attorney general vs supreme court who is higher rank

by Darryl Wiegand II 9 min read

Who has more power the Attorney General or the Supreme Court?

So really the question is who has more power, the attorney general or a supreme court justice. In the long run, I would early say that the Supreme Court Justice has more power because they will likely be on the bench far far longer then even the president, let alone the Attorney General.

Which is more dangerous the Attorney General or the Chief Justice?

Far more likely that the attorney general could wreak some havoc in your life than the same be said for the Chief Justice. if you are speaking of public opinion the Chief Justice is the big dog.

What is the difference between the AG and the Chief Justice?

Seen in this light, the Chief Justice is the higher position obviously since the CJ heads the entire judicial system whereas the AG is only the principal legal advisor to the government (or a certain ruling po Chief Justice is the highest position in the judicial branch under the legal system.

Why are state attorneys general getting more political?

One possible explanation for state attorneys general becoming more restless and political-minded is the office's rising media profile, which is a function of the rising capacity of the internet and mainstream press to produce and distribute content on controversial cases involving the AGs.

image

Which is higher, the Chief Justice or the AG?

Seen in this light, the Chief Justice is the higher position obviously since the CJ heads the entire judicial system whereas the AG is only the principal legal advisor to the government (or a certain ruling political party only).

What branch is the Attorney General?

The Attorney-General is part of the executive branch. The AG is the government’s chief law officer and legal adviser.

What is the highest post in the judicial system?

Chief Justice is the highest post in the judicial system. Attorney General is the legal advisor to the government which resides in the Execuetive branch. Besides as a legal advisor to the government, the Attorney General also acts as a public prosecutor. Chief Justice and Attorney General resides in different branches of the governing system and there is no comparison in the ranking between the two. Both are appointed by the President of Singapore on concurrence with the advice by the Prime Minister.

What is a state attorney?

State’s Attorney is an attorney representing the state. The duties of the State’s Attorney varies from state to state. In some states, the State’s Attorney is an elected position. The State’s Attorney is responsible for all criminal litigation in a geographical area. The State’s Attorney might also be responsible for providing legal advice to government units within that geographical area. A State’s Attorney for a specific county may handle all criminal cases within the county and provide legal advice to the political unit (such as a County Board) which runs the county.

What is the highest law officer in India?

The Constitution (Article 76 ) has provided for the office of the Attorney General for India. He is the highest law officer of the Country.

How is an attorney general selected?

At the state level, most attorney generals are selected by popular vote. The attorney general provides advice to the governor and the state legislature. S/he is not directly responsible for criminal prosecutions, although s/he may offer assistance in very high profile cases. The attorney general of the state usually reports to the voters of the state.

What is the primary duty of a US attorney?

The US Attorney;s primary duty is criminal and civil litigation. These are the lawyers who do most of the trials for the U.S. Government.

How many states have an attorney general?

The attorney general is appointed by the governor in five states: Alaska, Hawaii, New Hampshire, New Jersey and Wyoming. In Maine, the attorney general is chosen by the state legislature, while in Tennessee the choice falls to the state supreme court .

How does an attorney general influence a state?

Attorneys general exert substantial influence on a state's approach to law enforcement. Attorneys general often set particular law enforcement priorities (e.g. drug law, civil rights violations or sexual crime) and focus extra resources on these issues. This puts them, in the words of the National Association of Attorneys General, at the "intersection of law and public policy." Forty-three states publicly elect their attorneys general, reinforcing the office's relationship with, and direct accountability to, the people, in contrast with the Kings Attorneys of the past, whose singular service to their version of governors must have left those being governed wanting.

Why are state attorneys general restless?

One possible explanation for state attorneys general becoming more restless and political-minded is the office's rising media profile, which is a function of the rising capacity of the internet and mainstream press to produce and distribute content on controversial cases involving the AGs . Another, possible more likely, explanation is the office's status as a springboard to higher office - to the governorship, especially. Nine sitting governors as of November 2013 previously served as attorney general of their respective states:

How many states have no law degree requirements?

Considering the myriad legal responsibilities carried by state attorneys general, it may surprise you to discover that a whopping 19 states have no set statutory or constitutional provisions requiring an individual to hold a law degree, or have a valid license to practice law, in order to serve in the office of attorney general.

