when does the us attorney assert jurisdiction over a crime federal veresus state

by Amari Torp 10 min read

When instances are reported to the United States Attorney of offenses committed on land or in buildings occupied by agencies of the Federal government -- unless the crime reported is a Federal offense regardless of where committed, such as assault on a Federal officer or possession of narcotics -- the United States has jurisdiction only if the land or building is within the special territorial jurisdiction of the United States.

Full Answer

When does a federal court have jurisdiction in a case?

Jan 22, 2020 · When instances are reported to the United States Attorney of offenses committed on land or in buildings occupied by agencies of the Federal government -- unless the crime reported is a Federal offense regardless of where committed, such as assault on a Federal officer or possession of narcotics -- the United States has jurisdiction only if the land or building is …

What is the relationship between jurisdiction and venue in criminal cases?

Jul 05, 2010 · The feds try to stick to enforcing federal laws. They'll get involved in state/local cases under certain circumstances, such as child abductions, kidnappings (including adults), bank robbery, or when jurisdictional issues across states become problematic and their assistance is requested to take over the case for federal prosecution.

Can a US citizen assert jurisdiction in another country?

Mar 18, 2017 · At times, federal and state courts may share jurisdiction over certain cases. The parties involved in such matters can choose whether to take them to state or federal courts. Such things occur when state and federal laws overlap, which happens often when federal laws stem from the Commerce Clause .

When to take a case to state or federal court?

In many instances, state courts can hear matters of federal law, and federal courts can hear matters of state law, provided, in both instances, that certain conditions are met. State courts often limit their jurisdiction based on the amount in question or the types of claims brought. So, for example, lawsuits over amounts of less than $15,000 ...

What is the difference between state and federal jurisdiction when it comes to criminal law?

Generally speaking, state courts hear cases involving state law and federal courts handle cases involving federal law. Most criminal cases are heard in state court because most crimes are violations of state or local law.Aug 30, 2019

What is a key difference between state and federal prosecutors?

Prosecutors. Federal criminal prosecutions are handled by U.S. attorneys, who are appointed by and ultimately responsible to the U.S. Attorney General. State prosecutors—sometimes called district, state, county, or city attorneys—prosecute violations of state and local law.

What is the difference between a federal crime and a state crime?

Federal crimes are prosecuted by Assistant U.S. Attorneys and investigated by federal officers, such as FBI, DEA, or ICE agents. State crimes are investigated by county sheriffs, state agents, or local police officers, and prosecuted by state district attorneys or city attorneys.

What determines federal jurisdiction?

State court territorial jurisdiction is determined by the Due Process Clause of the Constitution's Fourteenth Amendment and the federal court territorial jurisdiction is determined by the Due Process Clause of the Constitution's Fifth Amendment.

When both the state court and the federal court has jurisdiction it is called?

The authority to hear certain cases is called. jurisdiction. When both the state court and the federal court have jurisdiction, it is called. concurrent jurisdiction.

Why are most criminal cases heard in state courts rather than federal courts?

State courts have broad jurisdiction, so the cases individual citizens are most likely to be involved in -- such as robberies, traffic violations, broken contracts, and family disputes -- are usually tried in state courts.

Is criminal law state or federal?

At the state level, criminal laws are passed by state governing bodies or can stem from a state's constitution. At the federal level, criminal laws are passed by the U.S. Congress or stem from the Constitution.Mar 18, 2017

Is a felony a federal crime?

Felonies can be committed at either the federal or state level. A federal felony is investigated by agencies like the FBI or DEA, and prosecuted by the US Attorney General.

Do federal and state investigations of crime use the same procedures?

Federal and state investigations of crime use the same procedures. Criminal defendants may be freed at one of many points throughout the criminal justice process. An arrest is not a seizure under the Fourth Amendment.

Who has jurisdiction over legal matters between states?

The Judicial Power shall extend to all Cases, in Law and Equity, arising under this Constitution, the Laws of the United States, and Treaties made, or which shall be made, under their Authority;—to all Cases affecting Ambassadors, other public Ministers and Consuls;—to all Cases of admiralty and maritime Jurisdiction; ...

