can you get attorney fees when not erisa

Although not the subject of this article, attorney’s fees may also be obtained in non-ERISA state court insurance bad faith cases too. In this article, we focus on the importance of ERISA’s fee-shifting provisions and some of the contours of that statutory remedy.

Full Answer

How to find an ERISA attorney?

 · While not all ERISA cases go far enough to result in an award of attorneys’ fees, a person who has been denied ERISA benefits, or benefits under any insurance offered through work, should consult an attorney who understands the ERISA attorney fee provisions, and will seek to obtain the most in attorneys’ fees that can be reasonably be awarded, which …

Does ERISA apply to me?

 · ERISA’s Fee-Shifting Provision. ERISA provides a “fee-shifting,” statutory exception to the American Rule. See 29 U.S.C. § 1132 (g) (1). More like the English Rule’s loser-pays regime, this provision grants the court discretion to award reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs in an ERISA action. ERISA’s generous fee-shifting provision does not even require that the party …

What are the penalties for ERISA violations?

 · Probably not. In most cases, attorney fees awarded under ERISA in federal court will only reduce your out-of-pocket attorney fees and you are still responsible for attorney fees associated with either a disability insurance application or an administrative, insurance-level appeal. However, there are exceptions to this rule.

What is an ERISA claim, and why is ERISA so?

Plan administrators owe duties to plan participants and beneficiaries, namely a requirement to respond to written requests for information. Failure or refusal to provide this information to a …

Why did the court uphold the District Court's exception to the exhaustion requirement?

Accordingly, the Court upheld the District Court’s exception to the exhaustion requirement because Unum gave Mr. Dishman inadequate notice of the denial and available appeals procedure. Further, the court also largely agreed with the District Court’s award of all Mr. Dishman’s attorneys’ fees (absent interest thereon) because:

Can you challenge a wrongfully denied claim?

Challenging a wrongfully denied claim for life, health, long-term disability or accidental death and dismemberment benefits can be a very time-consuming endeavor for law firms handling these types of cases. The resources required to fight a sophisticated insurer can quickly become very expensive. Without the ability to collect attorney’s fees, many ...

Is ERISA a statutory exception?

First, we provide a brief background on attorneys’ fees in our legal system, largely governed by the “American Rule.” Next, we discuss ERISA’s fee-shifting provision as a statutory exception to that rule and as applied by the Ninth Circuit in Dishman v. UNUM Life Ins. Co. of Am., 269 F.3d 974 (9th Cir. 2001).

Does ERISA apply to fees?

ERISA’s fee-shifting provision applies only to those fees incurred in preparation of litigation and not typically in the requisite administrative appeals process. However, there are exceptions to this rule. One case that discusses such an exception is Dishman v. UNUM Life Ins. Co. of Am., 269 F.3d 974 (9th Cir. 2001), in which the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals approved an award of attorneys’ fees for work that would otherwise be considered part of the administrative process. In Dishman, the court approved plaintiff’s attorneys’ fees because it found that there was nothing to pare off, as the insurer did not make an adequate administrative remedy available to plaintiff.

What Is ERISA?

ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974) is a federal law that governs employee benefit plans. The law covers most employer-sponsored short-term and long-term disability insurance plans as well as group health insurance plans and other benefit programs.

Contact Bryant Legal Group

Get the answers and insight you deserve. Our experienced disability insurance lawyers can evaluate your claim and help you understand all your legal options.

ERISA Plan Administrator Required to Provide Information

Upon request, a plan administrator is required to provide the following to a participant or beneficiary of an ERISA plan:

ERISA Provides for Punitive-Type Damages for Failure to Provide Required Information

Although not awarded here, the statutory penalty provisions of 29 U.S.C. § 1332 (c) is “meant to be in the nature of punitive damages, designed more for the purpose of punishing the violator than compensating the participant or beneficiary.” Again, a plan administrator is required to respond to written requests for information.

Does Aetna approve Geiger's claim?

The court further recognized that since Aetna had twice approved Geiger’s claim and the Social Security Administration’s concurrent approval of disability benefits further “bolster [ed] the reasonableness of her litigation position, as it validates the reliability of the medical evidence upon which she relied.” The court further added, “ [a] grant of attorneys’ fees may have a chilling effect on beneficiaries seeking redress for legitimate claims.”

