what does a plaintiff’s attorney do during re-direct of a witness at trial?

by Ms. Bernita Kuhlman IV 7 min read

When the defendant’s attorney has completed his or her cross-examination of the witness, the plaintiff’s attorney may re-examine the witness. This is called redirect examination (often just called “redirect”.) Redirect examination is usually limited to issues raised during cross-examination.

When examining a witness, the plaintiff's lawyer asks the questions first, and this is called DIRECT EXAMINATION. The defendant's lawyer then CROSS-EXAMINES the witness. Generally, cross-examination is limited to questions concerning matters brought up in direct examination.

Full Answer

What part of the trial process does the plaintiff's attorney ask questions?

After the defendant's attorney completes his or her questions, the plaintiff's attorney can ask questions of the plaintiff's witness. What part of the trial process does the scenario describe? E-arbitration is ________. A plaintiff files a complaint in the proper court. The court then issues a summons.

What happens after the plaintiff's attorney completes the direct examination?

After the plaintiff's attorney completes the direct examination, the defendant's attorney gets to cross-examine the witness. Cross-examination is a fundamental right in the American system of justice.

When can the plaintiff's attorney ask questions of the plaintiff witness?

After the defendant's attorney completes his or her questions, the plaintiff's attorney can ask questions of the plaintiff's witness. What part of the trial process does the scenario describe?

What happens after the opposing attorney calls the witnesses?

After this, the opposing attorney can conduct a final recross examination of the witness, which is limited to the subjects brought up during the redirect. Once the plaintiff's attorney has called all of the plaintiff's witnesses, the defendant's attorney begins calling witnesses.

What does a plaintiff's attorney do during direct examination of a witness?

The plaintiff's attorney does the initial questioning of the witness, which is called direct examination. The purpose of a direct examination is to get the witness to testify about facts that support the plaintiff's case.

What is the purpose of re direct examination?

The general purpose of redirect is to rehabilitate the witness and to explain or rebut any adverse proof, whether direct, circumstantial or inferential that arose during cross-examination.

When an attorney examines his client's witnesses and his client the attorney is engaging in what type of questioning?

direct examinationWhat is “direct examination”? In “direct examination,” an attorney questions a witness to get the witness's account (“testimony”) of what happened during the event that triggered the trial.

What is a basic rule of direct examination?

Lawyers for the plaintiff or the government begin the presentation of evidence by calling witnesses . The questions they ask of the witnesses are direct examination. Direct examination may elicit both direct and circumstantial evidence. Witnesses may testify to matters of fact, and in some instances provide opinions.

What comes after re direct examination?

After cross-examination, the plaintiff's lawyer may again question the witness (this is called REDIRECT), and this may be followed by recross examination. This process of examining and cross-examining witnesses and receiving exhibits continues until the plaintiff's evidence is before the jury.

What are the stages in examination of a witness?

There are three Stages of Examination of Witness, Examination-in-chief, Cross-Examination and Re-examination.

How important are witnesses with regard to the prosecution's case during a trial?

In court trials, witnesses are key components of a case and can help prove the innocence or guilt of a defendant. In criminal and civil cases, witnesses are often summoned to testify in court by a subpoena issued by the defense attorney or the prosecuting attorney.

How do you direct examine a witness?

Prepare. There is absolutely no substitute for hard work. ... Keep it Simple. “Learn to talk like a regular person wherever you are. ... Use Topic Sentences or Headers. ... Personalize the Witness. ... Direct the Focus to the Witness. ... Help the Witness Show, Not Tell, the Jury. ... Start Strong, End Strong, and Address Your Weaknesses.

What is direct and redirect?

Redirect examination, in the United States, is the questioning of a witness who has already provided testimony under oath in response to direct examination as well as cross examination by the opponent.

What questions should be avoided during direct examination?

You should avoid beginning questions with Did, Didn't, Does, Doesn't, Is, Isn't, Aren't, Will, Won't, Can, Can't, Could, Couldn't Would, Wouldn't—these will always call for a yes or no answer.

What type of questions are asked in direct examination?

On direct examination, you will usually only be allowed to ask open-ended questions that do not lead your witnesses in a certain way or influence their answers. “Leading questions,” where you suggest the answer to the question, are not allowed.