What factors determine which federal court has jurisdiction over a case?

Federal courts have jurisdiction over cases involving:the United States government,the Constitution or federal laws, or.controversies between states or between the U.S. government and foreign governments.

What two conditions must exist for federal courts to have diversity jurisdiction?

The two requirements for federal courts to exercise diversity jurisdiction are: (1) the plaintiff and defendant must be citizens of different states; and (2) the amount in controversy must be greater than $75,000, exclusive of interest and costs.

What is federal jurisdiction?

Federal crimes require federal jurisdiction. For a crime to be prosecuted in federal court there must be a basis for federal jurisdiction. The federal jurisdiction may be expressly stated in the statute itself, or it may be stated by Congress when the law is enacted. Many federal criminal statutes fall under the Interstate Commerce Clause ...

What is the difference between federal and state crimes?

Federal crimes are investigated by federal law enforcement agencies and are prosecuted by the United States Attorney. The cases are heard by federal judges, appointed by under Article III of the Constitution. State court criminal cases are usually investigated by local or statewide police agencies and are prosecuted by the state attorney’s office (known in some areas as the district attorney.) The cases are heard by the state court judge who may be an elected position or appointed by the governor.

Who hears criminal cases?

The cases are heard by the state court judge who may be an elected position or appointed by the governor. The vast majority of criminal cases are prosecuted in state court because most cases do not have a basis for federal jurisdiction.

What can Congress regulate?

Finally, Congress can regulate conduct that affects interstate commerce even though the conduct is purely intrastate.

What are some examples of federal fraud?

Theft of federal property, income tax fraud, printing counterfeit currency and false statement to a federal agency are a few examples. Mortgage fraud could have federal jurisdiction because false statements are made to a financial institution that is insured by the federal government.

What is white collar crime?

Federal white collar crimes are often committed when false statements are made through the mail or false statements cause money to be transferred by wire. This can be the basis of the federal wire fraud or mail fraud statutes. Drug offenses may be prosecuted in state court or federal court.

What is the jurisdiction of the state courts?

State and local courts have jurisdiction over state and local laws. The jurisdiction of state courts is broad, ranging from minor traffic violations to family disputes, robberies, broken contracts and many serious felonies. Most cases involving most citizens are tried in state courts. The jurisdiction of federal courts includes such things as ...

Who prosecutes federal cases?

When cases go to trial on the federal level, they are prosecuted by a U.S. Attorney or Assistant U.S. Attorney. When cases go to trial at the state or local level, they are prosecuted by a state or district attorney, or by a city attorney.

What is shared jurisdiction?

At times, federal and state courts may share jurisdiction over certain cases. The parties involved in such matters can choose whether to take them to state or federal courts. Such things occur when state and federal laws overlap, which happens often when federal laws stem from the Commerce Clause.#N#Known as “concurrent jurisdiction,” such shared federal and state jurisdiction can have significant impact on a case.#N#Though the Constitution’s Fifth Amendment shields citizens from so-called “double jeopardy,” meaning you can’t be put in jeopardy twice for the same offense, matters in shared or concurrent jurisdiction can provide rare exceptions. That is, if you are tried and acquitted of a state charge, federal prosecutors still could bring the charge to a federal court.#N#How can this be?#N#It’s because the double jeopardy clause of the U.S. Constitution only prevents multiple prosecutions by the same “sovereign” (possessor of power or control). Federal and state governments are considered separate sovereigns, so each can prosecute for the same crime.#N#Houston criminal defense attorney Neal Davis is working to strike down the dual sovereignty option by petitioning the U.S. Supreme Court in the case of former Beaumont ISD contract electrician Calvin Walker. Walker's federal trial on charges of fraud and money-laundering ended in a mistrial, and now state prosecutors want to try him again, which Davis is working to prevent.#N#Federal courts also have jurisdiction to hear cases involving state laws when a state law is argued to be in violation of the U.S. Constitution.

Why is the double jeopardy clause important?

