what do lawyers think of ace attorney

The Ace Attorney series is a nice example of a fairly realistic game, even though the legal accuracy of Ace Attorney can sometimes be troubling, and the series can occasionally get things wrong about the law. In the Ace Attorney series (excluding the spin-off, Ace Attorney Investigations), the player assumes the part of a defense attorney.

Full Answer

Is Ace Attorney a good game?

Answer (1 of 5): I’m not an attorney, and I love the Phoenix Wright games, but accuracy in legal proceedings would make for a boring game. Games should be fun after all. As far as the inaccuracies: *The accused aren’t innocent until proven …

How accurate is Ace Attorney?

Jul 15, 2016 · The Ace Attorney series is a nice example of a fairly realistic game, even though the legal accuracy of Ace Attorney can sometimes be troubling, and the series can occasionally get things wrong about the law. In the Ace Attorney series (excluding the spin-off, Ace Attorney Investigations), the player assumes the part of a defense attorney. The focus is on Criminal …

What is Category “Ace Attorney”?

The Ace Attorney series is really damn goofy, but but not as phony or unrealistic as some may think. I was inspired to write this considering the way some people overreact to statistics without ...

What is the double jeopardy clause in Ace Attorney?

Aug 27, 2021 · You know, I actually think if they made a seventh Ace Attorney game, the next prosecutor would be as antagonist, but unlike most prosecutors and other characters, actually doesn't like the mistreatments Phoenix and the other lawyers get to the point they try to call out to the judge about how unprofessional it is to see such mistreatments to ...

Is Ace Attorney realistic?

The Ace Attorney series is a nice example of a fairly realistic game, even though the legal accuracy of Ace Attorney can sometimes be troubling, and the series can occasionally get things wrong about the law.Jul 15, 2016

Who is the best attorney in Ace Attorney?

Favourite Ace Attorney characterMaya Fey – 264 votes.Kazuma Asogi – 194 votes.Apollo Justice – 161 votes.Godot – 143 votes.Barok van Zieks – 141 votes.Franziska von Karma – 133 votes.Herlock Sholmes – 107 votes.Ryunosuke Naruhodo – 99 votes.More items...•Nov 1, 2021

Do prosecutors and defense attorneys dislike each other?

Generally not. Both have jobs to do and they're likely to cross paths again down the road. Being cordial and professionally cooperative (in ways that don't compromise the attorney's case) makes the job easier and less stressful.

How accurate is Ace Attorney to the Japanese legal system?

Japan, unlike the US, has a system of “guilty until proven innocent”. If one is accused of a crime and brought into Japan's court, there is a 99% chance of conviction. ... In the court system of Ace Attorney, the accused are “guilty until proven innocent”.

Who is the best assistant in Ace Attorney?

Every Ace Attorney Assistant, Ranked1 Susato Mikotoba. An absolutely picture-perfect legal aid and assistant, Susato is incredibly knowledgeable about all things law and becomes an absolutely essential partner for Naruhodo.2 Maya Fey. ... 3 Kay Faraday. ... 4 Athena Cykes. ... 5 Kazuma Asogi. ... 6 Ema Skye. ... 7 Trucy Wright. ... 8 Iris Wilson. ... More items...•Aug 7, 2021

Why did Phoenix Wright Stop being a lawyer?

During a case seven years prior to the events of Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney, two months after Trials and Tribulations, he was forced to forfeit his attorney's badge after presenting evidence that, unknown to him, was forged.

Why are prosecutors heartless?

Because it's their job to apply the law and the facts to prosecute criminals. Their personal beliefs and emotions have nothing to do with it. They also do have a great deal of discretion in what cases go to trial.

Can you trust a prosecutor?

If they can't afford a lawyer, the big question on most criminal defendants' minds will be whether they can trust their public defender. Fortunately, for the most part, the answer to that question is yes.Jun 19, 2019

Do prosecutors play games?

What follows are the games that prosecutors most commonly play to avoid compliance with Brady. These games include charades, scavenger hunts, gambling, blind man's bluff, hide and seek, delay and conquer, obstacle courses, mazes, and Simon Sez.

Are Japanese courts like Ace Attorney?

The Ace Attorney games are Japanese-made, and therefore based on Japanese criminal justice system and courts procedures.Mar 10, 2017

Does double jeopardy exist in Japan?

Japan. No person shall be held criminally liable for an act which was lawful at the time it was committed, or of which he has been acquitted, nor shall he be placed in double jeopardy.

