how to choose a criminal attorney

by Marvin Rutherford 6 min read

  1. Look for responsiveness and efficiency. When it comes to criminal charges, you need an attorney who will be quick to act and respond to your calls.
  2. Choose an attorney with proven experience. Not only will you be looking for a firm that has experience in criminal defense, but you’ll also want to make sure they ...
  3. Do your research. You know what you need in a criminal defense attorney, now you just need to find him or her. ...
  4. Ask questions at the meeting. Once you’ve found a firm, or maybe a few, that you want to meet with to see who will work best for you, make ...
  5. Make sure they are giving you the time needed. If you have a complicated case–as many criminal defense trials can be–you need to make sure your chosen attorney is ...
  6. Confidence is key. Obviously, your attorney cannot guarantee a specific outcome. ...

Full Answer

How do I choose an attorney to represent me?

How To Choose the Right Lawyer: Ten Points to Consider When Selecting an AttorneyIdentify Your Legal Problem and Use a Specialist. ... Make Sure the Attorney has the Right Experience. ... Expect the Attorney to be a Good Communicator. ... Consider the Attorney's Professionalism.More items...

What are the signs of a good lawyer?

Top 10 Signs You Have Hired the Best Lawyer for Your CaseExperience.Results.Trial Victories.Honesty.Integrity.Objectivity.Pragmatic Optimism.Creativity.More items...•Nov 19, 2021

What should you not say to a lawyer?

9 Taboo Sayings You Should Never Tell Your LawyerI forgot I had an appointment. ... I didn't bring the documents related to my case. ... I have already done some of the work for you. ... My case will be easy money for you. ... I have already spoken with 5 other lawyers. ... Other lawyers don't have my best interests at heart.More items...•Mar 17, 2021

What is unethical for a lawyer?

Attorney misconduct may include: conflict of interest, overbilling, refusing to represent a client for political or professional motives, false or misleading statements, knowingly accepting worthless lawsuits, hiding evidence, abandoning a client, failing to disclose all relevant facts, arguing a position while ...

Experience

How many criminal appeals has the attorney worked on? Do they do one every couple years or is it a focus of their practice? How long have they been doing it? These are all reasonable questions to ask an attorney you’re thinking about hiring. I worked at the Michigan Court of Appeals as a prehearing attorney right out of law school.

Knowledge

Any criminal appeals attorney should be able to answer most common client questions without blinking. How long will the appeal take? How many criminal appeals are successful? How important is oral argument? These and other common questions should not stump an attorney. If they do, head for the door.

Results

Criminal appeals are extremely difficult to win. It’s estimated that only about 3% of criminal appeals succeed in the Michigan Court of Appeals. There are many excellent criminal appellate attorneys who have only won a handful of cases. Still, I think it’s fair to ask any attorney how many appeals they’ve won.

Professional development

A good criminal appeal attorney must constantly stay abreast of changes in the law. Every week, the Michigan Court of Appeals and Michigan Supreme Court are issuing opinions and orders that shape and reshape the law. Ask an attorney you’re considering for your criminal appeal what they do to keep track of changes in the law.

Proportion of practice

How much of the attorney’s practice consists of criminal appeals? If an attorney offers to do your criminal appeal, write your will, and finalize your divorce, that’s a good sign that their practice is not focused on criminal appeals. Don’t hire that attorney. Criminal appeals are extraordinarily complex. You want a specialist, not a generalist.

Caseload

How many cases do you currently have? Every client should ask their prospective attorney this question. Do you want to be one of a hundred clients or one of twenty? The fewer clients the attorney has, the more attention each client—and their case—is going to get.

Ask for a work sample

This one is somewhat unconventional. I’ve actually never had a client ask to see a sample of my work before they hired me. Which is kind of crazy. You should ask any attorney you’re considering for your criminal appeal to see a brief on appeal that they’ve prepared in another case.

image

Choosing An Experienced Defense Attorney

Image
Which leads to the point of this blog entry. How to choose an attorney? My suggestion would be to start with experience. When faced with the uncertainty of a criminal charge, you want to make sure you hire an advocate that has been where you are before with other clients. Experience is a must and the first place to start; …
See more on delucalawfirmny.com

Attorney with Trial Experience

  • Most cases will settle and will not end in trial, but you want to make sure that the attorney you choose, has the skill to try a case and more importantly that the government is aware of that fact. Likening a negotiation to poker, you cannot play the game, unless you have the ability to go all in. Trial experience, in my opinion, is the base of the pyramid that negotiation is constructed upon.
See more on delucalawfirmny.com

The Right Personality to Negotiate

  • Lastly, keep in mind that most cases settle. Meaning that the attorney you choose should be personable. It’s a must that you sit down with them and use the skills that you have gained your entire life to assess if this is the man or woman you want to send in to advocate on your behalf. The well-known law firms that hire the associate that had the b...
See more on delucalawfirmny.com

Initial Case Evaluation

  • I will not take on every case that comes into the office. If a client does not understand the dynamic that must exist between client and attorney in order to be successful, I will not enter into that relationship. Abraham Lincoln, a man who is revered as one of the best presidents and attorneys to have ever practiced said that a house divided against itself, cannot stand. There mu…
See more on delucalawfirmny.com