how to sue an executor of an estate and attorney in new york

When an executor breaches her fiduciary duty, you can sue her by filing a lawsuit for damages in civil court. You must establish that she does indeed have a fiduciary responsibility to the estate – she’s accepted the position of executor and this should be clearly confirmed by court documents.

Full Answer

Can you sue an executor of an estate?

Yes. If a beneficiary suspects that they are getting short-changed on their rightful share of the estate, they can sue the executor. We have clients who have been grossly mistreated and lied to by the executor, who is usually a relative and a person they are supposed to estate. We also have clients with the opposite problem – they are executors who are being unfairly accused by the …

What happens if an executor does not pay taxes?

Jan 20, 2021 · As an estate beneficiary, you have certain rights. If you take the time to understand them, you will be better equipped to recognize violations of your beneficiary rights, as well as recognize when there is a need to retain the help of a lawyer to sue the executor of the estate.

How does an executor of an estate settle an estate?

Jul 19, 2018 · The New York estate administration lawyers of Goldfarb Abrandt & Salzman LLP have been providing legal counsel and representation to individuals involved in probate for more than 25 years. To schedule a consultation with a lawyer, call us at (212) 387-8400 or send us an email through our online contact form.

What are the duties of an executor of a will?

Oct 18, 2021 · The Beneficiaries of the Estate May Be Able to Sue the Executor The second type of lawsuit is those brought by beneficiaries of the estate. Although state law does not require an executor to be a lawyer or some other type of expert, it imposes the obligation on every executor to do their job with honesty, good faith, and diligence.

Can you sue an estate in New York?

After the death of an individual, the usual course is to proceed to have a fiduciary appointed to represent the decedent's estate. In some cases the individual would have left a Last Will and Testament, which must be probated. ...Feb 16, 2021

Can a beneficiary challenge an executor?

If the beneficiaries of an estate (or any one of them) believe that an executor is exercising an executor's power in an irrational or biased way, steps can be taken to challenge this and/or remove the offending executor from having any further role in administering the estate.

How long do you have to file a claim against an estate in NY?

seven monthsIn New York, creditors have a maximum of seven months to file claims against an estate.

Does an executor have to show accounting to beneficiaries in NY?

To sum up, does an executor have to show an accounting to beneficiaries? Yes, if they ask for it. If you are looking for a New York estate attorney who has experience with executor accountings in New York estate, we at the Law Offices of Albert Goodwin are here for you.

Can I sue an executor?

If the executor fails to live up to their legal obligations, a beneficiary can sue them for breach of fiduciary duty. If there is more than one beneficiary, all beneficiaries must agree in order to sue an executor.Oct 18, 2021

Can one executor sue another executor?

If an agreement cannot be reached through negotiations, and a Grant of Representation has already been issued by the Probate Court, then it is possible for one Executor to apply to the Court to remove the other.Apr 10, 2019

Can I make a claim against an estate?

Making a claim against an estate. After the death of a person, their Will can be contested by relatives, dependents and others. A claim can be made for 'reasonable financial provision' in the Court. Similarly, if a person died without a will, the claim can be made under intestacy rules.

How long do you have to file a claim against an estate?

A claim for reasonable financial provision must be made within six months after probate or letters of administration have been issued, although the court can extend this period in certain circumstances (eg if the applicant has not made an earlier claim because of negotiations with the executors or administrators).

How long does an executor have to settle an estate NY?

The average length of the basic steps in the probate process in New York include: Appointment as administrator or executor of the estate: About four to six months. Settling the estate: About six to nine months. Closing the estate: About two to three months.Oct 26, 2021

Can beneficiaries demand to see deceased bank statements?

Some times beneficiaries want to see more detailed documents such as a Deceased's bank statement or pension documentation. Strictly speaking a beneficiary has no entitlement as of right to such documentation and it is your discretion as Executor whether or not to disclose it. The nature of the beneficiary's interest.Jun 19, 2019

What does an executor have to disclose to beneficiaries?

One of the Executor's duties is to inform all next of kin and beneficiaries of: The deceased's death; The appointment of themselves as an Executor/Administrator; Their inheritance – be it a specific item, cash sum or share of the estate.

Should an executor keep beneficiaries informed?

What Does an Executor Have to Tell Beneficiaries? Executors generally serve as a beneficiary's only conduit of information. As a result, executors have a responsibility to keep beneficiaries reasonably informed about the estate and administration.Jul 26, 2021

Why do you sue an executor?

Examples of valid reasons for suing an executor of an estate include: Executor failed to provide accountings to estate beneficiaries.

What happens to a decedent's estate when he dies?

When a decedent passes away, the decedent’s “estate” comprises all of the assets the decedent included in their will and any other assets the decedent owned, excluding property in the decedent’s trust or assets that have designated payable-on-death beneficiaries.

Why is it important for estate beneficiaries to familiarize themselves with their beneficiary rights at every stage of administration?

It is important for estate beneficiaries to familiarize themselves with their beneficiary rights at every stage of administration so that if anyone – e.g., the executor or administrator, another beneficiary, or an heir – violates them, immediate action can be taken.