It’s because the double jeopardy clause of the U.S. Constitution only prevents multiple prosecutions by the same “sovereign” ( possessor of power or control). Federal and state governments are considered separate sovereigns, so each can prosecute for the same crime.

What is the difference between federal and state courts?

All courts in America are either federal courts, or state and local courts (for counties, cities or other municipalities). Federal courts have jurisdiction (the authorization to hear cases) over constitutional matters or over federal laws passed by Congress. State and local courts have jurisdiction over state and local laws.

Where are the federal courts located?

Federal courts include district courts (trial courts) and circuit courts (the first level of appeal), which are located throughout the nation as well as the U.S. Supreme Court in Washington, D.C. State courts exist throughout a given state.

What are federal crimes?

In addition, crimes committed on federal property are considered federal crimes. Such property can include federal prisons or courthouses, as well as national parks, Native American reservations and the District of Columbia.

Which courts have exclusive jurisdiction over federal offenses?

In general, federal courts have exclusive jurisdiction over federal offenses, and state courts have exclusive jurisdiction over state offenses. (But some kinds of conduct qualify as both state and federal offenses—see State vs. Federal Prosecution .) Federal criminal jurisdiction commonly arises where:

What is criminal jurisdiction?

In criminal law, it includes the power to impose punishment. Absent jurisdiction, convictions and court-ordered sentences are void. (For an overview of some basic jurisdiction terminology, see What are the kinds of criminal jurisdiction? And, to learn about the relationship between jurisdiction and venue, see Venue .)

What is concurrent jurisdiction?

Concurrent jurisdiction exists where more than one court can claim power to decide a case. For example, more than one state might have jurisdiction where the crime begins in one state and continues into another. Or a crime might occur partly on federal land and partly on non-federal land, giving the state and the federal government jurisdiction.

What is the first in time rule?

In most cases, the first-in-time rule applies. When there are competing claims to jurisdiction, the prosecuting attorneys usually get together and try to reach an agreement about who will "go" first. Talk to a Lawyer. Start here to find criminal defense lawyers near you. Practice Area.

Is a crime within a state's borders a federal offense?

Most crimes that occur within a state's borders, or within three miles of its coastline, are prosecuted in state court. But some federally owned land rests entirely within one state's borders—if a crime occurs on that land, then it's typically a federal offense.

What does "jurisdiction" mean?

As you can see, the term “jurisdiction” can mean a lot of different things in a lot of different settings. For that reason, if you have questions about the various types of jurisdiction that can apply to your case, you should contact a local attorney who can advise you as to the laws related to your particular question. Provided by HG.org.

What are administrative bodies?

These are generally referred to as administrative bodies, and can include both state and federal agencies such as the Federal Communications Commission, the Securities and Exchange Commission, local code enforcement boards, state licensing agencies, and many others. These agencies have jurisdiction as set forth by the laws ...

What is the role of the federal court?

A federal court presides over cases where there are questions about constitutional rights, or when a plaintiff asserts that the grounds for his case arise under federal legislation.

How are private disputes resolved?

Private disputes are resolved through the civil court system, as opposed to the criminal court system. The wronged party files a lawsuit and becomes the plaintiff, and the person against whom accusations are made becomes the defendant. The defendant can make counter claims against the plaintiff. The civil court system can be complex ...

Why is forum shopping important?

When there are multiple courts with jurisdiction, forum shopping is possible so you can choose the court most likely to be favorable to your case. Because the rules of civil procedure are complicated in many ways, it can be difficult to even decide where to file a case, much less to proceed with presenting the strongest claim possible.

What is the purpose of state courts?

State courts are courts of general jurisdiction and most people who become involved in a civil case will have their dispute heard in state court. State courts can preside over cases arising out of state laws, including contract laws and tort laws. This means if you have a real estate dispute; breach of contract dispute; shareholder dispute;

How to contact an Irvine civil litigation attorney?

Give us a call at 866-237-8129 or contact us online to learn more.

Is California a federal court?

The California State Court System and the U.S. federal court system are entirely separate court systems with different judges who preside over different issues. The only time there is crossover and a case moves from one to another is when a defendant petitions to move the case from state to federal court or vice versa and there are grounds ...