how does attorney get paid in chapter 11

by Alvah Prohaska 6 min read

Initial attorney fee retainers for a small to mid-sized Chapter 11 case vary, but expect between $9,000 and $30,000 depending upon the complexity of the case. With the complex fees and other requirements associated with Chapter 11 bankruptcy, it can be complicated to understand how the payment of attorneys’ fees works.

Under the Bankruptcy Code, attorneys and other professionals who provide services for the debtor and official committees are entitled to be paid from the bankruptcy estate – the pool of assets and monies otherwise available to pay creditors – but the attorneys and other professionals must first file applications to be ...

Full Answer

How do I pay my attorney fees in Chapter 13 bankruptcy?

If you file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy, you might need to come up with a portion of your attorney fees upfront. But you can typically pay the remainder of your fees through your repayment plan after your case is filed. (To learn more about how a Chapter 13 plan works, see our topic area on The Chapter 13 Repayment Plan .)

How do bankruptcy lawyers get paid?

Most debtors who file for bankruptcy don't have a lot of money to pay for an attorney. For this reason, many people wonder how bankruptcy lawyers get paid. In general, how a bankruptcy attorney gets paid depends on whether you are filing for Chapter 7 or Chapter 13 bankruptcy. Read on to learn more about how bankruptcy lawyers get paid.

What is a Chapter 11 debtor's life like?

In the two most recent installments, the authors provided an overview of a chapter 11 debtor's life, from preparing for bankruptcy through plan confirmation and emergence. Now, the authors switch perspectives and talk about chapter 11 from the secured creditor's perspective. There's an old adage that "where you stand depends on where you sit."

Do you have to pay attorney fees before filing a case?

Because your attorney can’t try to collect his or her unpaid fees after filing your case, you will normally have to pay all attorney fees upfront before your case is filed. Further, unpaid fees can lead to conflicts of interest between debtors and their attorneys.

image

Who gets paid in Chapter 11?

Secured creditors, like banks, typically get paid first in a Chapter 11 bankruptcy, followed by unsecured creditors, like bondholders and suppliers of goods and services. Stockholders are typically last in line to get paid. Not all creditors get repaid in full under a Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

How long does it take to settle a Chapter 11?

There is no time limit on completing the repayment plan. Most take between six months and two years. The Chapter 11 filing fee is $1,738, but that's just the start since Chapter 11 bankruptcies are usually complicated.

Do employees get paid when a company files Chapter 11?

In a Chapter 11 bankruptcy or “reorganization,” the employer remains in business and tries to reorganize and emerge from bankruptcy as a financially sound company. Many employees may remain at work and continue to be paid and receive benefits. However, some may be laid off.

Does Chapter 11 protect from lawsuit?

One of the most significant features of chapter 11 bankruptcy is its ability to shield the debtor from collateral litigation. Chapter 11 provides that all such litigation is “automatically stayed” upon the filing of the bankruptcy petition.

Does the trustee monitor your bank account?

While your trustee will most likely periodically check all of your financial accounts such as your bank accounts, in order to ensure that you have enough money to continue making your bankruptcy payments, they are not permitted to touch any of your funds, other than the funds which are allocated for your secured loan ...

Does Chapter 11 wipe out all debt?

The central element of a Chapter 11 bankruptcy is the creation of a plan to repay creditors all or part of what is owed. Once the bankruptcy court approves this, the business still has to repay its remaining debts but the legal part of the bankruptcy process is essentially over.

How are unpaid wages treated in bankruptcies?

Under this classification of bankruptcy, when an organization owes employees' wages, the employees then become creditors of the bankrupt company. As with other creditors, employees who are owed wages share in the remaining assets of bankrupt employer.

Can a company survive Chapter 11?

Chapter 11 can include a certain amount of downsizing and liquidation, but many businesses can survive this process and reorganize successfully.

What happens to my pension if my company files Chapter 11?

A Chapter 11 (reorganization) usually means that the company continues in business under the court's protection while attempting to reorganize its financial affairs. A Chapter 11 bankruptcy may or may not affect your pension or health plan.

Do unsecured creditors get paid in Chapter 11?

An unsecured creditor with a nonpriority claim must be paid at least as much as the creditor would have received had the debtor filed under Chapter 7, and the payments need not be in cash. Nonpriority claims may be paid in cash, property, or securities of the debtor or the successor to the debtor under the plan.

What happens at the end of Chapter 11?

During a Chapter 11 bankruptcy, businesses usually retain possession and control of their assets under the supervision of a bankruptcy court. Filing for Chapter 11 suspends all judgments, collection activities, foreclosures, and repossessions of property against the filing business.

How are unsecured creditors paid?

General unsecured creditors get paid on a pro rata basis. They'll all receive the same percentage of the balance owed. However, as long as you act in good faith, you may selectively pay nonpriority claims, in effect favoring some creditors over others.

Seven Ways for Professionals to Get Paid in Chapter 11

Payment of professionals in Chapter 11 is a complex process intended to ensure transparency and fairness. It can also be a maze filled with traps for the unwary.

