under washington law, when can attorney fees be recovered in civil cases

by Dr. Maximillian Kutch 5 min read

(1) When the prevailing party in district court is entitled to recover costs as authorized in RCW 4.84.010 in a civil action, the judge shall add the amount thereof to the judgment; in case of failure of the plaintiff to recover or of dismissal of the action, the judge shall enter up a judgment in favor of the defendant for the amount of his or her costs; and in case any party so entitled to costs is represented in the action by an attorney, the judge shall include attorney's fees in the amount provided in RCW 4.84.080 as part of the costs: PROVIDED, HOWEVER, That the plaintiff shall not be entitled to such attorney fee unless he or she obtains, exclusive of costs, a judgment in the sum of fifty dollars or more: AND PROVIDED FURTHER, That if the plaintiff obtains judgment, exclusive of costs, of at least fifty dollars but less than two hundred dollars, the judge shall include attorney fees of one hundred twenty-five dollars as part of the costs.

Full Answer

What is the American rule for attorney fees?

What are the grounds for attorney fees?

Which law authorizes attorney fees?

Is the United States immune from a lawsuit?

See 1 more

About this website

image

Can you sue for attorney fees in Washington state?

In Washington, a party can recover its attorney fees against another party if a law or statute that governs the case provides for the recovery of attorney fees. There are many types of statutes that include these types of provisions.

What is the common name for when an attorney takes a percentage of the amount recovered in a successful lawsuit?

About contingency fees Contingency fees mean you will pay the lawyer a certain percentage of the money you receive if you win the case or settle the matter out of court. If you lose your case, the lawyer does not receive any payment from you.

Can the winning party recover legal fees in Texas?

Under Texas law, a contract may provide that the prevailing party, whether the plaintiff or defendant, will recover its attorneys' fees against the other party, or that the statutory right for a prevailing plaintiff to recover its fees under section 38.001 is waived leaving no party able to recover its fees.

When can you recover attorney fees in Texas?

September 1, 2021For cases filed in Texas after September 1, 2021, Chapter 38 was thus amended to provide, “a person may recover reasonable attorney's fees from an individual or organization other than a quasi-governmental entity authorized to perform a function by state law, a religious organization, a charitable organization or a ...

What is the most percentage a lawyer takes?

No matter when the claim settles or how much, the legal representative usually cannot take more than the 33.33 percent of compensation awards. However, most of the fees and expense the lawyer will acquire through the completed case are in the fine print of a legal agreement between client and lawyer.

Under Which type of arrangement do lawyers receive a percentage of the amount recovered by winning or settling a case?

contingent fee arrangementIn a contingent fee arrangement, the lawyer agrees to accept a fixed percentage (often one-third to 40 percent) of the recovery, which is the amount finally paid to the client. If you win the case, the lawyer's fee comes out of the money awarded to you.

What is the American Rule of law?

The American Rule is a rule in the U.S. justice system that says two opposing sides in a legal matter must pay their own attorney fees, regardless of who wins the case. The rationale of the rule is that a plaintiff should not be deterred from bringing a case to court for fear of prohibitive costs.

Can you recover attorney fees for breach of fiduciary duty Texas?

The short answer is: No, you are usually not entitled to recover your attorneys' fees in a Breach of Fiduciary Duty case. However, there may be other causes of action to file with your breach of fiduciary duty claim, which may entitle you to recover attorneys' fees.

Can you recover attorneys fees from an LLC in Texas?

Attorney's Fees Now Recoverable Against LLC's and Partnerships in Texas Breach of Contract Cases. Texas Civil Practice and Remedies Code Section 38.001 has been expanded for lawsuits filed on or after September 1, 2021 to allow for the recovery of attorney's fees against LLC's and partnerships.

What section of Tex Civ prac and Rem Code applies to whether or not the court may award attorney's fees in a breach of contract case?

Prac. & Rem. Code § 38.002 (West 2017). Recovering attorney's fees in a breach of contract claim is by far the most common application of Chapter 38: A person may recover attorney's fees from an individual or corporation for breach of oral or written contracts.