How long can an attorney general serve in Tennessee?

1, Tennessee, is appointed by the State Supreme Court to serve a term of eight years. 1, Virginia, has a provision specifying an individual can serve as attorney general for an unlimited number of terms.

How many states require an attorney general to be a citizen?

U.S. citizen. 38 states have a formal provision stating an attorney general must be a United States citizen, while 12 do not have a formal provision. Of the 38 states, 5 specify the number of years and 33 do not.

How many states have a state resident requirement for an attorney general?

1, Oklahoma, sets the limit at 31. 1, Colorado, sets the limit at 27. 1, Mississippi, sets the limit at 26. State Citizen. 43 states have a formal provision stating an attorney general must be a state resident, while 7 do not have a formal provision. Of the 43 states, 24 specify the number of years and 19 do not.

What is an attorney general?

Attorneys-General in common law jurisdictions, and jurisdictions with a legal system which is partially derived from the common law tradition, share a common provenance.

Who is the Attorney General of Australia?

The Attorney-General is the minister responsible for legal affairs, national and public security, and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation. Michaelia Cash is the current Attorney-General.

What is the main legal advisor to the government?

In common law jurisdictions, main legal advisor to the government. In most common law jurisdictions, the attorney general or attorney-general (sometimes abbreviated AG) is the main legal advisor to the government. The plural is attorneys general. In some jurisdictions, attorneys general also have executive responsibility for law enforcement, ...

What is the role of the Attorney General of Kenya?

In Kenya the Attorney General is the Principal Legal Adviser to the Government and ex officio Member of Parliament and Cabinet. His duties include the formulation of legal policy and ensuring proper administration of Kenya's legal system including professional legal education. Assisting the Attorney General in the performance of his duties as Principal Legal Adviser to the Government are:

What is the mission of the Attorney General of Ireland?

The Mission of the Office of the Attorney General is to provide the highest standard of professional legal services to Government, Departments and Offices. The Attorney General of Ireland is the legal adviser to the Government and is therefore the chief law officer of the State.

When was the Attorney General of Tonga established?

The office of Attorney General was established in Tonga in 1988, and was held jointly with the portfolio of Justice Minister until the two were separated in 2009. The Attorney General is defined as the "Chief Legal Advisor to Government".

Who is a power of attorney?

The term was originally used to refer to any person who holds a general power of attorney to represent a principal in all matters. In the common law tradition, anyone who represents the state , especially in criminal prosecutions , is such an attorney.

Who sided with the liberal justices against the other conservatives?

Texas Division, Sons of Confederate Veterans (6/18/15), Thomas sided with the liberal justices against the other conservatives (5-4), approving Breyer’s opinion that the state of Texas was within its rights to reject a specialty license plate featuring an image of the Confederate flag. (See Breyer’s capsule below.)

Who appointed Brett Kavanagh?

7. Brett Kavanagh. Appointed in 2018 by Donald Trump. Rating: Poor. No, I’m not ranking him low for the skeletons in his high-school closet. That was a stupid inquisition. I rank Kavanagh low because he’s not a particularly good justice. But he did write one piece of excellence.

What did Haymond write for the 5-4 majority?

Haymond (6/26/19), he wrote for the 5-4 majority (himself and the four liberals), overturning the lower court’s denial of a trial by jury to a man convicted a second time of carrying child pornography. (Rightfully: a new crime demands a new trial, no matter how despicable the offense.

Who appointed Stephen Breyer?

6. Stephen Breyer. Appointed in 1994 by Bill Clinton. Rating: Decent. Of all the justices, Breyer is sort of just there. He’s not a bad justice, but not especially noteworthy. He’s pragmatic above all, with no axes to grind, and that in itself is good. But he opposes originalism in favor of a more dynamic view of the law, whereas I’m much more originalist. Still, he’s a fair-minded and non-partisan thinker.

Is the Supreme Court correct to uphold Trump's order?

Nonetheless, the conservative majority was correct to uphold Trump ’s order. The Supreme Court has no power to second-guess the president’s executive decisions, no matter how disagreeable, only to decide if the president’s decisions are constitutional or not.