What is Ace Attorney called in Japanese?

Gyakuten SaibanIn the "Ace Attorney" game series (known as "Gyakuten Saiban" in Japan) players take on the role of a defense attorney who fights for the lives of his wrongfully accused clients.Dec 21, 2015

What does it mean to appeal a case?

That is a misconception. An appeal means that a higher court will review the facts of the case, and never the same court. As we can clearly see, the same judge presides over both trials.

Who is Maggey Byrde?

Maggey Byrde, defended by our beloved Phoenix Wright, is convicted of the murder of Glen Elg. However, Byrde’s defense attorney isn’t Phoenix Wright, but an impostor with a cardboard badge (No kidding). This means that the defendant does not have a proper lawyer.

What does double jeopardy mean?

The Double Jeopardy Clause means that if someone is prosecuted once for a crime, they can’t be prosecuted again for the same crime. It doesn’t matter whether they were acquitted or convicted. This is true both under the American Law system and the Japanese Law system.

What is a mistrial?

A mistrial is a cancelled trial that can happen for a number of reasons. Usually something goes pretty badly at the first trial, which violates the due process of law. A second trial brings justice to the ones who need it. The first instance of a retrial happens in the “ Recipe for Turnabout ” case.

Can you be in two different places at the same time?

That’s not how double jeopardy works! Of course it’s not possible for a single person to be in two different places at the same time. If the prosecution wanted to convict him of murder, no one could prevent them from putting him on trial. Atmey’s attorney would happily present his alibi. Though, once the court found out the alibi was a fake, there is nothing preventing him from getting convicted of murder.

Will Tenkai be retried?

It would be a retrial if Tenkai is put on trial once again, but he isn’t. Manfred von Karma forged evidence at that trial. This would make it a mistrial and open the possibility of a retrial for Tenkai. But that’s not the case here. Due to the nature of the spin-off, we don’t get to see the actual trial.

Can Athena Cykes be retried?

Retrials are not that easy to get. On top of that, Athena Cykes had been only 11 years old at the time of her mother’s murder. Japan’s age of criminal responsibility is 14 years. She could not be tried as an adult in this “retrial” anyway. Also, just as in “The Inherited Turnabout” mentioned above, they are not putting the same person on trial. Hence, it can’t be a retrial. This time, there’s not even forged evidence to classify the first trial as a mistrial.

What does "iie" mean in Ace Attorney?

In the Japanese version of the game, they say “iie” which roughly means “no” but has different connotations and uses in English. It’s generally a rude thing to say in denial, more so than the English “no,” so people generally politely make excuses. Attorneys yelling it in court in Ace Attorney is every bit as ridiculous as with the English “Objection!” The difference is this: whereas the phrase “objection” is used in American courts (not yelling, usually), the word “iie” isn’t used in the context of objecting to something in court because as you know Japanese people are polite and not so confrontational. Which might also be why judges don’t pound gavels to shut people up, which begs the question: is it because they are too polite to tell the audience to shut up, or the audience is too polite to be loud in the first place? Series creator Shu Takumi noticed both of these when he and his team visited real courts prior to making the game, but decided to leave them in the game anyway.

Who is Phoenix Wright's partner?

Spoiler. In Justice for All , Phoenix Wright ends being coerced into defending someone who he knows is guilty of the crime, as his partner Maya is kidnapped and threatened to be killed if he doesn’t get the culprit a ‘not guilty’ verdict.

What is the opening statement in a court case?

There is an opening statement, followed by presentation of evidence, witness testimony and cross-examination, defendant questioning, and finally closing arguments. If the case is settled a sentence is issued by the judge (the lay judges/jury just aid the judges in their decision but do not have deciding power).

Has Manfred von Karma forged evidence?

Manfred von Karma and a few others have forged evidence to further their goals. Some have read in to this as being commentary on the situation in Japan, with success-driven prosecutors looking to get guilty verdicts no matter the cost. I’ll leave it up to you to decide whether or not the games creators are potentially parodying or criticizing prosecution with Manfred von Karma, but I have been unable to locate any definitive proof that there is a problem with forgery on a large scale. However, if there was a significant issue with forgery, there ought to be at least some reports on it. Prosecutors in Japan have way more cases than they can handle. They have plenty of guaranteed convictions, so I really doubt they would need to resort to forgery and put their fancy badge and cravats at risk. Not to say it never happens, but it does not appear to be an issue of any significance.