Can lawyer Sue client for fees in Texas?

A lawyer may hire another lawyer to sue a client for delinquent fees. See, e.g., Opinion 464 (August 1989). A lawsuit is a matter of public record, and it will force a client to either hire an attorney for representation in the suit or proceed pro se.

Can you get attorney fees for breach of contract Texas?

Generally, Texas law provides that each party to a lawsuit is responsible for her attorneys' fees. However, Texas law has long provided that a party in a breach of contract claim may recover her attorney's fees in addition to the damages she suffers.

Can you sue for lawyer fees Texas?

Generally, Texas law provides that each party to a lawsuit is responsible for her attorneys' fees. However, Texas law has long provided that a party in a breach of contract claim may recover her attorney's fees in addition to the damages she suffers.

Can lawyer Sue client for fees in Texas?

A lawyer may hire another lawyer to sue a client for delinquent fees. See, e.g., Opinion 464 (August 1989). A lawsuit is a matter of public record, and it will force a client to either hire an attorney for representation in the suit or proceed pro se.

Are expert fees recoverable as costs in Texas?

Expert witness fees are not recoverable in a personal injury case in Texas. One of the largest expenses a lawyer must incur in many cases is the cost of expert witness fees.

What are reasonable attorney fees in Texas?

The average hourly rate for a lawyer in Texas is between $130 and $415 per hour.

Payment of Attorney’s Fees in Litigation Involving Successful ...

Attorney's Fees in Litigation Under Administrative Procedure Act and Endangered Species Act eligible for a fee award.” See Ruckelshaus v. Sierra Club, 463 U.S. 680, 682 & n.l (1983).

USAO Matrix 2015-2021 - United States Department of Justice

USAO ATTORNEY’S FEES MATRIX — 2015-2021 Revised Methodology starting with 2015-2016 Year Years (Hourly Rate for June 1 – May 31, based on change in PPI-OL since January 2011)

Attorney Fees and Costs: Everything You Need to Know - UpCounsel

Updated July 14, 2020: Attorney Fees and Costs. Attorney fees and costs are one of the biggest concerns when hiring legal representation. Understanding how attorneys charge and determining what a good rate is can be confusing.

34 CFR § 21.1 - Equal Access to Justice Act. | CFR | US Law | LII ...

(a) The Equal Access to Justice Act (the Act) provides for the award of fees and other expenses to applicants that - (1) Are prevailing parties in adversary adjudications before the Department of Education; and (2) Meet all other conditions of eligibility contained in this part. (b) An eligible applicant, as described in paragraph (a) of this section, is entitled to receive an award unless -

What is the American rule for attorney fees?

In Washington, the general default rule is that each party in a lawsuit is responsible for its own attorney fees incurred in the lawsuit. This is known as the “American Rule”. In contrast, the “British Rule” provides that the losing party in a lawsuit must pay the winner’s attorney fees.

What are the grounds for awarding attorney fees?

Equity. If there are no statutes or no contractual provisions that apply, there are various equitable grounds upon which courts can decide to award attorney fees. But these grounds are narrow and usually only applicable in special, limited circumstances. One of the more common equitable grounds for awarding attorney fees is if the other side has engaged in some sort of bad faith in the litigation, but that is a high burden to prove and courts are reluctant to find a party engaged in bad faith.

What are some examples of statutes?

Examples include parties who prevail on a Consumer Protection Act claim, on a claim involving unpaid salary or wages, or on a claim of discrimination. However, each statute is different and should be read carefully.

Can you recover attorney fees?

Contract. A party can also recover attorney fees if the dispute involves a contract that includes a provision that the prevailing party is entitled to recover attorney fees. It is actually quite common to see these boilerplate attorney fees provisions in contracts nowadays. Even if the contractual provision is written to only benefit one party—only party A can recover its attorney fees if it wins, but not party B—there is a Washington law that says such provisions are reciprocal, meaning that the benefit of the attorney fees provision applies to both parties equally.

What is legal Disclaimer?

Disclaimer: This article and blog are intended to inform the reader of general legal principles applicable to the subject area. They are not intended to provide legal advice regarding specific problems or circumstances. Readers should consult with competent counsel with regard to specific situations.