Who are the liar type of witnesses?

Hostile & Untrustworthy – These types of witnesses purposely lie in an attempt to disrupt the investigation. If it has been determined that this person is lying, the next step should be to find out why.

What happens after a plaintiff's attorney completes the direct examination?

After the plaintiff's attorney completes the direct examination, the defendant's attorney gets to cross-examine the witness. Cross-examination is a fundamental right in the American system of justice. Generally, cross-examination is limited to matters covered during the direct examination. The attorney may ask leading questions during cross-examination.

What can a plaintiff's attorney ask for in a direct exam?

During direct exams, attorneys can ask witnesses to identify demonstrative evidence, such as documents and photographs and/or to explain what they saw, heard, or did in relation to the case at hand. For example, a plaintiff's attorney in a car accident personal injury lawsuit may call a bystander to testify as to what he or she saw just before, during, and/or after the accident, including what the weather was like, what happened during the accident, and any other details the witness remembers from the day.

What happens after a witness is cross-examined?

After this, the opposing attorney can conduct a final recross examination of the witness, which is limited to the subjects brought up during the redirect.

What does cross examination mean in court?

During cross-examination, the attorney tries to undermine or impeach the witness's credibility by showing that the witness is not reliable or that the witness may have misstated something or even lied during the direct examina tion. For example, if the witness said one thing in an accident report or during a deposition and then testified differently at trial, the defendant's attorney can refer to the previous statements and show inconsistencies in the story.

How to undermine a witness's credibility?

Another way to undermine the witness's credibility is to show that the witness has a stake in the outcome of the case, which might influence the testimony.

What happens when a defendant calls witnesses?

The same procedure is followed as in the plaintiff's presentation of witnesses. The defendant's attorney conducts direct examination of the witnesses, and the plaintiff's attorney will conduct cross-examinations.

What is direct examination?

During direct examination, a judge will have some control over the scope and form of the questions. The judge can stop repetitive questioning and prevent a lawyer from asking leading questions, which imply, suggest, or prompt the witness to give a particular answer. However, a judge won't restrict questions unless the other attorney makes an objection. If the plaintiff's attorney is leading the witness, then the attorney for the "defendant" (the person being sued) can object to the question. After listening to the objection, the judge will either sustain (grant) or overrule (deny) it and allow the witness to answer the question.

What happens after the defendant's attorney completes his or her questions?

after the defendant's attorney completes his or her questions, the plaintiff's attorney can ask questions of the plaintiff's witness...What part of the trial process does the scenario describe?

What happens when a plaintiff files a complaint in the proper court?

a plaintiff files a complaint in the proper court. The court then issues a summons. However, the defendant does not answer the complaint...What is then entered against the defendant

Why does an appellate court reverse a lower court decision?

an appellate court reverses a lower court decision because it finds prejudicial evidence was admitted that was obtaining through an unconstitutional search and seizure...The scenario is an example of which of the follow?

What happens after a witness is sworn in?

After being sworn in, a witness for the plaintiff is questioned by plaintiff's attorney, introducing documents and other evidence the support the plaintiff's case through the witnesses' testimony...What step of the trial process does this scenario describe?

How long does it take for a defendant to answer a written question?

defendant receives a series a detailed written questions asking about her knowledge of the case. The questions must be answered within 60 days of receipt...What type of discovery was served on Defendant?

How do two parties settle a legal dispute?

One of the parties registers her dispute with an online service and then notifies the other party by email of the registration of the dispute. The registering party submits an amount she is willing to accept or pay to the other party. The other party is afforded the opportunity to accept the offer, a settlement have been reached; however, the other party may return a counteroffer. The process continues until a settlement is reached...the scenario best describes which of the following

What is a jury in divorce?

jury instructions. a couple has decided to end their marriage. They meet with a neutral third party, who acts as an intermediary between then to assist in resolving the issues involved in the divorce, including property settlement, payment of alimony, and child support, custody of children, and visitation rights.

What happens when a plaintiff calls all witnesses?

Once the plaintiff has called all of its witnesses and has presented all of its evidence, the plaintiff “rests” its case.

Who is the first witness in a case in the court?