How many nominees have been rated not qualified since 1989?

The table below lists all 22 announced nominees rated not qualified since 1989:

Who is replacing Justice Minton?

Judge William J. Brennan, Jr. to replace Justice Minton. The President had assigned to Attorney General Brownell and the Department of Justice the task of recommending a nominee to meet four specific criteria: an exemplary personal and professional reputation for legal and community leadership; good health; relative youth; and ABA “recognition.” He also expressed a preference for giving most serious consideration to the promotion of an outstanding lower court judge. Brownell ... submitted Brennan’s name to the Federal Bureau of Investigation for a full field investigation and to the ABA Committee for its assessment of professional qualifications. The results of the ABA and FBI investigations were presented to the Attorney General for his consideration and eventual review with the President.

What happens if a committee evaluator recommends a not qualified rating?

If the evaluator intends to recommend a “not qualified” rating, the committee chair appoints a second evaluator to conduct another review, which may include additional interviews with colleagues and another interview with the candidate. The committee then reviews the report (or two reports, if a second investigation was conducted). Each member votes on a rating, with the majority determining the committee’s official rating. A tiebreaker vote goes to the committee chair.

What is the American Bar Association?

The American Bar Association ( ABA) was founded in 1878 by 75 lawyers from 20 states and the District of Columbia. As of 2018, its membership numbered about 400,000 individuals and 3,500 entities. It is a nonprofit 501 (c) (3) organization. The ABA describes its mission as "serving our members, improving the legal profession, eliminating bias and enhancing diversity, and advancing the rule of law throughout the United States and around the world."

How many votes are needed for a majority?

The rating may also be accompanied by the designation of “a majority” (eight to nine votes), a “substantial majority” (10 to 13 votes), or “unanimous.”

How many members are there in the American Bar Association?

The American Bar Association (ABA) was founded in 1878 by 75 lawyers from 20 states and the District of Columbia. As of 2018, its membership numbered about 400,000 individuals and 3,500 entities. It is a nonprofit 501 (c) (3) organization.

What is considered a well qualified nominee?

The nominee must be at the top of the legal profession in his or her legal community; possess outstanding legal ability; breadth of experience; the highest reputation for integrity; and demonstrate the capacity for sound judicial temperament.

What is the difference between the Attorney General and the Solicitor General?

The Attorney General is the chief law officer of the state while the Solicitor General is the Deputy Law officer.

What is the office of the Attorney General?

In the U.S., the Attorney General is also the chief legal adviser to the executive branch of the government. This includes the president, government agencies, departments, and other executive offices. Cases brought against the state or the executive are typically filed in the name of the Attorney General. The Attorney General personally represents the state in legal actions that are of a serious or controversial nature. Furthermore, the person holding office as the Attorney General also serves as the head of the U.S. Department of Justice and a member of the president’s cabinet.

Who is Solicitor General?

Once again, in most common law jurisdictions, the Solicitor General is typically considered the deputy of the Attorney General or the Assistant to the Attorney General. Thus, in jurisdictions such as the U.S. and U.K., the Solicitor General is the second high-ranking law officer in the country , or rather, the second-in-command after the Attorney General. The Solicitor General too represents the government or state in legal actions. In the U.S., the Solicitor General is commonly associated with representing the government or state in federal courtroom proceedings. This means that the Solicitor General represents the Attorney General in court and argues the case on behalf of the state. The Solicitor General and his/her staff prepare for the case by gathering evidence and drafting arguments.

What does the Solicitor General represent?

The Solicitor General too represents the government or state in legal actions. In the U.S., the Solicitor General is commonly associated with representing the government or state in federal courtroom proceedings. This means that the Solicitor General represents the Attorney General in court and argues the case on behalf of the state.

Who represents the state in legal actions?

Cases brought against the state or the executive are typically filed in the name of the Attorney General. The Attorney General personally represents the state in legal actions that are of a serious or controversial nature.

Is the Attorney General more popular than the Solicitor General?

