If a medical provider states that an employee can work, but the employee chooses to stay home anyway, the case is not recordable.

Is horseplay a work related activity?

Voluntary recreation on the premises is not work-related; horseplay on the premises is work-related. Ensure that your employees know what is acceptable in this area and what is not.

What is restricted duty?

Restricted duty occurs when an employee cannot perform all routine duties at least once per week. Current job descriptions will describe all routine duties and assist with quick decisions about what is (and is not) restricted duty.

Read Next

A food manufacturer has been cited and is facing $107,000 in proposed fines from federal workplace safety regulators after an employee died from a 24-foot fall.

Food company cited on forklift safety after worker death

A food manufacturer has been cited and is facing $107,000 in proposed fines from federal workplace safety regulators after an employee died from a 24-foot fall.

Is OSHA good or bad?

The good OSHA is the one that brings us wonderful things like the Web site. The bad OSHA is the one that enforces regulations that are 30 or more years out of date, and the ugly OSHA is the one whose behavior is, on occasion, reprehensible.

What are the OSHA regulations?

Anyone who's been to OSHA's Web site knows that, in the words of Virgil's Aeneas, "It is a sight wondrous to behold." The site is exceptionally easy to navigate and is a veritable gold mine of occupational safety and health information. Some of the site's attractive features: 1 The most up-to-date edition of the regulations, including hundreds of letters of interpretation related to enforcement policy. 2 The Field Inspection Reference Manual, which describes the agency's inspection procedures. 3 The OSHA Technical Manual, which is a treasure trove of information on topics such as air sampling, noise monitoring, indoor air quality, laser safety and heat stress. 4 Preambles to standards that provide an explanation and commentary on the regulatory requirements. 5 A subject index covering topics that range from asbestos to zinc with thousands of links to other useful safety and health resources.

Who said it is a sight wondrous to behold?

Anyone who's been to OSHA's Web site knows that, in the words of Virgil's Aeneas, "It is a sight wondrous to behold." The site is exceptionally easy to navigate and is a veritable gold mine of occupational safety and health information. Some of the site's attractive features:

What is the OSHA Technical Manual?

The OSHA Technical Manual, which is a treasure trove of information on topics such as air sampling, noise monitoring, indoor air quality, laser safety and heat stress. Preambles to standards that provide an explanation and commentary on the regulatory requirements.

What is voluntary protection program?

The Voluntary Protection Programs (VPP) recognizes that good safety management programs that go beyond OSHA standards can protect workers more effectively than simple compliance. Participation in OSHA's VPP requires facilities to be committed to excellence and to focus on more than mere regulatory compliance.

Is OSHA outdated?

As noted above, OSHA's new and revised standards may be state-of-the-art, but most of its other standards are woefully outdated. Many OSHA standards are based on 1960s-vintage national consensus standards, many of which have been revised dozens of times since being adopted by the agency in 1972. Permissible exposure limits (PELs) are perhaps the best-known example.

Who is Susan Harwood?

Susan Harwood Grants. Susan Harwood was an outstanding figure in the safety and health community who, before her death in 1996, spent eight years as director of OSHA's Office of Risk Assessment.

What are the penalties for OSH violations?

They include a fine of not more than $10,000 or imprisonment for not more than six months, or by both for the first offense.

What is the purpose of the OSH Act?

Under the OSH Act, the agency can bring criminal charges against an employer for: Willful violations causing an employee’s death;

What is a willful citation?

By definition, a willful citation means deliberate indifference to the facts or law, of which the employer has actual knowledge or actual knowledge of significant risks coupled knowledge of the necessary steps to avoid the risks.