Can you recover attorney fees against another party in Washington?

A party to a lawsuit can recover its attorney fees against another party in the following circumstances: (1) if a statute provides for the recovery of attorney fees; (2) if a contractual agreement between the parties provides for the recovery of attorney fees; or (3) some recognized ground of equity.

Is there a right to attorney fees at the end of a lawsuit?

And it is important to know this as early as possible. The answer can drive economic decisions in pursuing or not pursuing litigation. If the prevailing party will have a right to recover attorney fees, that could make it more palatable to pursue a lawsuit through to the end, especially for a party that has a strong case. But the flip-side of the coin is if the other side wins it will recover its attorney fees. So, the stakes are increased in attorney fee cases.

What is the statute of attorney fees in Washington?

Statutory Attorneys Fees - There are quite a few statutes in Washington that allow for the recovery of attorneys' fees. For example, the Washington Law Against Discrimination allows the party claiming injury (not the defendant) the right to recover reasonable attorneys' fees. Similarly, the Washington Consumer Protection Act allows the consumer ...

What is the rule for attorneys fees?

Court Rule Attorneys' Fees - There are a few court rules that authorize the court to award attorneys' fees during a lawsuit. For example, Rule 37 of the Washington Court Rules authorizes the court to award attorneys' fees to a party who is forced to bring a motion to compel their opponent to engage in discovery.

What is the Washington Consumer Protection Act?

Similarly, the Washington Consumer Protection Act allows the consumer the non-reciprocal right to recover reasonable attorneys' fees. In addition, for lawsuits where the amount in dispute is less than $10,000.00, RCW 4.84.250, allows the judge to award reasonable attorneys fees.

What is the equitable basis for recovering attorneys fees?

Common Fund - Another equitable basis for recovering attorneys' fees is where a party brings an action and creates or preserves a common fund for the benefit of others as well as the party bringing the action. So there you have it. These are the exceptions to the rule that each side must pay their own attorneys' fees in Washington State.

Do you have to pay your own attorney's fees in Washington State?

In Washington State, where I practice law, the general rule is that each side must pay their own attorneys' fees unless one of the exceptions to the rule applies. And, there are only a few exceptions to this rule.

Can arbitrators award reasonable attorneys' fees?

But, judge and arbitrators will commonly award "reasonable attorneys' fees" and the amount awarded will often be less than the actual attorneys' fees incurred. Be sure to talk to your lawyer about this issue so you understand it at both the contract drafting stage and at the pre-litigation decision making stage.

What is the American rule for attorney fees?

The general rule in this country, the so-called "American Rule" is that each party must pay its own attorney's fees. See Alyeska Pipeline Service Co. v. Wilderness Society, 421 U.S. 240 (1975). There are, however, numerous federal statutes providing for attorney fee awards where the United States or a federal agency or official is a party. The most generally applicable statute authorizing attorney's fees awards against the United States is the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), 28 U.S.C. § 2412, which makes the federal government liable for fees where:

What are the grounds for attorney fees?

The principal grounds under which the American common law would permit attorney's fees to be awarded are the "bad faith" and "common fund" theories. The "bad faith" theory allows an award where a party has willfully disobeyed a court order or has "acted in bad faith , vexatiously, wantonly, or for oppressive reasons.".

Which law authorizes attorney fees?

The most generally applicable statute authorizing attorney's fees awards against the United States is the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), 28 U.S.C. § 2412, which makes the federal government liable for fees where:

Is the United States immune from a lawsuit?