We hope you enjoyed your free content!

Access the Journal of Corporate Renewal and other content in the Learning Link.

What is a disqualified professional person?

disqualified professional persons without providing consistent bases for their

When do conflicts of interest need to be raised?

conflicts of interest need only be raised when an attorney is petitioning for

Is debtor relief unanimous?

debtor relief, "courts simply aren't unanimous on how these conflicts ought to be reconciled-and

Will the court compensate the DIP?

court will not compensate and is more likely to allow the DIP to make

Do attorneys get paid for bankruptcy?

Most attorneys expect to be paid for their work. In bankruptcy, however, an

Who examines DIP's and attorney's?

creditors, and other interested parties to examine the DIP's and attorney's

What is the Fifth Circuit ruling on bankruptcy?

Consequently, based on the Fifth Circuit's ultimate ruling, the bankruptcy community must assume that the Fifth Circuit interpreted §§327, 330 and 1107 as allowing compensation for either the trustee's counsel or debtor's counsel, but not both, based on the termination of DIP status after chapter 11 trustee appointment. However, the Fifth Circuit did not include such a discussion in its actual holding, even though, as that court mentioned, the creditor/appellees raised exactly this point. Family Snacks, 157 F.3d at 424-26.

What court case held that bankruptcy cannot award compensation to debtors counsel from estate assets for work performed after the appointment of?

The Family Snacks Opinion. In Family Snacks, the Fifth Circuit held that a bankruptcy court cannot award compensation to debtor's counsel from estate assets for work performed after the appointment of a chapter 11 trustee.

What are the negative effects of family snacks?

Family Snacks creates many problems for debtor's counsel and has potentially negative ramifications for the bankruptcy community. In addition to the obvious economic ramifications, there are ethical and legal ramifications, not to mention the reluctance of debtor's counsel to perform any service after the appointment of a chapter 11 trustee.

How to receive priority claim under 507?

First, counsel must seek and obtain approval under §327. 2 Section 327 states that the trustee, or debtor-in-possession (DIP) pursuant to §1107, may employ an attorney or other professional person to represent or assist the trustee or DIP. 11 U.S.C. §327 (a) (1999).

What is the Fifth Circuit opinion on Family Snacks?

However, the Fifth Circuit's opinion contains an incomplete analysis and focuses on statutory construction of the 1994 Amendments.

When to consider trustee representation?

Also, if the necessary work does not create a conflict of interest, consider trustee representation when such representation furthers the debtor's goals. The conflict-of-interest issue is pertinent here to prevent ethical as well as fiduciary problems. When debtor's counsel is hired for a special purpose, however, the code actually supports such employment. See 11 U.S.C. §327 (e) (1999).

Does bankruptcy require an attorney to be a counsel?

Thus, the lawyer remains counsel for the debtor. Furthermore, state law ethical obligations may require an attorney to continue to perform as counsel, regardless of the potential prohibition of payment. Thus, the attorney works for free.

What happened to Castellino and Picerne?

Castellino defaulted under its agreement with Picerne by failing to pay Picerne and Picerne's subcontractors for work ­performed on the site. Picerne recorded a mechanic's lien against the property and filed a state court complaint against Castellino to foreclose the mechanic's lien. Picerne later amended the state court complaint to include Bank of the West, Castellino's lender, as a defendant. Bank of the West held a deed of trust encumbering the subject property, and disputed Picerne's claim that Picerne's mechanic's lien was superior in priority to Bank of the West's lien on the property. Castellino also disputed the validity, priority, and amount of Picerne's lien.

What is the impact of Castellino case?

The Castellino case illustrates the ­consequences to creditors that fail to ­negotiate language into a Chapter 11 plan preserving certain contractual rights and claims. The result in Castellino could likely have been avoided had Picerne insisted that the settlement agreement and plan preserve any potential claims for attorneys' fees in accordance with the terms of the original agreement with Castellino. In light of the holding in Castellino, creditors that have a statutory or contractual right to recover attorney fees resulting from pre-petition litigation (whether or not such claim is contingent or unliquidated at the time of plan confirmation) should attempt to negotiate the appropriate language into a proposed Chapter 11 plan in order to avoid discharge of the claim upon plan confirmation.

What issues are considered during the Chapter 11 plan confirmation process?

One such issue involves the dischargeability of a claim that accrues pre-petition, continues to accrue after the filing of the debtor's Chapter 11 petition, and extends beyond confirmation of the debtor's plan of reorganization. The recent decision in In re Castellino Villas, A.K.F, D.C. No. 2:12-cv-07282-JFW (9th Cir. 2016) highlights the importance to creditors of negotiating language expressly preserving a contractual right to attorney fees incurred in litigation commenced ­pre-petition that continues post-petition and post-confirmation.

Why did the court stay Picerne's action?

