what attorney do mental capacity of client

It is not the role of a solicitor to be an expert in mental capacity assessment of their client. However, a solicitor can be involved in carrying out a “legal” assessment of their client’s mental capacity which involves:1

Full Answer

Can a solicitor do a mental capacity assessment of a client?

It is not the role of a solicitor to be an expert in mental capacity assessment of their client. However, a solicitor can be involved in carrying out a “legal” assessment of their client’s mental capacity which involves:1

Are attorneys licensed to assess the capacity of clients?

Although attorneys are not typically licensed physicians, the criteria set forth in the code provide the basic framework for the attorney to assess the client’s capacity.

Should attorneys work with elderly clients with questionable mental wherewithal?

Working with clients with questionable mental wherewithal is a recurrent concern amongst elder law and estate planning attorneys. Concerns are justified, as legal malpractice suits regarding the capacity of elder clients are swinging toward a higher burden of diligence by attorneys in the field. What guidance do attorneys with aging clients have?

How does a lawyer protect a client with diminished capacity?

Protection for lawyers representing diminished capacity clients lies in documentation of the state of mind of the client. The more documentation an attorney has to justify their belief that the client was satisfactorily competent at the time of the action, the more protection the attorney affords him or herself.

What is a client lawyer relationship?

The “normal client-lawyer relationship” involves communicating with the client, informing the client of the progress of his or her case, and maintaining the client’s confidences. How is the attorney to continue representation with a client who cannot effectively communicate with the attorney and/or is unable to understand ...

How to determine if a client lacks capacity?

Determining whether the client lacks capacity to perform a task, typically involves assessing whether the client is able to effectively communicate and understand the decision and its consequences. When questions of capacity arise, the attorney must properly assess and document the client’s capacity. A simple conversation with the client will give the attorney the opportunity to make an assessment of capacity.

What ethical issues arise when a client has diminished capacity?

The ethical issue of representing a client with diminished capacity frequently arises in estate and probate practice. Oftentimes, an adult child will bring a parent to an attorney’s office to prepare and execute estate plan documents, because the parent has recently been diagnosed with dementia or “is not doing well.” These are the last-minute preparers. Sometimes the parent has an estate plan, but now the adult child brings the parent into the attorney’s office to make changes. Beside the obvious question of undue influence, there is the question of capacity to execute legal documents. Finally, there are the parents with an estate plan appointing an adult child or children to act as personal representatives of the parents and their estates, and other family members raise claims of mismanagement or abuses of power against the representative. The attorney faced with these situations must ask herself whether the client lacks capacity to make any legal decisions, whether the attorney may represent or continue to represent the client, and/or whether the attorney is authorized to notify others of the client’s risk of harm.

What is the American Bar Association's Model Rule of Professional Conduct?

American Bar Association’s Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.14 states that when representing a client with diminished capacity, “the lawyer shall, as far as reasonably possible, maintain a normal client-lawyer relationship with the client.” The “normal client-lawyer relationship” involves communicating with the client, informing the client of the progress of his or her case, and maintaining the client’s confidences. How is the attorney to continue representation with a client who cannot effectively communicate with the attorney and/or is unable to understand the information given to the client? What happens if the attorney learns during the representation that a third party is abusing the client, but the communication was made in confidence?

What is the presumption of a lawyer?

The basic presumption is that a person is of sound mind and, therefore, legally competent to make his or her own decisions, which includes the capacity to execute legal documents. Depending on the circumstance, the attorney must review the applicable capacity standards when representing a client. For instance, if the client is brought to ...

Can an attorney reveal confidential information?

Otherwise, the attorney may not reveal any confidential information, without the client’s informed written consent. Usually, a client with diminished capacity could not give such informed consent.

Do attorneys have to be licensed?

Although attorneys are not typically licensed physicians, the criteria set forth in the code provide the basic framework for the attorney to assess the client’s capacity. Similarly, the American Bar Association, in conjunction with the American Psychological Association, has published a handbook for attorneys to refer to when making similar ...

What is the role of an attorney in mental health?