Where no statute, including the EAJA, specifically allows for the recovery of fees, sovereign immunity bars the award of fees. It is fundamental that the United States, as a sovereign, is immune from suit save as it consents to be sued and the terms of its consent to be sued in any court define the court's jurisdiction to entertain the suit. See United States v. Mitchell, 445 U.S. 535, 538 (1980). Waivers of sovereign immunity "cannot be implied but must be unequivocally expressed." United States v. King, 395 U.S. 1, 4 (1969). This rule of strict construction has been specifically applied to claims for attorney fee awards against the United States. Library of Congress v. Shaw, 478 U.S. 310 (1986); Ruckelshaus v. Sierra Club, 463 U.S. 680, 685 (1983); Nichols v. Pierce, 740 F.2d 1249, 1258-59 (D.C. Cir. 1984); Commissioner of Highways v. United States, 684 F.2d 443, 444 (7th Cir. 1982); Nibali v. United States, 634 F.2d 494, 497 (Ct.Cl. 1980).

Why do courts support the American rule?

Courts have reiterated their support for the American Rule because (1) litigation is inherently a risky proposition, and a party should not be penalized for merely participating in a lawsuit; (2) those without means would be unduly discouraged from pursuing their legal rights if they feared that losing the case would also cost them their opponents’ legal fees; and (3) the cost of proving the amount of legal fees would pose an undue burden on judicial administration. Blue Sky Advocates v. State, 107 Wn.2d 112, 123, 727 P.2d 644 (1986).

Can a court award attorney fees?

However, there are three exceptions to this rule and Courts can award attorney’s fees where: (1) there is a contractual provision for attorney’s fees, (2) a statute allows for the award of attorney’s fees, and (3) equity allows for attorney’s fees.

Can you recover attorney fees from bad faith?

In rare cases, a party can recover attorney’s fees from a party who engages in bad faith litigation conduct. There are three types of bad faith litigation conduct: (1) pre-litigation misconduct, where a party engages in bad faith conduct that wastes private and judicial resources and forces a legal action to enforce a clearly valid claim or right; (2) procedural misconduct, where a party engages in bad faith conduct during the course of the lawsuit; (3) substantive bad faith, where a party intentionally brings a frivolous clam, counterclaim or defense for an improper motive such as harassment. While most litigants believe that the other side has engaged in bad faith conduct in some form or another, recovering under this provision is extremely rare.

Do you have to win to get attorney fees in Washington?

While contractual attorney’s fees are enforced as a matter of course in Washington, they do require a “win” to apply. In some cases where the case ends in a draw or a tie, where both sides lose a little and win a little, the Court may refuse to award fees. In addition, most courts will only award “reasonable” attorney’s fees, so an attorney’s fee provision in the Contract should not be treated as a blank check to direct your attorneys to overwork the case. .

Can a litigant recover attorney fees?

A litigant can recover attorney fees if the dispute involves a contract that includes a provision that the prevailing party is entitled to recover attorney fees. It is quite common to see an attorney’s fee provision in adhesion contracts. The good news is that in Washington, attorney’s fee provisions have to be applied bilaterally, or in other words, even if the contract only provides attorney’s fees provision if Party A wins, the Courts will apply it equally, so whichever party prevails will be entitled to have their attorney’s fees reimbursed by the other side.

How Can I Get My Attorney Fees Paid For in a Breach of Contract Claim?

For example, in a breach of contract action against an individual, you would include a request that the Court grant you a judgment in the amount of your attorney’s fees as a result of you having to hire an attorney to pursue an action against the breaching party.

What is restitution in contract law?

Restitution may be ordered so the breaching party must pay the injured party back, with the intent to restore the injured party to the position they were in prior to the breach . These damages do not generally include lost profits or earnings caused by the breach of contract.

Do I Need a Lawyer If I Am Facing a Breach of Contract?

If you are involved in a breach of contract dispute, you should consult with a skilled and knowledgeable contract attorney. An experienced business attorney can review your contract and advise you on how best to proceed in recovering damages.

What is the remedy for a non-breaching party?

The specific type of remedy that the non-breaching party may be entitled to will largely be determined by the severity of the breach of contract, as well as the damage done by the breaching party. Compensatory damages are the most commonly awarded in suits involving breach of contract. This remedy is intended to compensate ...

What are punitive damages?

Some other types of damages include punitive damages, which are intended to punish the breaching party for their breach, and remedies in equity. This occurs when a court orders a party to do something as opposed to paying out monetary damages.

What happens if a plaintiff takes too long to file a lawsuit?