When the plaintiff begins its case-in-chief, it will call its first witness, who, once at the witness stand, is sworn in by either the judge or the clerk of the court. Once the witness is sworn in, the plaintiff’s attorney may begin questioning the witness.

What happens when a jury rests?

Once the plaintiff rests, the jury will leave the courtroom while the parties, the judge, the attorneys, and anyone watching the trial, remain. At this point, the defendant may move the court to order a verdict in its favor. Sometimes called a “motion for a directed verdict” or “motion for judgment as a matter of law”, such a motion asks the court to dispense with either some or all of the rest of the trial. If the court grants the motion, judgment will enter for the defendant. Through such a motion, the defendant will attempt to convince the court that the plaintiff has failed to prove an element of at least one of the claims against it. Said another way, the defendant will try to convince the judge that the plaintiff has failed to establish a prima facie case for one or more of its causes of action.

What happens if a plaintiff files a one count complaint?

If the plaintiff has filed a one-count complaint and does not offer evidence to support every element of the only claim against the defendant, the judge will enter total judgment in the defendant’s favor. If the plaintiff has filed a multiple-count complaint and does not prove an element of one of the claims against the defendant, the judge will enter partial judgment in the defendant’s favor (only as to that claim). For example, where the complaint contained six counts and the plaintiff did not support an element of one of the claims, the court will enter judgment for the defendant as to that particular count; the rest will remain, and the trial will continue as to those other claims.

What is the plaintiff's case in chief?

The plaintiff’s case-in-chief is the time that the plaintiff has the opportunity to present evidence in support of its position. The reason that the plaintiff is the first party to present evidence is that the plaintiff has the burden of proof. What this means is that it is the plaintiff who must prove that the defendant is liable.

What is the purpose of a direct examination?

The purpose of the direct examination is to have the witness tell a story and testify about facts personally known to the witness. When the plaintiff’s attorney has finished his or her direct examination of the witness, the defendant’s attorney has the right to cross-examine the same witness.

How many examinations are there in a witness's testimony?

Most jurisdictions limit a witness' testimony to four examinations – direct, cross, redirect and re-cross. Some jurisdictions will allow, in special circumstances, another re-direct and re-cross. Some jurisdictions also allow the judge to ask the witness questions. In a few jurisdictions, jurors are allowed to examine the witnesses through written questions.

What happens when a plaintiff's attorney rests the case?

Once the plaintiff’s attorney has finished calling all of their witnesses and presenting any other evidence, the plaintiff will rest their case. The defendant then may make a motion for a directed verdict if they believe that the plaintiff did not provide evidence for all of the required elements of their claim.

What happens if a case proceeds beyond a pre-trial motion?

If a case proceeds beyond any pre-trial motions, and the parties do not reach a settlement outside court, the case will be decided at a trial. This happens only in a very small percentage of cases, since most parties prefer to avoid the costs, time, and uncertainty of going through a full trial. Either a judge or a jury can decide a trial in ...

What is a jury pool?

The jury pool consists of a random selection of the population, excluding certain people for whom serving on a jury would be a significant hardship. The judge and the attorneys will go through the process of voir dire to determine which members of the jury pool will serve on the jury. Voir dire is meant to exclude jurors who will be biased based on their relationship to the parties, their knowledge of the case, or their natural sympathy for one side or the other. If a juror appears to be biased, either side can make a challenge for cause to exclude them.

What is a voir dire?

Voir dire is meant to exclude jurors who will be biased based on their relationship to the parties, their knowledge of the case, or their natural sympathy for one side or the other. If a juror appears to be biased, either side can make a challenge for cause to exclude them.

What is the opening statement of a jury?

In the opening statement, each party’s attorney will present their theory of the case, explain the conclusion that they intend the judge or jury to reach, and outline the evidence that they will use to support their case.

What do the jury instructions do?

Before the jury deliberates on the case, they will receive jury instructions to guide their analysis. The attorneys will prepare a proposed set of jury instructions that will describe the law governing the case and explain how the jury should apply the law to the facts. The judge can approve the instructions or modify them as needed.

What happens if the jury cannot reach a decision?

If the jury cannot reach a decision, which is rare, the court will either dismiss the case or set up a new trial. The party who loses at trial has a right to appeal the decision to a higher court, although an appeals court will not make factual determinations and will not hear witness testimony or review new evidence.