What happens if you are named as a beneficiary of an estate?

As an estate beneficiary, you have certain rights. If you take the time to understand them, you will be better equipped to recognize violations of your beneficiary rights, as well as recognize when there is a need to retain the help of a lawyer to sue the executor of the estate.

Why are estate beneficiaries important?

Estate beneficiaries have important rights to not only protect against inheritance theft but also to ensure that the worth of the estate is not compromised before the executor or administrator is permitted to distribute assets.

Why do we need a small estate affidavit in California?

Because the probate process is also expensive and burdensome for the courts, the California Legislature has created mechanisms by which probate can be expedited or avoided entirely. For instance, if an estate is worth less than $166,250, a Small Estate Affidavit can potentially be used to altogether avoid probate.

Who takes care of estate taxes?

Any taxes that do need to be paid in relation to the estate are usually taken care of by the executor or administrator during administration prior to making any distributions. The majority of estate beneficiaries can rest assured that they will receive their distributions from a decedent’s estate in full.

What to do if executor of estate has not acted?

If you believe that the executor of your estate has not acted in accordance with his or her fiduciary duties, you should speak to an attorney about bringing an action against the executor in addition to seeking removal.

What to do if you suspect an executor of an estate is dishonest?

If you suspect that an executor of an estate in which you have an interest is engaging in unethical conduct, being dishonest with you, or is unable to effectively do his or her job due to mental illness, substance abuse, or some other condition, speak to an attorney as soon as you can.

What is the role of executor in a will?

Some of an executor’s responsibilities include paying the estate’s debts and taxes, accounting for the assets of the estate, paying creditors, and distributing the estate’s assets to beneficiaries. Unfortunately, in some circumstances, an executor fails to comply with the terms of a will, engages in misconduct in violation of his or her fiduciary duties, or cannot discharge his or her duties. When this occurs, it may be possible to remove the executor through legal action.

When is it important to remove an executor?

When the executor of an estate engages in misconduct or otherwise violates his or her fiduciary duties, the damage to the estate can be irreparable, so it is important to act quickly if you believe that the removal of an executor is necessary or appropriate.

Why is the executor removed?

Some of the specific reasons an executor may be removed include the following: Mismanagement of the estate’s assets. Dishonesty about the condition of the estate or the decedent’s affairs.

What to do if you are the beneficiary of an estate?

If you are the beneficiary of an estate and believe that the executor is not properly executing his or her duties, you should speak to an experienced attorney. Any delay can result in the loss or dissipation of the estate’s assets, so it is in your best interest to immediately after realizing there may be a problem.

What are the responsibilities of an executor?

Some of an executor’s responsibilities include paying the estate’s debts and taxes, accounting for the assets of the estate, paying creditors, and distributing the estate’s assets to beneficiaries. Unfortunately, in some circumstances, an executor fails to comply with the terms of a will, engages in misconduct in violation ...

How to sue an executor for breach of fiduciary duty?

The Legal Process. When an executor breaches her fiduciary duty, you can sue her by filing a lawsuit for damages in civil court. You must establish that she does indeed have a fiduciary responsibility to the estate – she’s accepted the position of executor and this should be clearly confirmed by court documents.

What is the fiduciary duty of executor of will?

Fiduciary Duty. The executor of a will has a fiduciary duty to the estate and its beneficiaries – an obligation to always act in their best interests and not her own. This prohibits her from taking certain actions: She can’t make risky or unsafe investments or transactions on behalf of the estate.

What happens if you win a case?

If you win your case, the executor may be ordered to personally reimburse you for losses you and other beneficiaries sustained because of her actions. If the estate is still open, the executor will most likely be removed from office and someone else will be appointed to serve .

What to do if you believe someone is doing something wrong?

If you have reason to believe he is doing something wrong, you can file a show cause proceeding in many states . This isn't a whole new lawsuit, but a motion you'd make as part of probate case. You can ask the judge to order the executor to make a full accounting of what he’s done so far.

What happens if an estate loses money?

If the estate has already lost money or value, the accounting might provide pivotal, concrete evidence if you also choose to sue him in a separate civil action lawsuit. Beverly Bird is a practicing paralegal who has been writing professionally on legal subjects for over 30 years.

What to do if you haven't received anything?

If you haven’t received anything, this might be a good indication that something’s wrong. Keep a chronological diary of actions he’s taken that you consider wrong. The rules for filing a complaint with the court are the same as with any civil lawsuit, including doing so before the statute of limitations expires.

Do executors have to notify the court of an estate?

Although the exact process can vary by state, executors don’ t always work under a legal microscope when settling an estate. After the initial flurry of court filings, they may not be required to notify the court of the estate’s progress until they file the final accountings with the court. This leaves a lot of time and opportunity ...

What happens if you leave a last will and testament?

In some cases the individual would have left a Last Will and Testament, which must be probated.   This results in the appointment of an executor.   If there is no Will, a proceeding needs to be commenced to have an administrator appointed. Whether an executor or administratoris given authority by the Surrogate’s Court, ...

What to do after death of a person?