However, if the plaintiff takes too long to file their lawsuit, the defendant may be able to assert that they, the breaching party, actually suffered some type of harm or prejudice. The breaching party may then seek to prevent the plaintiff from filing the lawsuit, which is known as estoppel by laches.

What is the difference between a partial breach and a complete breach?

Partial breaches do not affect how the rest of the contract may be carried out, whereas a complete breach renders the contract entirely useless. A court can assess whether a specific breach was minor, or substantial.

When a state or federal statute under which a claim is asserted specifically permits an award of attorneys' fees?

In the case of a contractual provision for an award of attorneys’ fees, courts will generally defer to the terms of the contract under the presumption that the contract was read, understood, and agreed to by all parties involved.

Why are attorneys' fees drafted?

Since litigation costs are difficult to accurately predict based on a variety of factors, attorneys’ fees provisions are often drafted to provide for an award of a party’s reasonable attorneys’ fees. Many state and federal statutes are drafted similarly.

What is the exception to the American Rule?

The other exception to the American Rule is when state or federal statutes under which a claim is asserted provides for the award of attorneys’ fees for a successful litigant . In these cases, the legislature has made the affirmative decision to permit courts to award attorneys’ fees for prevailing parties, often times to punish ...

What is the American rule in litigation?

Whether you initiate litigation or find yourself defending a lawsuit, the “American Rule” in litigation is that each party is responsible for paying their own attorneys’ fees throughout the lifespan of a case. In fact, there are generally only two instances when the losing party in litigation lawfully bears the attorneys’ fees ...

Can a court order an attorney's fee in Pennsylvania?

However, even in circumstances where a contractual or statutory attorneys’ fees provision does not apply, in Pennsylvania, courts are permitted to order litigants to pay attorneys’ fees who, during the course of litigation, engage in particularly egregious conduct that has a significantly negative effect on other parties, or the proceedings as a whole 2 (i.e. intentional delay of the proceedings, failing to comply with court orders, frivolous pleadings or argument etc.). In our experience, although courts will generally reduce claims of actual attorneys’ fees incurred to a more reasonable figure, courts will not hesitate to sanction a litigant’s conduct when it is so egregious that it unacceptably and unjustifiably wastes the time and resources of the court and other litigants.

Why was the Second Circuit's decision to enforce attorneys' fees fair?

The Second Circuit also held that enforcement of attorneys' fee clauses was fair because "courts should presume...that the creditor gave value, in the form of a contract term favorable to the debtor...in exchange for the collection costs provision." United Merchants, supra, 674 F. 2d at 137 .

When Can Post-Petition Attorneys' Fees Receive Administrative Priority Status?

Under certain circumstances, post-petition attorneys' fees can qualify for administrative priority status, even though the underlying transaction or contract receives only general creditor status. For example, certain employees who are terminated without sufficient prior notice can assert claims for up to 60 days of lost wages under the Worker Adjustment and Retraining Notification Act (WARN Act), 29 U.S.C. §2901 et seq. Accordingly, the court in In re Jamesway Corp., 242 B.R. 130, 132 (Bankr. S.D.N.Y. 1999) , held that both the lost wages and the attorneys' fees provided for in the statute may be asserted as claims against the bankruptcy estate. The Jamesway court also ruled that while the lost wages are not entitled to administrative priority, the associated attorneys' fees should receive this status, since they are awarded pursuant to a fee-shifting statute. The court reasoned that the purpose of a fee-shifting statute is to encourage attorneys to take such cases, and that forcing a successful attorney to stand in line with all other creditors would defeat this incentive. Furthermore, debtors with clear WARN liability would have little incentive to settle "if they knew they could pay the adversaries' legal bills at pennies on the dollar." Id. at 134 .

What is the duty of the court under 502c?

The court pointed out that it is the court's duty under §502 (c) to estimate contingent and unliquidated claims and to disallow certain claims under §502 (b). Since "contingent, unliquidated attorneys' fees are not among those claims that may not be allowed," it is the duty of the court to estimate and allow these fees.

What is a claim in bankruptcy?