Once an attorney determines whether a client has a mental illness and takes the proper legal precautions, the attorney should also consider his or her behavior toward the client as the representation continues. For any client, effective representation goes far beyond the bare minimum legal and ethical requirements. Effective representation requires communication and understanding.

What to do if an attorney is uncertain about a client's mental health?

If an attorney remains uncertain about a client’s mental state after a preliminary assessment, then the attorney may need to consult the help of a mental health professional. If an attorney does not discover a mental illness until after representation commences, the attorney should take steps to ensure the client’s interests have been preserved. Indeed, contracts and other legal documents may be considered invalid if the client did not possess the requisite capacity at the time the document was signed.

What is the ABA model rule of professional conduct?

For lawyers in this position, they need to know ABA Model Rule of Professional Conduct 1.14, which addresses client-lawyer relationships where the client suffers from a mental illness or diminished capacity. Rule 1.14, a version of which has been adopted in all 50 states and the District of Columbia, states, “the lawyer shall, as far as reasonably possible, maintain a normal client-lawyer relationship with the client.”

What should an attorney do when a client has diminished capacity?

Attorneys representing a client with diminished capacity should constantly evaluate whether the client is capable of acting in his or her own interest, and adjust representation accordingly. We are in a position to help people who trust us and seek us out for advice regardless of a particular client’s mental or physical state.

What is the pivotal question to consider when an attorney believes his or her client suffers from a mental illness?

If an attorney believes his or her client suffers from a mental illness, the pivotal question to consider is whether the client cannot adequately act in the client’s own interest.

What happens if a client cannot act in his or her own interest?

If the client cannot act in his or her own interest, then an attorney “may take reasonably necessary protective action, including consulting with individuals or entities that have the ability to take action to protect the client and, in appropriate cases, seeking the appointment of guardian ad litem, conservator or guardian.”

What is client capacity?

One authority explains that perhaps the clearest and most enduring articulation of client capacity remains that of the President’s Commission for the Study of Ethical Problems in Medicine and Biomedical and Behavioral Research, enunciated in their seminal 1982 report: “Decision making capacity requires, to greater or lesser degree: (1) possession of a set of values and goals; (2) the ability to communicate and to understand information; and (3) the ability to reason and to deliberate about one’s choices.”

Who acts as a guardian in a psychiatric facility?

The Public Guardian and Trustee will also act as guardian where a treating physician finds a patient in a psychiatric facility incapable of managing property either upon admission or discharge, and notifies the Office of the Public Guardian and Trustee of the finding.

Who decides whether a person is capable?

In general terms, who decides whether a person is capable depends on what the decision is that needs to be made. This is because each task we do in our day-to-day lives and the decisions we make, each require a varying level of understanding and knowledge. This is why, at law, we consider capacity as a “task-specific” question. What this means is that the decision a person is making (or being asked to make), will ultimately determine who will assess their capacity or authority to make it.

Why do you need an assessment of a power of attorney?

An assessment of the person’s capacity by a third party is not usually required, but the lawyer may suggest an assessment in order to protect the will or power of attorney from future challenges. ‘Activating’ a continuing power of attorney for property.

What is a continuing power of attorney?

This means that the attorney has authority to act under it immediately, as long as it is otherwise valid.

What is the capacity to make a will?

By way of example, for someone to have capacity to make a will, the person must understand the nature of the act and its effect. They must also understand the extent of the property of which he or she is disposing and be able to appreciate and comprehend the various claims that might be given effect to through the will (e.g., claims of dependents, etc.). In such circumstances, capacity is highly fact specific.

Who is the guardian of property under SDA?

Under the SDA, a person may be assessed by a capacity assessor for the purposes of “statutory guardianship”. If the capacity assessor declares the individual incapable, the Public Guardian and Trustee is the individual’s guardian of property as soon as the certificate of incapacity is received from the assessor.

Can a court appoint a guardian?

Only the court can appoint a guardian of the person if an individual lacks capacity to make treatment or personal decisions and he or she did not execute a power of attorney for personal care before becoming incapable. Tags. # decision making, guardian for property, mental capacity, power of attorney. Claire Kadwell.