The court stayed Picerne's action in order to permit arbitration between the parties pursuant to the terms of Picerne's ­construction contract with Castellino. That contract contained a provision for the award of attorney fees and costs to the prevailing party in the event of litigation arising from the parties' performance under the contract. An arbitration award was issued in favor of Picerne and confirmed by the state court. On the same day that the state court entered its order confirming the arbitration award, Castellino filed a ­petition for protection under Chapter 11 of the Bankruptcy Code.

What is fair contemplation?

The circuit court applied the "fair ­contemplation" test and focused its ­ analysis on whether post-confirmation fees ­incurred in the state court litigation "arose" ­pre-petition as a contingent, unliquidated claim that was discharged upon confirmation of the plan.

Did Picerne file for bankruptcy?

The bankruptcy filing automatically stayed Picerne's state court action, and Picerne consequently filed a motion for ­relief from the stay seeking an order allowing the parties to continue litigation of the state court action. That motion was granted by the bankruptcy court.

Can a creditor's contingent claim be discharged in bankruptcy?

Therefore, a creditor's contingent claim to such fees is discharged in bankruptcy, even if some fees were incurred post-petition."

How to retain a bankruptcy attorney?

If you are filing for Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you can typically retain an attorney by paying only a portion of the total attorney fees upfront and setting up a payment plan for the rest. When you retain a bankruptcy attorney, he or she will usually talk to your creditors or send letters to them on your behalf.

What is Martindale Nolo?

Nolo is a part of the Martindale Nolo network, which has been matching clients with attorneys for 100+ years.

What happens if you file Chapter 7 bankruptcy?

Chapter 7 Bankruptcy. When you file for bankruptcy relief, an automatic stay goes into effect that prohibits most creditors from collecting their debts from you. If you have unpaid attorney fees, they typically get discharged (eliminated) in your bankruptcy along with many of your other debts.

How long does it take to pay back a Chapter 13 bankruptcy?

Chapter 13 bankruptcy is designed to allow debtors to pay back some or all of their debts through a three- to five-year repayment plan. One of the debts you can include in your repayment plan is your bankruptcy attorney's fees.

Can you pay your fees after filing a Chapter 13?

But you can typically pay the remainder of your fees through your repayment plan after your case is filed. (To learn more about how a Chapter 13 plan works, see our topic area on The Chapter 13 Repayment Plan .)

Do you have to pay attorney fees upfront?

Because your attorney can't try to collect his or her un paid fees after filing your case, you will normally have to pay all attorney fees upfront before your case is filed. Further, unpaid fees can lead to conflicts of interest between debtors and their attorneys.

What is adequate protection in bankruptcy?

One natural idea for adequate protection would be to give the secured creditor an administrative priority claim to the extent of any diminution in its collateral value. But §361 (3) of the Bankruptcy Code provides that this is not adequate protection. However, should a secured lender's adequate protection prove to be insufficient to compensate it for a loss of collateral value during the case, the lender may be entitled to a "super-priority" administrative claim under §507 (b), which gives the lender priority over other "regular" administrative claims, and acts as a backstop provision to protect the secured lender.

What if the debtor is using the proceeds of a lender's "hard collateral" to preserve that hard?

What if the debtor is using the proceeds of a lender's "hard collateral" to preserve that hard collateral ( i.e., rents generated by an apartment building are used to preserve and maintain the building)? Often such an arrangement is, without more, considered adequate protection because the maintenance and upkeep of the building benefits the lender as mortgagee. In a similar fashion, if the secured lender has an equity cushion, where the value of the "hard collateral" substantially exceeds the amount of the secured debt, that lender is likely to be deemed to have adequate protection. The theory for this outcome is that if the value of the secured creditor's collateral substantially exceeds the debt owed to it, the use of cash collateral is unlikely to present an unfair risk to the secured lender.

What is a secured creditor?

A secured creditor may be the holder of a real estate mortgage, a bank with a lien on all assets, a receivables lender, an equipment lender, the holder of a statutory lien or any number of other types of entities. It may be a senior lender or a subordinate lender. It may be oversecured, fully secured or undersecured.

How much interest should a secured creditor receive for a $1 million debt?

In other words, if the collateral value is $1 million and the debt amount is $950,000, then the secured creditor should only receive post-petition interest (and fees) up to a total of $50,000.

Why does collateral value decrease in bankruptcy?

For example, if your collateral is a new car, and the debtor, during the case, drives the car for a year and puts 15,000 miles on it , the value will be diminished. Another reason for diminution may be market value. This is common, for example, if the collateral is securities. But it also happens with other assets whose value fluctuates over time.

What is adequate protection?

Adequate protection, described in §361 of the Bankruptcy Code, can take on many forms, including periodic cash payments to the secured lender, payment of post-petition interest or the granting of additional liens to the creditor on previously unencumbered assets.

What is the task of a secured creditor in a contested hearing?

During a contested hearing, the secured creditor must establish that the cash at issue is, in fact, its cash collateral, a task that is ordinarily not very difficult (but don't forget to have competent evidence at the hearing).

image