Who can ask questions of a plaintiff's witness?

After the defendant's attorney completes his or her questions, the plaintiff's attorney can ask questions of the plaintiff's witness.

What happens when a plaintiff files a complaint in the proper court?

A plaintiff files a complaint in the proper court. The court then issues a summons. However, the defendant does not answer the complaint.

What happens after an arbitration hearing?

After an arbitration hearing is complete, the arbitrator reaches a decision and issues an award. The parties agree in advance to be bound by the arbitrator's decision and remedy. In this situation, the decision and award of the arbitrator cannot be appealed to the courts.

What happens after a plaintiff is sworn in?

After being sworn in, a witness for the plaintiff is questioned by plaintiff's attorney, introducing documents and other evidence that support the plaintiff's case through the witnesses' testimony.

What is the purpose of a legal dispute?

Two parties are engaged in a legal dispute. In order to reach a voluntary settlement of their dispute, they decide to engage in discussions. During these proceedings, the parties make offers and counteroffers to one another. The parties or their attorneys also provide information to the other side in order to assist the other side in reaching an amicable settlement.

What happens when a couple decides to end their marriage?

A couple has decided to end their marriage. They meet with a neutral third party, who acts as an intermediary between them to assist in resolving the issues involved in the divorce, including property settlement, payment of alimony and child support, custody of children, and visitation rights. This third party does not make a decision or an award.

How do two parties settle a legal dispute?

One of the parties registers her dispute with an online service and then notifies the other party by e-mail of the registration of the dispute. The registering party submits an amount she is willing to accept or pay to the other party. The other party is afforded the opportunity to accept the offer. If that party accepts the offer, a settlement has been reached; however, the other party may return a counteroffer. The process continues until a settlement is reached.

What is a witness in a trial?

A witness is someone who has personal knowledge of a situation that may be helpful to the jury in deciding the outcome of the case. This personal knowledge is shared with the judge and jury through a series of questions between the witness and the plaintiff’s attorney or prosecutor. This is called direct examination.

What is expert witness testimony?

Expert witness testimony – Testimony of a person who is qualified to help the jury or judge understand specialized details of the case. Expert witnesses are asked to express their professional opinion during the trial.

How long does it take to get a sentencing hearing?

A criminal defendant who is found guilty, or who voluntarily pleads guilty, is scheduled for a sentencing hearing approximately 90 days after the verdict. This gives the U.S. probation officer time to research and prepare a pre-sentence report for the judge. This report is used by the judge to determine punishment for the crime. The judge’s primary goal is to order punishment that is suitable for the crime committed, but no more than needed. Other goals include keeping the community safe, deterring similar crimes in the future, and rehabilitating the individual to prevent them from committing future crimes. The judge also wants to avoid unfair differences in sentences for similar crimes committed by different defendants. Types of punishment can include imprisonment, house arrest, supervised release, substance abuse treatment, counseling, educational training, payment of fines and/or restitution. When assigning the appropriate punishment, the judge uses the advice of U.S. Sentencing Guidelines . These guidelines take into account the seriousness of the offense, and the criminal history of the person. For some types of crimes, there is a mandatory minimum sentence set by federal law. In many cases, there may be a term of imprisonment, followed by a period of supervised release . During that term of release, the offender will be supervised by a U.S. probation officer while living back in the community, and will be required to adhere to various conditions.

What is the most common type of evidence?

Actually, the most common type of evidence is provided by witness testimony . Often witness testimony may be the only evidence presented. It’s up to the jury, or the judge in a bench trial, to decide the true facts from what is said by each party and each witness.

What punishments can a judge give for a similar crime?

Types of punishment can include imprisonment, house arrest, supervised release, substance abuse treatment, counseling, educational training, payment of fines and/or restitution.

What is physical evidence?

Physical evidence – Physical objects and documents can be used by either side to prove or disprove issues. An example would be DNA, fingerprints, or a photograph.

What is the purpose of evidence in a case?

Evidence. Objections. Evidence is used by the parties to prove or disprove unresolved issues in the case. There are rules in place to govern how evidence is collected, what evidence can be admitted in the case, and how the judge and jury may consider evidence to render a decision.