4 Bankruptcy Code §101 (5) provides, in relevant part, that: "claim means...right to payment, whether or not such right is reduced to judgment, liquidated, unliquidated, fixed, contingent, matured, unmatured, disputed, undisputed, legal, equitable, secured or unsecured." Return to article

Can an unsecured creditor claim attorneys fees?

A claim for attorneys' fees and costs can be a significant boost to an unsecured creditor's claim. It can be used as leverage in the context of claims objections, and in some cases, even be classified as an administrative claim. Since there is rarely a downside to asserting a claim for attorneys' fees, unsecured creditors should always include attorneys' fees in their proofs of claim. In addition, creditors should carefully craft the attorneys' fees clauses in their sales and loan contracts both to comply with state law restrictions on attorneys' fees and to specifically state that the fees incurred in a bankruptcy proceeding may be recovered.

Can an unsecured claim be made under a statute?

In relatively rare cases, an unsecured claim will be made under a statute that includes a fee-shifting provision for the successful plaintiff. 5 For example, a New Jersey statute enables tenants who have been charged more rent than allowable under rent control ordinances to sue for treble damages and attorneys' fees. A successful plaintiff in such a case can include the attorneys' fees awarded under the statute as part of its bankruptcy claim. 6

Can attorneys' fees be recovered?

Attorneys' fees are recoverable if based on a contract enforceable under state law or statute. The majority view—or the view affirmed by the most circuit courts (including the Second, Sixth, Ninth and Eleventh Circuits)—is that attorneys' fees can be included in an unsecured creditors' claim when they are provided for by a specific statute or a contract enforceable under state law. 3 For these courts, the primary legal justification for such awards is that such clauses are simply another contract right, and the Bankruptcy Code specifically states that contract rights can be the basis for a claim. 4 As stated by the Eleven Circuit, "It is established that 'debt' is to be given a broad and expansive reading for the purposes of the Bankruptcy Code...Therefore... "debt"...would appear to include a debtor's contractual obligation to pay a creditor's attorneys' fees." Transouth Financial Corp, supra, 931 F.2d at 1507 .

When contracts provide attorney fees for only one party, are they likely to be enforced?

When contracts provide attorney fees for only one party – as opposed to a provision allowing the successful party to recover its fees – they are less likely to be enforced. It is important that litigants understand the costs of prosecuting or defending a lawsuit. It is my goal to hold these candid conversations with my clients early ...

What is the job of a litigator?

As a litigator, one of my jobs is to ensure that my clients understand the risks and benefits of pursuing or defending a lawsuit. As the saying goes, knowledge is power. Only when my clients understand the economic realities of their case are they empowered to make the right decision for them.

What is Finney Law Firm?

The Finney Law Firm is positioned to serve your litigation and transactional needs. On the front end, we work to provide our commercial clients with contractual documents that will best position them should a dispute later arise. With respect to litigation, we make it our goal to fully inform our clients of all aspects of their case – legal and economic – so that we can empower you to make the best decisions necessary to resolve your disputes.

Can you recover attorney fees in Ohio?

Ohio follows the “American rule” for the recovery of attorney fees under which a prevailing party in a civil action generally cannot recover attorney fees as part of the costs of litigation. Attorney fees may be awarded to the prevailing party, however, when: (1) a federal or state statute explicitly provides for an award of attorney fees; (2) the prevailing party demonstrates bad faith or malicious conduct on the part of the unsuccessful litigant; or (3) where the dispute involves an enforceable contract that contains an attorney fee provision.

Do you have to reimburse your attorney if you prevail in a case?

Frequently, a client will assume that if we prevail in the litigation, the opposing party will have to reimburse my client for his or her attorney fees. But, the reality is that attorney fees are awarded only in special circumstances, and even when those circumstances are present, it is far from guaranteed that a court will award attorney fees to the prevailing party.

Is attorney fee unambiguous?

The court explained that where the attorney fee provision is unambiguous, is not the product of compulsion or duress, and did not result from the parties having unequal bargaining power, the provision should be enforced by the courts.

Is the Ohio Supreme Court ruling on attorney fees void?