What is a client lawyer relationship?

[1] The normal client-lawyer relationship is based on the assumption that the client, when properly advised and assisted, is capable of making decisions about important matters. When the client is a minor or suffers from a diminished mental capacity, however, maintaining the ordinary client-lawyer relationship may not be ...

What should a lawyer determine before discussing matters related to the client?

At the very least, the lawyer should determine whether it is likely that the person or entity consulted with will act adversely to the client's interests before discussing matters related to the client. The lawyer's position in such cases is an unavoidably difficult one.

What is emergency legal assistance?

[9] In an emergency where the health, safety or a financial interest of a person with seriously diminished capacity is threatened with imminent and irreparable harm, a lawyer may take legal action on behalf of such a person even though the person is unable to establish a client-lawyer relationship or to make ...

What should a lawyer consider when a legal representative has not been appointed?

[7] If a legal representative has not been appointed, the lawyer should consider whether appointment of a guardian ad litem, conservator or guardian is necessary to protect the client's interests.

Who must keep the client's interests foremost?

Nevertheless, the lawyer must keep the client's interests foremost and, except for protective action authorized under paragraph (b), must look to the client, and not family members, to make decisions on the client's behalf.

Can a severely incapacitated person make a decision?

In particular, a severely incapacitated person may have no power to make legally binding decisions. Nevertheless, a client with diminished capacity often has the ability to understand, deliberate upon, and reach conclusions about matters affecting the client's own well-being.

What is the role of a solicitor in a client relationship?

It is fundamental to the solicitor/client relationship that a solicitor must rely and act on instructions of their client. However, where a solicitor considers that key indicators point clearly to a client’s lack of mental capacity to give competent instructions, it is their responsibility to explore this issue further. This Guide aims to assist solicitors to take a principled approach to this task which is thorough, thoughtful and respectful of each client’s particular circumstances. Solicitors who inform themselves of the issues surrounding client mental capacity and who are aware of the available resources in the area will be better equipped to face the challenges which often arise in this area of practice, while still providing a high standard of legal service to their client.

Why is it important for a solicitor to approach their consultation with their client?

It is vital that a solicitor approaches their consultation with their client in a way which will help the solicitor gain as much useful information as possible about whether the client has mental capacity to instruct a solicitor or make

Can a solicitor assess mental capacity?

It is not the role of a solicitor to be an expert in mental capacity assessment of their client. However, a solicitor can be involved in carrying out a “legal” assessment of their client’s mental capacity which involves:1

Who said the formula for determining testamentary capacity is stated in the judgment of the Court?

The formula for determining testamentary capacity is stated in the judgment of the Court (Cockburn CJ, Blackburn, Mellor, and Hannen JJ) delivered by Sir Alexander Cockburn in Banks v Goodfellow (1870) LR 5 QB 549 at 565 as follows:

Is mental capacity legal in New South Wales?

There is no single legal definition of mental capacity in New South Wales. Rather, the legal definition of mental capacity depends in each case on the type of decision which is being made or the type of transaction involved6.

When a client with diminished capacity wishes to have others participate in discussions, the lawyer must still look to the client for?

Additionally, keep in mind that comment 3 of the Model Rules states that when a client with diminished capacity wishes to have others participate in discussions, the lawyer must still look to the client for decision making. Friends or family members may have helpful input, but the decisions are ultimately those of the client – absent a legally appointed representative. When the client has been appointed a representative, comment 4 of the Model Rules states that the lawyer should look to that representative for direction.

How to assess client capacity?

When assessing a new client’s capacity for forming a client-lawyer relationship, it is critical for the lawyer to pay close attention to the articulated goals, reasonings, and state-of-mind of the client. In subsequent meetings, the lawyer should pay attention to whether these goals are staying fairly consistent – noting any questionable deviations. Maintaining evidence of the reasonable certainty of requisite capacity through notes and other documentation is very important for the lawyer with concerns of possible incapacity. Retaining doctor’s opinions on capacity, meeting notes, and even video records of meetings are helpful in establishing the reasonable belief that a client is capable of executing their own wishes.