After the death of an individual, the usual course is to proceed to have a fiduciary appointed to represent the decedent’s estate. This is necessary in order to have someone who has the legal ... Free Consultation: (212) 355-2575Tap Here To Call Us. This is Attorney Advertising.

What is the case of Dubois v Beaury?

Beaury, in which a lawsuit was commenced in the United States District Court for the Northern District of New York, the plaintiff’s failure to understand this concept led to the dismissal of his case. In DuBois, the plaintiff commenced his lawsuit which ...

Can an estate be sued in New York?

A New York Estate is Not a Legal Entity and Cannot Be Sued. by Jules M. Haas. After the death of an individual, the usual course is to proceed to have a fiduciary appointed to represent the decedent’s estate. This is necessary in order to have someone who has the legal authority to collect the decedent’s assets, ...

Who dismissed Corbitt's case?

Corbitt’s widow asked the Court to dismiss the case.   In an opinion dated November 30, 2020, United States District Judge Frederick Sullivan granted the dismissal. The Court found that under New York law an estate is not a legal entity.

Is a decedent's estate a separate entity?

It is not always known that a decedent’s estate, at least in New York, is not recognized as a separate legal entity. The nature of a decedent’s post-death proceedings flow from the existence and authority given to the appointed fiduciaries.

Who to consult before taking compensation in New York?

As you can see, it is now always easy to determine which assets are included in the calculation, so an executor is well advised to consult with a New York estate attorney before taking their compensation.

Is interest received from property of the estate included in executor compensation?

For example, interest received from property of the estate is included in when you calculate the executor compensation, but the property itself may not be included because the executor is not involved in the property’s sale. This is sometimes counterintuitive, because the executor usually is involved in retitling the property from ...

Can an executor take advance compensation in New York?

However, New York SCPA 2310 and 2311 do authorize the executor to apply to the court for the advance payment of compensation, and will be able to take advance compensation if the judge issues an order allowing them to do so.

Is executor compensation taxed?

Is Executor Compensation Subject to Income Tax. Yes, typical New York executor compensation is counted as income and is subject to income tax. On the other hand, the IRS and New York Department of Revenue give estate executors an option to not take commissions and not pay income tax.

Can an executor serve without compensation?

Some wills direct that the executor is to serve without compensation, but those wills are far and few in between. Even fewer wills specify the amount or the percentages of the executor compensation. Typical executor compensation is in accordance with SCPA 2307, but a will can change that default.

Is real estate a part of an estate?

real estate given to specific beneficiaries is also not a part of the estate. Specific legacy or devise is not includable in commission calculation – the value of real property or personal property left to a specific person cannot be used as a basis of calculating executor commissions.

Is property that the executor is not receiving and paying out included in calculating their commission?

As a rule of thumb, property that the executor is not receiving and paying out is not included in calculating their commission.

What happens if an executor is removed?

If you have standing to seek removal of an executor, you may also be entitled to money damages for your losses. You should discuss this with an experienced New York wills and trusts lawyer to protect your interests.

Why do you have to remove an executor?

There are many reasons why an executor may need to be removed, including substance abuse, mental illness or other conditions. The following are some grounds that are typically the basis of a legal action to remove an executor: An inability to manage the affairs of the estate (often because of physical and/or mental infirmities) ...

What happens if you believe the executor is wrong?

If you truly believe there is some type of executor misconduct, there are ways of handling the situation. The beneficiaries can take the executor to the court, which might result in the court forcing the executor to give a full accounting of financial transactions. The court can also remove the executor or prevent the executor from receiving a fee.

What is executor misconduct?

E xecutor misconduct is serious. When an executor is withholding an inheritance, not communicating with beneficiaries, or taking too long, it’s easy for beneficiaries to get frustrated. Feelings of helplessness and lack of control can lead to anger and even ruin relationships. Fortunately, there are things you can do to get executors to act appropriately, although you must understand what the executor is legally required to do and what actually constitutes executor misconduct.

What is the duty of executors of a will?

Executors have a fiduciary duty to the deceased person they are acting for and the beneficiaries of the will. This means they must act in the best interests of these parties. They must keep proper records of all financial transactions and show those records to residual beneficiaries, should they wish to see them.

What happens if an estate is insolvent?

Similarly, if an estate is insolvent, meaning the liabilities are more than the assets, the beneficiaries will not receive a distribution. But there have been cases where the executor has delayed distributing the estate for other reasons.

Does the executor have to consult with beneficiaries?

Residuary beneficiaries have the right to know what is going on throughout the probate process. However, the executor isn’ t required to consult with the beneficiar ies or keep them updated every single step of the way. Being an executor can be challenging and sometimes beneficiaries confuse ...

Is the executor acting as you would if you were the executor?

First, recognize that the process may not be moving as quickly as you would like, but that doesn ’t mean it isn’t moving along. The executor may not be acting as you would if you were the executor, but that still doesn’t mean that he or she is doing anything wrong. If you truly believe there is some type of executor misconduct, ...

What is it called when family members are appointed as executors?

When family members are appointed as executors, also called personal representatives, stealing from the estate is very common. People can be greedy and having access to money makes it all too easy to use that money for their own pleasure.