Is there a basis for awarding fees in an ERISA case?

This ruling illustrates that there is rarely a basis for awarding fees to a prevailing defendant in an ERISA benefit case. The only cases in which fees have been awarded have been situations where the litigation was frivolous and brought in bad faith. The court’s remarks about the evidence supporting the plaintiff also suggest that she has a reasonable chance on appeal since the court of appeals applies the de novo standard of appellate review over a summary judgment ruling.

What is the phone number for ERISA?

If your ERISA or non-ERISA claim for health, life, short-term disability or long-term disability insurance has been denied, you can call (949)387-9595 for a free consultation with the attorneys of the McKennon Law Group PC, several of whom previously represented insurance companies ...

Does ERISA cover attorneys fees?

ERISA law, as interpreted by the courts, allows for recovery of attorneys’ fees, although whether the attorneys’ fees are covered is at the discretion of the judge.

How much can you be fined for ERISA violations?

Under the Act, individuals may now be fined up to $100,000 and jailed up to 10 years, and companies may face up to $500,000 in fines for ERISA violations.

How can ERISA be punished?

The first of these is if someone who is covered by a plan, or a plan beneficiary, files a complaint against the violator. Generally, such a person would first need to exhaust certain administrative procedures to seek corrective action before filing any lawsuit. The second way is through an action initiated by the Employee Benefits Security Administration, or EBSA , which is a part of the Department of Labor that enforces federal laws related to retirement plans and health insurance policies.

Can ESBA recover ERISA violations?

However, some the of things that ERISA allows an impacted party to recover are: When ESBA assesses civil penalties for ERISA violations, the amount of the fine generally depends on the degree of willfulness with which the violations were committed.

Can you be imprisoned for violating Erisa?

The second are criminal punishments, which can mean not only that a party may need to pay a fine but that a person convicted of violating an ERISA requirement may be im prisoned. Let's have a closer look at these penalties and punishments for ERISA violations more closely. Thank you for subscribing!

What are the most common violations of ERISA?

Some of the most common ERISA violations include: Improperly denying benefits to current or former employees. Breach of fiduciary duty toward employees covered by plan.

What are the obligations of an employer under ERISA?

Some obligations that ERISA imposes on employers toward their employees include: Providing plan participants with important information such as the major features of the plan and how the plan is financed. Setting up procedures for employee grievances about the plan, as well as an appeals for those grievances.

Does ERISA preempt state law?

Moreover, ERISA preempts any state law that may apply to such plans. This means that if a particular state has a law that covers a pension or insurance plan, and that state law in any way conflicts with ERISA, then the applicable law will be the federal ERISA law, not the state law.

What is an ERISA lien?

ERISA liens are quickly becoming one of the biggest sources of frustration for personal injury attorneys. ERISA is the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974, 29 U.S.C. 1001, et seq. which governs most employee health plans. Many ERISA plans rely on preemption principles to assert that they are under no obligation to reduce their lien ...

What is the saving clause in ERISA?

Insured Plans and the Savings Clause of 29 USC 1144. Generally, federal law governing ERISA plans preempts state law. However, under 29 U.S.C. 1144 (b) (2) (A), referred to by many as the "saving clause," an exception exists to the rule of federal preemption. This clause states that "nothing in this title shall be construed to exempt ...

Do you get a credit for copays?

Importantly, be sure to obtain a credit for co-pays made by your client. These should be subtracted from the total lien claim.

What happens if settlement funds are not a specific source?

If it is not a specific source, i.e. the settlement funds, then it may not fit under the rule set forth in Sereboff.

Can equitable rules trump reimbursement?

While "equitable rules cannot trump a reimbursement provision, they may aid in properly construing it," wrote Justice Kagan. Because US Airways' plan was silent as to allocating attorney's fees, the Court held that the common fund doctrine applied as the default rule.

Does Section 502 (a) (3) override the language of the contract?

It held that in a section 502 (a) (3) reimbursement action under ERISA based on an equitable lien by agreement, the ERISA plan's terms govern, and equitable principles will not override the language of the contract.

What is Section 502 A of ERISA?

Under section 502 (a) (3) of ERISA, a civil action may be brought by a fiduciary to obtain appropriate equitable relief to redress violations of the plan or to enforce any provisions of the subchapter or the terms of the plan. See, 29 U.S.C. Section 1132 (a) (3).