Judge Hoover authored a vigorous dissent, however, stating that the Ohio Supreme Court has previously held that contracts for the payment of attorney fees upon default of a debt obligation are void and unenforceable. Judge Hoover reasoned that the Credit Account Application at issue operated as a penalty to the defaulting party and only benefitted the plaintiff/creditor who provided the form agreement. The dissent further opined that contractual attorney fee provisions should only be enforced where the evidence suggests that the provision was freely negotiated by parties with equal bargaining power.

What is the American rule for attorney fees?

The general rule in this country, the so-called "American Rule" is that each party must pay its own attorney's fees. See Alyeska Pipeline Service Co. v. Wilderness Society, 421 U.S. 240 (1975). There are, however, numerous federal statutes providing for attorney fee awards where the United States or a federal agency or official is a party. The most generally applicable statute authorizing attorney's fees awards against the United States is the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), 28 U.S.C. § 2412, which makes the federal government liable for fees where:

What are the grounds for attorney fees?

The principal grounds under which the American common law would permit attorney's fees to be awarded are the "bad faith" and "common fund" theories. The "bad faith" theory allows an award where a party has willfully disobeyed a court order or has "acted in bad faith , vexatiously, wantonly, or for oppressive reasons.".

Which law authorizes attorney fees?

The most generally applicable statute authorizing attorney's fees awards against the United States is the Equal Access to Justice Act (EAJA), 28 U.S.C. § 2412, which makes the federal government liable for fees where:

Is the United States immune from a lawsuit?

Where no statute, including the EAJA, specifically allows for the recovery of fees, sovereign immunity bars the award of fees. It is fundamental that the United States, as a sovereign, is immune from suit save as it consents to be sued and the terms of its consent to be sued in any court define the court's jurisdiction to entertain the suit. See United States v. Mitchell, 445 U.S. 535, 538 (1980). Waivers of sovereign immunity "cannot be implied but must be unequivocally expressed." United States v. King, 395 U.S. 1, 4 (1969). This rule of strict construction has been specifically applied to claims for attorney fee awards against the United States. Library of Congress v. Shaw, 478 U.S. 310 (1986); Ruckelshaus v. Sierra Club, 463 U.S. 680, 685 (1983); Nichols v. Pierce, 740 F.2d 1249, 1258-59 (D.C. Cir. 1984); Commissioner of Highways v. United States, 684 F.2d 443, 444 (7th Cir. 1982); Nibali v. United States, 634 F.2d 494, 497 (Ct.Cl. 1980).

image

The English Rule v. The American Rule

Image
In England, traditionally, the loser in litigation pays the winner’s attorneys’ fees. While the American legal system has indeed borrowed many legal principles from our friends across the pond, this one stayed on the other side of the Atlantic. In America, the general rule is that each side pays its own attorneys’ fees, regardles…
See more on greenmistrettalaw.com

Attorneys’ Fees Awards Within The Court’S Discretion

  • Even though a statute may allow for the recovery of attorneys’ fees by the prevailing party, a court generally has significant discretion in determining the amount of the fee award. Courts often use the “lodestar method” to determine an appropriate amount. When applying the lodestar method, a court multiplies the number of hours reasonably expended by a reasonable hourly rate. The cour…
See more on greenmistrettalaw.com

When to Seek Attorneys’ Fees: An Exercise in Futility?

  • To recover attorneys’ fees, a party must, first and foremost, win the underlying case. This could be at the end of trial or after a dispositive motion (i.e. a motion that ends the case), like a motion for summary judgment. In either event, the prevailing party seeking fees would need to file a motion for attorneys’ fees after judgment is entered in...
See more on greenmistrettalaw.com

Final Thoughts

  • Cost is an important factor in deciding to pursue litigation. Depending on the circumstances, spending $50,000 in attorneys’ fees to obtain a $10,000 judgment may seem a hollow victory. While attorneys’ fees may be recoverable in certain circumstances, it is safest, at the outset, to assume you will not be able to recover them. If you do recover attorney’s fees, it is unlikely you w…
See more on greenmistrettalaw.com