What can elder law attorneys do to protect themselves?

There are steps that elder law and estate planning attorneys can take to protect themselves – and the client – when concerns of diminished capacity arise. The bottom line is that a diligent attorney will use common sense and established rules of assessments and conduct to decide whether their client is cognizant enough to utilize their services, ...

What happens after an attorney meets with a client?

After the initial meeting with a client, an attorney may not meet with that client again for some time. Clients face many obstacles in the time between these meetings. Often, aging clients begin to struggle with mental faculties over time. A once-competent client may no longer have the requisite level of capacity to modify or begin new legal tasks after years since the last interaction between client and attorney. The prospect of a potential elder-client poses additional concerns. Unlike with existing clients, the attorney works to establish competency without the baseline of that of someone they have worked with over time.

Why do lawyers want to make sure their clients' best interests are put first?

Attorneys need to make sure that the client understands the legal representation and how decisions will affect their family and circumstances. When representing a client with diminished capacity, the road gets a little more difficult but there is help in navigating it. Be familiar with the Model Rules of Professional Conduct and the ethical rules in your state.

Why is it important to keep doctor's opinions?

Retaining doctor’s opinions on capacity, meeting notes, and even video records of meetings are helpful in establishing the reasonable belief that a client is capable of executing their own wishes.

What is the common theme between requisite capacity and various legal tasks?

A common theme between requisite capacity and various legal tasks is twofold: the client’s ability to understand the task, and their ability to appreciate the consequences of the actions taken. Many red flags can be identified through the typical series of interactions with the client.

When a client’s capacity to make decisions is limited due to mental impairment, the lawyer shall, as far as?

Rule 1.14 states that when a client’s capacity to make decisions is limited due to mental impairment “the lawyer shall, as far as reasonably possible, maintain a normal client-lawyer relationship with the client.” Model Rule 1.14(a)

What are behavioral or physiological clues?

Behavioral or Physiological Clues: Your client may start exhibiting certain behaviors or characteristics that are indicative of a person with a mental disability. Some of those behaviors/characteristics are:

What happens if an attorney does not have capacity?

An attorney must assess capacity and if there is no capacity, then the attorney could not ethically allow the documents to be signed. In cases where capacity is tough to determine, a lawyer must be extra careful.

What does a lawyer do with dementia?

A very, very difficult question. The lawyer represents his or her client, and has a duty to do what the client wants. That means the lawyer needs to be assured that the client is able to clearly state what he or she wants. A lawyer can find him- or her-self on the edge, in the grey area, but if the client expresses the same wishes consistently, and meets certain basic criteria, the lawyer might move forward. It's all balancing dementia hits different people differently, and just because a person is diagnosed with dementia doesn't mean they automatically lose their ability (or their right) to make testamentary plans.

What is the ethical obligation of an attorney?

An attorney has an ethical obligation to make sure that his or her client is legally competent which is not always the same thing as medically competent. * This will flag comments for moderators to take action.

What is the attorney's responsibility?

100%. It is the attorney's responsibility to determine legal competency of the person who will be signing documents. While that can be accomplished in many ways, it is the attorney's duty to make a legal determination (not judicial, although this is sometimes necessary) of competence.

Is it okay to have a lawyer for lucidity?

People go thru periods of lucidity even when diagnosed with certain mental conditions so if the signor appears good, is expressing themselves in a positive manner, and a reasonable person would not spot an issue of competency, then the attorney should be okay. However, if the person is drooping over, doesn't know what year it is, ...

Do you mean to ask whether the attorney has authority to decide whether the person is competent?

Do you mean to ask whether the attorney has authority to decide whether the person is competent? No, a probate judge determines that, if there is a dispute. The attorney is just a witness (given the same weight as any other witness) to whether the person appeared to understand what they were doing that day by executing the POA and trust.

Can an attorney videotape a signing?

If the situation is very critical some attorneys even videotape the signing to show lucidity at the time of signing.