However, the Attorney General is more popular term out of the two. Thus, before proceeding to distinguish the two terms it is important to examine their definitions.

image

Current Officeholders

Qualifications

  • Qualifications for the office of attorney general vary widely from state to state. Minimum age 35 states have a formal provision specifying minimum age, while 15 have no formal provision. Of the 35 states: 1. 7 designate an officeholder must be at least 30 years of age. (FL, ID, KY, NM, NY, PA and VA) 2. 10 require a minimum age of 25. (AL, AZ, GA, IL, LA, MT, NV, ND, UT and WV) 3. 13 re…
See more on ballotpedia.org

Elected vs. Appointed

  • Attorneys general are chosen in four different ways; they are either popularly elected or appointed by the governor, the state legislature, or the state supreme court. The office is elective in 43 states and chosen by a state government organ in seven. The attorney general is appointed by the governor in five states: Alaska, Hawaii, New Hampshire, New Jersey and Wyoming. In Maine, th…
See more on ballotpedia.org

Budgets and Official Compensation

  • Budget
    The difference in budgets for the offices across the states reaches $735,982,631. Nebraska has the smallest budget, spending only $5,795,369 a year on the attorney general's office, while Californiaspends the most with a budget of $741,778,000. This can be because the number of di…
  • Salary
    While the salaries also differ, they do not necessarily coincide with the budgets. While Oregon is on our top five highest budgets chart, the attorney general has the second lowest salary, at $77,200. In fact, of the top five highest budgets, only Washingtonhas a compensation also ranke…
See more on ballotpedia.org

Commentary

  • Among the chief criticisms of the office is that state attorneys general have strayed from their traditional defense-based lawyer role to assume a more proactive and political posture, often in ways that overstep the legal authority of the office and/or what would be historically recognized as the limits of institutional etiquette. In some cases, attorneys general look inward to test the b…
See more on ballotpedia.org

See Also

External Links

  1. Website of the National Association of Attorneys General
  2. The Council of State Governments,"Book of States: Table 4.19 Attorneys General 2013," accessed November 2, 2013
  3. The Council of State Governments,"Attorneys General: Valuing Privacy in the Digital Age," July 1, 2013
  1. Website of the National Association of Attorneys General
  2. The Council of State Governments,"Book of States: Table 4.19 Attorneys General 2013," accessed November 2, 2013
  3. The Council of State Governments,"Attorneys General: Valuing Privacy in the Digital Age," July 1, 2013
  4. The Council of State Governments,"Attorneys General: Pillars of Hope: Attorneys General Unite Against Human Trafficking," July 2, 2012

Overview

In most common law jurisdictions, the attorney general or attorney-general (sometimes abbreviated AG or Atty.-Gen ) is the main legal advisor to the government. The plural is attorneys general. In some jurisdictions, attorneys general also have executive responsibility for law enforcement, prosecutions or even responsibility for legal affairs generally. In practice, the extent to which the attorney general personally provides legal advice to the government varies betwee…

Attorneys-general in common law and hybrid jurisdictions

Attorneys-General in common law jurisdictions, and jurisdictions with a legal system which is partially derived from the common law tradition, share a common provenance.
In Australia, the attorney-general is the chief law officer of the Crown and a member of the Cabinet. The Attorney-General is the minister responsible for legal affairs, national and public security, and the Australian Security Intelligence Organisation. Michaelia Cash is the current Attorney-General. …

Etymology

In regard to the etymology of the phrase Attorney General, Steven Pinker writes that the earliest citation in the Oxford English Dictionary is from 1292: "Tous attorneyz general purrount lever fins et cirrographer" (All general attorneys may levy fines and make legal documents). The phrase was borrowed from Anglo-Norman French when England was ruled by Normans after the conquest of England in the 11th-century. As a variety of French, which was spoken in the law courts, schools, …

Similar offices in non-common law jurisdictions

Non-common law jurisdictions usually have one or more offices which are similar to attorneys-general in common law jurisdictions, some of which use "attorney-general" as the English translation of their titles.
The state attorney (ríkislögmaður) represents the state in civil lawsuits. The state attorney is appointed by the Prime Minister for a period of 5 years and must have the same qualifications re…

External links

• Quotations related to Attorney general at Wikiquote