Direct Examination

Cross-Examination

  • After the plaintiff's attorney completes the direct examination, the defendant's attorney gets to cross-examine the witness. Cross-examination is a fundamental right in the American system of justice. Generally, cross-examination is limited to matters covered during the direct examination. The attorney may ask leading questions during cross-examination.
See more on lawyers.com

Challenging Witness's Credibility on Cross-Examination

  • During cross-examination, the attorney tries to undermine or impeach the witness's credibility by showing that the witness is not reliable or that the witness may have misstated something or even lied during the direct examination. For example, if the witness said one thing in an accident report or during a depositionand then testified differently at trial, the defendant's attorney can refer to t…
See more on lawyers.com

Redirect and Recross Examination

  • Following cross-examination of the witness, the plaintiff's attorney has an opportunity to ask the witness follow-up questions regarding topics discussed during the cross. After this, the opposing attorney can conduct a final recross examination of the witness, which is limited to the subjects brought up during the redirect.
See more on lawyers.com

Defense's Case

  • Once the plaintiff's attorney has called all of the plaintiff's witnesses, the defendant's attorney begins calling witnesses. The same procedure is followed as in the plaintiff's presentation of witnesses. The defendant's attorney conducts direct examination of the witnesses, and the plaintiff's attorney will conduct cross-examinations.
See more on lawyers.com

Plaintiff’S Case-In-Chief

  • The plaintiff’s case-in-chief is the time that the plaintiff has the opportunity to present evidence in support of its position. The reason that the plaintiff is the first party to present evidence is that the plaintiff has the burden of proof. What this means is that it is the plaintiff who must prove that the defendant is liable. The jury does not assume that the plaintiff is automatically entitled to relief; r…
See more on lawshelf.com

A Note About Admissible Evidence

  • This is not a course on evidence, and the paragraphs that follow cannot substitute for a thorough understanding of the purpose of evidence and what evidence is admissible. The next paragraphs will help you understand the basic purpose of testimony and what type of testimony is generally allowed. As explained earlier, the purpose of direct examination is to let the witness tell his or he…
See more on lawshelf.com

Motions Made After Plaintiff’S Case-In-Chief

  • Once the plaintiff rests, the jury will leave the courtroom while the parties, the judge, the attorneys, and anyone watching the trial, remain. At this point, the defendant may move the court to order a verdict in its favor. Sometimes called a “motion for a directed verdict” or “motion for judgment as a matter of law”, such a motion asks the court ...
See more on lawshelf.com

Selecting A Jury

Image
The jury pool consists of a random selection of the population, excluding certain people for whom serving on a jury would be a significant hardship. The judge and the attorneys will go through the process of voir dire to determine which members of the jury pool will serve on the jury. Voir dire is meant to exclude jurors who will …
See more on justia.com

Opening Statements and Examination of Witnesses

  • In the opening statement, each party’s attorney will present their theory of the case, explain the conclusion that they intend the judge or jury to reach, and outline the evidence that they will use to support their case. The plaintiff has the burden of proof in civil cases, so their attorney will start with presenting their case. This involves calling witnesses to testify on their behalf, as well as pr…
See more on justia.com

The Response of The Defense

  • Once the plaintiff’s attorney has finished calling all of their witnesses and presenting any other evidence, the plaintiff will rest their case. The defendant then may make a motion for a directed verdict if they believe that the plaintiff did not provide evidence for all of the required elements of their claim. (This is called making a prima facie...
See more on justia.com

Closing Arguments and Jury Instructions

  • Closing arguments offer each side an opportunity to make a final impression on the jury. The attorneys will explain what they have proven, highlight a few key points for the jury to remember, and potentially call the jury’s attention to flaws in the opponent’s arguments. Before the jury deliberates on the case, they will receive jury instructions to guide their analysis. The attorneys …
See more on justia.com

Verdicts

  • After the jury has finished their deliberations, they will issue a verdict. Juries do not need to reach a unanimous decision in civil cases. The number of jurors who must agree to reach a verdict varies from state to state. If the jury cannot reach a decision, which is rare, the court will either dismiss the case or set up a new trial. The party who loses at trial has a right to appealthe decisi…
See more on justia.com